6 ms·
There are two groups of economists: scientists who predicted that austerity wouldn't work and would make things worse, and quarks (aka the Chicago school) who r
by nl 14y ago
There are two groups of economists: scientists who predicted that austerity wouldn't work and would make things worse, and quarks (aka the Chicago school) who recommended it.
In most areas of science bad ideas don't disappear, it is just that those who support them die and ideas with some evidentiary support become the new norm.
After the response to the 70's oil shocks economists knew that austerity didn't work. Unfortunately measures that are known to work are a political minefield, so those "economists" who don't support it get a lot of support from politicians who don't support it either.
In some ways it is similar to evolution or climate change. You can find "scientists" who deny them both. Economics is worse though, because it is so closely tied to politics.
Incidentally, Krugman has been writing about Iceland since 2010[1].
[1] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/06/30/the-icelandic-post-crisis-miracle/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/06/30/the-icelandic-po...
- tsotha 14y ago>There are two groups of economists: scientists who predicted that austerity wouldn't work and would make things worse, and quarks (aka the Chicago school) who recommended it. Oh please. The idea that you can spend your way out of debt has been shown to be disastrous over and over, and yet like the Marxist "scientists" before them these Neo-Keynesians are going to claim everything is peachy until even the slowest among us can see they're wrong (and not scientists, either). But like any good faith healer they'll say "You didn't do it hard enough". Does that sound familiar? In the short run austerity is painful. In the long run it's the only option, and putting off the pain only makes it worse when you're out of options. Either you do it honestly by cutting expenditures, or you do it the normal way by printing money. The idea you can derive globally applicable lessons from a country the size of Cleveland is a bit daft.
- barrkel 14y agoIf Cleveland had its own currency, you could derive globally applicable lessons. But it doesn't. The "normal way" is much much better than deflationary expenditure cutting. Deflation increases the debt burden in real terms. The underlying reason governments are following austerity is because protecting old people's benefits & pensions (the people on the credit side of the debt, i.e. claims on future production) is more important than growing the economy for young people, because that's how the votes are structured in the economies that matter (Germany in Europe). Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists.
- tsotha 14y agoGoing into endless debt does not grow economies any more than running up your credit cards makes you wealthier. It just gives you the illusion of growth. If you want to see where this leads look at what happens in Japan over the next 12 to 18 months. And anybody who lived through the Carter years understands high inflation is something to be avoided at all costs. It's not a stimulant to the economy, it's a drag. Companies don't know what the real return on their money will be so they don't make investments. >Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists. Nonsense. Politics is very, very, very anti-austerity. Governments do not get smaller without a major upheaval. Look at the UK, where you hear much wailing and gnashing of teeth over "austerity" that's simply a tiny cut in the rate of growth of the budget.
- tankenmate 14y agoProjected cuts of 10% next year on top of the already in the pipeline cuts of 25% would be difficult to sell as "a tiny cut in the _rate of growth_ of the budget". The cuts to government capital expenditure has been largely the cause for the contraction in the construction [1], which has in turn contributed to the UK going back into recession. Borrowing in order to increase sales (taxes in the case of governments) or to decrease costs (increase economic efficiency, spending on infrastructure and the like) is a good idea; both companies and governments do this all the time. Borrowing to spend frivolously is a bad idea no matter who you are. [1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/apr/25/eurozone-crisis-live-uk-double-dip-recession#block-22 http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/apr/25/eurozone-cris...
- tsotha 14y ago>Borrowing in order to increase sales (taxes in the case of governments) or to decrease costs (increase economic efficiency, spending on infrastructure and the like) is a good idea It can be a good idea if the economic activity that results covers the cost of borrowing. But that's not an easy thing to determine, and any rational start to the process tends to get warped by political reality. The fetish for infrastructure spending results in, for example, rail projects that lose ¥32 for every ¥1 they take in: http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/05/20/minispike-the-end-of-the-line/ http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/05/20/minispike-the-end...
- mpweiher 14y ago"The idea that you can spend your way out of debt has been shown to be disastrous over and over," The idea is not that you can spend your way out of debt, that would be silly. The idea is that you can and should spend money to compensate for lack of demand in a recession, because the markets overshoot. Once you are out of recession, you must pay back the debt. So austerity when the economy is good, spending when it is bad. Anti-cyclical government behavior. Austerity in a recession is pro-cyclical. As was predicted and Greece (for example) has shown, a government cannot save itself out of debt in a recession, because tanking the economy at a crucial time like that makes the debt worse (as percent of GDP, and that's the crucial number in terms of ability to repay). Update: I am German, "living within your means" is sort of part of my DNA, and not living within your means is going to cause problems. But timing does matter!
- treerock 14y agoTotally agree. But then the question becomes, what do you do when countries actually increase spending and debt when the economy is good, and therefore have nothing to spend when the bad times arrive. The main distinction between Iceland and Ireland is that Iceland can print its own money. In the UK it seems that 'nasty' parties that advocate spending cuts in the good times get voted out of office, and replaced by parties that increase spending. So it becomes less a question of economics and more one of politics. For the moment Germany might see "living within your means" part of the DNA, but few other countries do. And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened.
- mpweiher 14y ago"But then the question becomes, what do you do when countries actually increase spending and debt when the economy is good, and therefore have nothing to spend when the bad times arrive." "So it becomes less a question of economics and more one of politics." Precisely. And all the western countries have been guilty of this, the only difference is that of degree. Which is why debt has generally only crept up and politics has slowly but surely ceded sovereignty to the banks, especially in Europe where new currency is apparently only created via commercial banks (unlike the US, which just prints it). "And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened." As far as I can tell that's the current political struggle, especially between the North and South.
- othermaciej 14y agoEstonia and Latvia are doing pretty well with austerity: <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-07-19/krugmenistan-vs-dot-estonia> http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-07-19/krugmenistan...; It's understandable that regular readers of Krugman may not know this since he goes to great pains to deny the obvious on this point.
- tsotha 14y agoYes, and Japan, the country he's held out as a great Keynesian success in the past, is going over the falls right before our eyes: http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/12/kyle-bass-on-end-of-debt-supercycle.html http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/12/kyle-bass...
- brc 14y agoI'm glad you were the one to point out that Krugman has become so fixated with denying the obvious that it has become embarrassing. Continually pointing out that Japan hasn't get gone broke isn't much of a defense when their economy - once the envy of the world - has completed two decades of stagnation and shows no signs of recovery. Had Japan done a Iceland-style cleanout, they would probably be still striking fear into the hearts of governments and corporates everywhere.
- gregsq 14y agoExcept for one complication. Japan's public debt is largely owed to it's own citizens, such a large proportion being internal debt. Even if they defaulted on the external component, they'd still have a problem of the type Iceland could avoid. Iceland wrote off banking debt, which was something like 70% of their external debt.
- twoodfin 14y agoI don't think the term you want is "write off". Creditors write off debt. Borrowers default.
- 14y ago
- brc 14y agoNo economist calls themselves a scientist. They call themselves economists. The term 'austerity' is meant to apply to a government living within its means. These days it is applied to a government with single digit debt growth instead of double-digit growth. Kind of like how eating balanced meals is now called dieting. It's true that you can avoid unemployment by borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again. What is also true is that, without production there is no consumption. Digging up holes and filling them in is not production, ergo, consumption will not rise. TLDR; J.B. Say was right. Keynes was wrong.
- tankenmate 14y agoAnd yet all the countries that have slashed government spending and backstopped private debt have also taken a nose dive in GDP. Eppur si muove. TLDR; Keynes advocated government spending on infrastructure (increased collective efficiency) not pointless hole filling.
- Tichy 14y agoHere is why this government spending recommendation is just a head fake: assuming the economy can be in a functional state at all, it is obviously true that if the government would spend money on the right things, it could create a functional economy. The real problem of economics however is resource allocation, or in this case, what should the government spend the money on. The proponents of government spending don't give any details - they don't solve the problem at all. They just market themselves as prophets by spouting trivial truths (spending money on the right things is good). You'll answer "spending money on infrastructure" but that is not good enough. Even for roads there is a point when enough is enough (imagine every square meter of the country covered in roads). To fix the economy, you have to devise a mechanism of efficient resource allocation. Just saying "let the government decide" is not an answer.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoPut simply, you are outright lying. Advocates of Keynesian spending advocate its usage for public goods and commons goods, the two known categories where "the government" is clearly more efficient than markets. Does that mean no decisions remain in the realm of politics and everything turns into a technocratic utopia run by Economics majors? No. But that's because in any case there is no such thing as an apolitical economic policy of any kind. All of it, right down the property laws themselves, is political. In fact, it's generally the very core of politics.
- Tichy 14y agoThe scary thing about Krugman is that his whole ideology seems to depend on that example of one babysitting exchange ring that didn't print enough money and therefore couldn't trade. It's an interesting story, but I wouldn't simply translate it to whole economies of nations. I can think of a lots of other factors that might have made the babysitting ring fail.