5 ms·
Thanks for the very informative comment. I also recognize that a lot of people's understanding of food is scarcely more rigorous than cargo cult rituals, but a
by nitrogen 14y ago
Thanks for the very informative comment. I also recognize that a lot of people's understanding of food is scarcely more rigorous than cargo cult rituals, but a few points seem a bit unclear to me.
...It's not like the bacteria cause obesity as some articles suggest, their presence is itself a symptom of a nutritional problem (such as too much intake)....
How do you square this with the claim from the original article that giving mice a toxin produced by gut bacteria (Lipopolysaccharide endotoxin) causes obesity and insulin resistance, and that "[m]ono-association of germfree C57BL/6J mice with strain Enterobacter cloacae B29 isolated from the volunteer’s gut induced fully developed obesity and insulin resistance on a high-fat diet but not on normal chow diet, whereas the germfree control mice on a high-fat diet did not exhibit the same disease phenotypes"?
It's not "evil complex polysaccharides" wreaking havoc and producing energy out of thin air to make people fat, it's (as always) people eating too much who are bringing this upon themselves.
Why, then, do some people become obese when they eat as their instincts tell them, and others do not? For example, I eat whenever I'm hungry, stop when I'm full (or even overfilled), snack frequently while working (mostly nuts, dried fruits, and sometimes Fritos), and yet remain thin, while others eat carefully and remain obese. What's the difference?
- Udo 14y ago> How do you square this with the claim from the original article [...] I think the article makes some dubious claims, mostly centered around a single human volunteer (!), using a mice experiment to back that up - I'll remain skeptical until it can be reproduced by another team. The inclusion of Traditional Chinese Medicine alone as playing a key role to curing the condition is a huge tipoff that something is amiss. But even taking all those doubts into consideration, let's entertain the hypothesis that this bacterium does produce signals that make a person eat more. It's possible. But you still acquire the bacterium by eating too much in the first place. It simply couldn't colonize you if you didn't. > Why, then, do some people become obese when they eat as their instincts tell them, and others do not? My personal opinion is there are two big factors. First, lifestyle. People eat too much because that's simply how they live their lives. It may be because they only have access to high-calorie food, or because everybody around them eats too much, or because they have made a habit of eating too much. The second group (which I'm a part of) is worse: for them, food is an addiction. Many of them may already eat "healthy", high-quality stuff - so moving away from fast food does nothing for them. Eating simply has the same effect on them as drugs do on other people.
- Mz 14y agoYou do not acquire bacterium by eating too much. You acquire them by being exposed to them -- kissing the wrong person, sitting beneath a contaminated window air conditioner blowing on you, etc. Yes, they then need to colonize you to become a big problem. You have zero evidence to support your claim that eating too much is a prerequisite for their ability to colonize you.
- Udo 14y agoI already outlined the mechanism in my first post. Kissing and ACs are not the reason you get these organisms inside you. They are already everywhere. Just by moving through life, you're exposed to a huge variety of enterobacteriae. You wouldn't believe how everything is just covered with E. coli, for example. It's not a matter of staying away from dirty surfaces, or of wiping everything down with disinfectant. These organisms are omnipresent, and it's normal for them to live inside your gut as well. In fact, the majority of them are endosymbionts, and are regulated by their environment. This means whatever comes into your colon determines which bacteria get to thrive on it. This is not my claim, it's basic biology. I invite you to do the following experiment at home. Get yourself a petri dish and fill it with sterile Agar. Then wash your hands. After that, make some fingerprints in the Agar. Incubate for a few days. You'll be surprised.
- Mz 14y agoOh, I am very well aware that germs, fungus etc are rampant. But you have to be exposed to a specific one to catch that specific one. There has to be a vector, whether it is a dirty surface or another person or something else. Your view amounts to "vague miasma -- no specific source", which is a view that annoys me. It came from somewhere. It didn't just magically pop into existence from the ether because "you ate too much". I really don't know how to discuss this with you. You blame everything on "behavior" then claim to have a food addiction. Your view strikes me as rather handwavy, while dismissing a possible specific cause for some individuals: exposure to a pathogen. This is not the first time I have heard this, so I doubt that there is only one study. No, I likely cannot convince you of anything. But you are equally failing to convince me.
- DanBC 14y ago> Why, then, do some people become obese when they eat as their instincts tell them, and others do not? For example, I eat whenever I'm hungry, stop when I'm full (or even overfilled), snack frequently while working (mostly nuts, dried fruits, and sometimes Fritos), and yet remain thin, while others eat carefully and remain obese. What's the difference? I really really want to see good quality food diaries for people who claim to eat little but not lose weight. I'd also want to see how much exercise they do. (And not even actual exercise, just how much they move around during the day.)