11 ms·
The TSA's True Focus Isn't Safety - It's Self-Preservation
- Shivetya 14y agoat times I wonder if this is not the unwritten goal of many agencies. We have an incredible duplication of effort on the part of many aid agencies and no progress is usually attempted to weed that out, how would we even begin with this one?
- pavel_lishin 14y agoSee Pournelle's Iron Law of Bureaucracy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bureaucracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bur... In any bureaucracy, the people devoted to the benefit of the bureaucracy itself always get in control and those dedicated to the goals the bureaucracy is supposed to accomplish have less and less influence, and sometimes are eliminated entirely.
- lani 14y agoalso, John Gall's Systemantics - First Principles - : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics 'Once a system is set up to solve some problem, the system itself is new entity which engenders new problems relating the development, operations, and maintenance of that system'
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoThis is why these hit pieces are completely unfair to the TSA. Just about every organization becomes self-preserving as its primary function. Government and non-profit are the most obvious but the bureaucracy of for-profit companies and even individual divisions inside of those companies follow the same rules. I was just looking over the recent Android handsets via tmobile and was shocked at the nightmare of tacked-on apps and other carrier garbage on them. All these divisions in t-mobile are trying to justify their existence by dropping various apps on the handsets like music managers, music stores, t-mobile tv, AV, security, etc etc. No one wants or needs these and the few that do will find them in the play store. Look at well run companies like Apple or Google. The iphone and the Nexus have none of this junk. I imagine their corporate culture is a lot less bureaucratic than that of a carrier like tmobile. >in any bureaucratic organization there will be two kinds of people: those who work to further the actual goals of the organization, and those who work for the organization itself. I like to think Apple and Google are the former and carriers in the latter.
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> Just about every organization becomes self-preserving as its primary function. But when they prioritize self-preservation over their intended goal, that's bad.
- jonnathanson 14y agoI think the real issue arises in organizations where self-preservation is actually at odds with, or at least orthogonal to, the organization's stated goal. Take the TSA, for instance (and many government agencies, departments within large corporations, nonprofits, etc.). The supposed goal of the TSA is to efficiently and effectively protect travelers and the country from criminal and terrorist actions. In theory, if the TSA is doing its job well, it's actually reducing budgetary needs and slashing fat in favor of efficiency. The TSA should be trying to become clever and nimble, moreso than massive and overhead-burdened. But the self-preservation mandate suggests the opposite. Self-preservation, for a government agency, means making sure you preserve or grow your budget year over year -- because you're fighting other agencies for it. Every dollar you get is up for grabs by other agencies next fiscal, and vice versa. Accordingly, becoming expensive and inefficient works in favor of self-preservation. As any seasoned bureaucrat knows, not achieving results means asking for more money to throw at the problem. If the TSA demonstrated that it was achieving its goals at current budget levels, it wouldn't receive the same budget next year. Or even face a budgetary reduction.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoI think most people are resigned to the existence of bureaucracies, despite such problems as rent-seeking, inefficiency, etc, as long as they meet a few basic criteria: (1) they serve some reasonably obvious positive purpose (2) the negative effects of what they do aren't too noxious, in particular when compared with (1) The TSA, it would seem basically fails on both points. Despite the good intentions with which it was formed, it's pretty clear that they don't improve safety in any significant manner (you might find people some disagree about this, because they believe the security theater, but I think the number is dropping). The negative effects of their existence, of course, are legion, (I suspect it's quite hard to find anybody that disagrees on this point!). So I'd suggest the public probably on average doesn't support the TSA to the same degree they might other bureaucracies, even those that they find annoying. Unfortunately, of course, the public's opinion on the matter is of little importance once the system is in place...
- cdooh 14y agoWhile the TSA is messed up and all that, Americans shouldn't be too quick to turn to private companies. Private companies would be profit focused, this means that any way to minimise costs will be taken which may compromise security. I give you Blackwater in Iraq as a good example
- bcoates 14y agoI think when most people ask for "private companies" they mean cheaper, less intrusive security theater, in the pre-2001 vein.
- Firehed 14y agoThe pre-2001 screening was perfectly fine, and would still work today (maybe excepting the improvements to detecting plastic explosives, although I imagine that screening would have picked up the detonators just fine). The other major improvement to security was locking, reinforced cockpit doors, which should have been the standard on all commercial aircraft from the start. What went wrong during 9/11 was that passengers assumed that a hijacking was a financially-motivated detour, rather than a political/religious attack on our ways of life (and prior to that day, there was no reason to assume otherwise). As such, there was very little resistance to the hijackers as people didn't want to get cut by a relatively small knife. Had they had even the faintest idea that failure to resist could have resulted in what happened, you can say with 100% confidence that things would have gone down differently. Basically, that trick was good once and once only, regardless of the change in security policy that it brought about. And let's face it - only an idiot would try that again; there are targets with far higher value (and probably much more exploitable security flaws) if someone wanted to send a message again.
- gknoy 14y ago> only an idiot would try that again; there are targets with far higher value (and probably much more exploitable security flaws) if someone wanted to send a message again. Specifically, the large gatherings of tightly-clustered people waiting at a security checkpoint are much more vulnerable than any plane full of passengers.
- jcromartie 14y agoThis is true of every institution.
- swombat 14y agoSo the TSA is like some kind of rogue AI just "tryin' to survive" - except that unlike an AI, it's incredibly stupid on a massive scale. Doesn't bode well for our chances of fighting a real intelligent AI when it finally creeps up on us.
- indiecore 14y agoWhy fight it? I for one embrace our AI overlord, maybe we can finally have the philosopher king we need.
- adpowers 14y agoI flew yesterday and found a rifle bullet+cartridge on the "secure" side of the TSA checkpoint. Yet somehow the gift-wrapped paperbacks in my checked luggage were deemed suspicious and unwrapped. Useless fools.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoWhat do you mean "found"? You mean you accidentally left it in your luggage, or you just sort of found it laying outside a book store?
- adpowers 14y agoIt was sitting on the ground at the end of the table where you collect your belongings and repack your laptop. I showed it to TSA agent and went on my way.
- frig8 14y agoYou know, it's not entirely unreasonable that someone could package a bomb to look like a gift-wrapped paperback. So if their technology can't distinguish your book from a potential explosive via X-rays alone, it may have to get opened. Explosives detection results in false alarms, unfortunately, but as far as I know most countries do it and it rarely results in such inconvenience to passengers. The rifle cartridge is obviously on their contraband list, so it should have been caught. Someone probably brought it through accidentally. .22 LR?
- mseebach 14y agoMy SO once bought a small blender (less the blade) through in her hand luggage - I understand and respect why they asked to take a closer look at that. But if a bomb is indistinguishable from a paperback, then a bomb is indistinguishable from a bag full of clothes. Which means that the current level of security is woefully inadequate and only by opening up all luggage and carefully sifting through every one inch layer of material can we find hidden bombs. Rather, this seems like a perfect example of the self-perpetuation suggested in the article. It takes a while, so there's a line, it look very meticulous and the victim isn't going to complain, or he might risk finding himself on a do-not-fly or do-harass list.
- ianstallings 14y agoThis is true of almost every government entity.
- ceejayoz 14y agoThis is true of almost every entity.
- ScottBurson 14y agoDelete "almost".
- stcredzero 14y agoSome entities are truly crazy.
- mseebach 14y agoProbably, yes. But at least private entities can be (and frequently are) killed by customers starving them of their income - this can happen passively by simply not buying their products anymore. Public sectors ones need politicians to actively invest political capital in not just removing it, but figuring out what it was meant to do in the first place, how to do it better and then setup a new entity that's better - so there's very high friction to take on the task. Obviously, also, anyone who takes on TSA opens himself up to being labeled "soft on national security". Of course, there are many anemic private companies that are kept alive for various reasons long beyond their reasonable lifetime, but generally this holds. Private companies come and go much faster than public sector ones. That said, I'm not sure airport security is necessarily a good fit for a private company.
- ianstallings 14y agoI think a good example to point to would be Pinkerton security, which for example guards some military bases when needed for things like air shows. They are highly trained at security. The TSA seems to hire almost anyone that is breathing and hasn't been to prison. They seem completely unconcerned with security and more concerned with being rule-bent weirdos.
- codex 14y agoHN has quite an anti-TSA bias. The TSA has problems, but so does every large organization. I suspect HN'ers glare at the TSA because they travel frequently, and it would benefit them disproportionately to cut down on travel time and inconvenience. This is like the trucking lobby arguing for fewer restrictions on driver safety--the perspective is not exactly objective.
- cwp 14y agoThat. Or, perhaps, the TSA is objectively awful. Tell you what. Post an article that sings the praises of the TSA and I'll upvote it. Then we can have a discussion about bias.
- codex 14y agoA fair point. I spent only about 30 seconds on this, but found: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4943959 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4943959, "Surprise Gallup Poll: People Think TSA Does A Good Job". This is a poor article: it's merely reporting on a public poll of the TSA. I didn't expect the public to be so approving; I expected views of TSA to be like views on taxes: they're necessary, but everybody still hates them. But perhaps the public is so scared of terrorists on planes that the TSA is comforting to them. It's not a report on TSA efficacy, but I didn't look for one; such a report is would not be worth much due to the difficulty of proving a negative: the TSA's objective is not to find 100% of contraband, but to prevent terrorist attacks. There have been no terrorist attacks (excepting the shoe bomber, but there have been no shoe attacks since shoes started to be inspected), but does that prove the TSA is effective? Hard to say. EDIT: I submitted two more articles: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4944165 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4944165 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4944163 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4944163 Still no upvotes, though.
- mseebach 14y ago> There have been no terrorist attacks (excepting the shoe bomber, but there have been no shoe attacks since shoes started to be inspected), but does that prove the TSA is effective? Hard to say. No, really, it's not. Of prevented terror attacks since 9/11, TSA has prevented exactly 0% of them. The shoe bomber was on the plane with the bomb when he was subdued by fellow passengers. The underwear bomber also made it onto the flight. Only for 2011, but you can bet the TSA wouldn't let you forget if they actually caught a terrorist: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/01/the_tsa_proves.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/01/the_tsa_proves...
- DodgyEggplant 14y agoEvery organization tends to preserve the problem it should solve (don't remember the source, sorry)
- pmb 14y agoThe whole trick of designing institutions is to make sure that when they act for their own self-preservation (as they will and do) they will simultaneously be achieving the goal we want them to be achieving.
- betterunix 14y agoSo what is the TSA's goal with airport security?
- joshuahedlund 14y agoHow do you design institutions to correct for this, anyway? In general, if you set up an institution to solve a problem, there is an incentive not to actually solve the problem because it would eliminate the need for the institution's existence...
- Firehed 14y agoSo, ensure that organizations that fail to achieve their goal go away? This isn't complicated: if you want to keep your job, you need to do it, and meet some sort of standard in doing so. The problem is we've somehow managed to create organizations that continue to exist even when they completely fail to accomplish the intended tasks. Once your method of self-preservation shifts from "functioning" to "lobbying", the whole thing needs to be dismantled. The TSA is fortunate in that they have other people lobbying on their behalf, but that doesn't change the fact that they exist due to legislation rather than effectiveness.
- r00fus 14y agoThe TSA has acheived this goal, if by "we" you mean the military/security industrial complex that employs millions and costs tax payers trillions.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWhy do people accept this reality when talking about the TSA, but not other government agencies? All government agencies are like this, especially the Federal ones.
- Firehed 14y agoThe TSA is more actively harmful to the freedoms we (supposedly) cherish, and is a strong push towards a surveillance society and a police state. Many other agencies are equally unproductive (or actually do something useful, just in a very inefficient manner), but not actively working against something we care about.
- chernevik 14y agoThe TSA is more _obviously_ harmful. And many other agencies aren't _actively_ working against things we care about -- that is, obstruction per se isn't generally their goal. But they're still obstructive just the same.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoThe TSA is also extremely visible in the public's eye. How many people do you know that have complained that the CIA was spying on them, vs. how many people do you know who have complained that they got government-groped?
- fennecfoxen 14y agoI take it you don't care about a quasi-reasonable budget, the kind without a deficit of ~1/3. Or about the economic growth lost when tax dollars siphon it out of the broader economy. (Or even away from alternative quasi-productive government infrastructure projects.) Unsurprising, really; there are entire political parties based on the premise of not caring about those things, and in many countries. ;)
- mahyarm 14y agoThe TSA is a pet issue of the upper-middle class because they annoy and harass them frequently and they are an easy and relatively safe way to push back against a police style authority. They're a figurehead of what was lost after 9/11. The TSA is also an obvious waste. They aren't that much different before hand although, their function were covered by a hodgepodge of regulations usually dictated by the FAA and private airport security employed at airports US wide. The upper-middle class tends to set the agenda for the media in general. They're also the archetype of what are depicted in TV shows and so on. Why the recent school shooting became a national outrage is probably because they were a middle class school. The death toll also added to it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wallawe 14y agoWelcome to America's permanent big government state. This is a prime example of excessive government bureaucracy, and it demonstrates how inefficient and wasteful many of these govt. programs are but exist anyway to keep politicians happy. The only reason TSA is getting called out for its unnecessary bloat is because the public despises what they do.
- rayiner 14y agoThe size of the federal bureaucracy has hovered around 2m +/- 10% for the last 50 years, even as the U.S. population has increased by over 70%.
- wallawe 14y agoI highly doubt the employee headcount of the federal government is a good indicator of efficiency. I would say not at all. There could be 10 total government employees but that wouldn't signify more well-oiled machine. My initial assertion stands true. The government is bloated, inefficient, and wasteful (now more than ever). TSA is merely a good microcosm for the system as a whole. Side note: it's appreciated (expected?) to provide sources when throwing out stats.
- rayiner 14y agoRe: source, see: http://www.opm.gov/feddata/html/ExecBranch.asp http://www.opm.gov/feddata/html/ExecBranch.asp I think the headcount of the bureaucracy, relative to the size of the country being managed, is a very relevant metric of the efficiency of the system. I mean after all, in a private company it would be pretty impressive if the company nearly doubled in size without adding substantially to the number of managers. The point isn't that the federal government isn't large, it's that it's a complete mispreception to assert that the TSA is a good microcosm of the federal government. The TSA is a traditional bloated bureaucracy, with tons of government employees doing not much of anything. That's not what most of the federal government looks like. I've worked in a federal agency and in the private sector, and if anything the federal agency was better run and more leanly staffed. In reality, 95% of federal expenditures are just checks to other people. Checks to farmers to subsidize agriculture, checks to states to subsidize highway construction, Social Security checks, Medicare reimbursement checks, etc. The fact is that people rant up and down about how bloated the federal government is, but nobody can ever point to non-trivial ways to reduce spending. And the reason is that it's not a matter of simply firing a bunch of bureaucrats that sit on their ass doing nothing--there just aren't very many of those people. Rather, it's all about not writing those checks. Writing a $20 billion check to subsidize suburban commuters instead of $40 billion, cutting grandma's social security check by 20%, etc. That's where all the money goes.
- makmanalp 14y agoLink to cut through the blogspam to actual Govt Accountability Office report: http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/650364.pdf http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/650364.pdf
- nollidge 14y agoI don't think it's "blogspam" to summarize and contextualize a dry government report.
- indiecore 14y agoI paid extra to not fly though the US. I encourage other North Americans who can to avoid it to do similarly.
- dpeck 14y agoThe <organization of any sort> True Focus isn't <organizations purported purpose> - It's Self-Preservation
- smsm42 14y agoSo they think patting down 5-year-old girls and 90-year-old grandmas and grabbing my testicles each time I have to fly - not actually making the country more secure? Banning cupcakes and handbags with gun-shaped emboidery is actually not protecting us from terrorists? I can't believe it...
- rz2k 14y agoThe TSA is clearly flawed, but I'm happy that planting bombs on oblivious children and elderly is an ineffective tactic.
- smsm42 14y agoWas it ever?
- jinushaun 14y agoWhere can I sign up for free testicle grabs? This is not the TSA I know.
- smsm42 14y agoIt's not free, it costs over 8 billion a year. In my tax bracket, that's about $180 a year for me. Of course, for more affluent folks it's more, reaching into thousands for highest income levels. As for the questions where you can sign up - I'm sure there are fine establishments around which for a modest sum of money can fulfill some of your fantasies. I can't help you with that though, as my expertise with such matters is limited to rumors and hearsay.
- jasonkolb 14y agoNow why isn't this sort of thing talked about during campaigns?
- forgotAgain 14y agoBecause campaigns are run for the good of the candidate, not the good of the country or the people. If the campaign thought that promising to fix the TSA would be a net positive to attaining their goal of winning the election then they would do so. The same analysis explains why very few important issues are discussed, and why even then, they are spoken of in a series of talking points previously gauged to insure a net positive result.
- frozenport 14y agoThe TSA is consistently on the Republican agenda and the Democrats have a hard time laying people off.
- stcredzero 14y agoTSA: Out to photograph and grope your ass while covering their own.
- orthecreedence 14y agoThis is not unique to the TSA, or bureaucracies in general, but more the universe. Every dynamic system feels the desire to grow and preserve itself.
- michaelbrave 14y agothis reminds me of another article written a little while ago http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-11-18/how-airport-security-is-killing-us http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-11-18/how-airport-... which discussed how it is incredibly less safe to drive than to fly (even with terrorist attacks) and that the increased security of the TSA is making more people drive instead, which has caused a lot more accidents and deaths because of it. both interesting.
- epsylon 14y agoIn other words, the TSA is a self-licking ice-cream cone. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-licking_ice_cream_cone
- beloch 14y agoThe TSA is good for a variety of business interests. One specific example is the manufacturers of back-scatter X-Ray machines. They're hideously expensive and pure security theater but, in large part thanks to the TSA, they're in most U.S. airports now. How would you like to own a company that makes a product that doesn't actually have to work in order for you to gross billions? Now, if this bothers you, you should probably pay attention to the fact that the market for these toys is expanding. Rapidly. http://www.propublica.org/article/drive-by-scanning-officials-expand-use-and-dose-of-radiation-for-security-s http://www.propublica.org/article/drive-by-scanning-official... You know when you're about to step through one of these scanners at an airport, but now one can drive right past you in your car without your knowledge! Despite their lack of concrete results in airports, the back-scatter X-Ray machine market is exploding into new form-factors, and it's all thanks to U.S. taxpayer dollars. The horrible punch-line to this is that these back-scatter vans face an almost impossible task. It's hard enough to tell bombs from batteries in the controlled setting of a an airport security check-stop. Imagine trying to distinguish bombs from the random things people keep in their cars! The crews operating these vans must generate so many false-positives that, in order to reach the point where they can actually provide some real measure of security, they would need to be supremely competent, supremely dedicated, and entrusted with extraordinary powers to search suspicious vehicles. All of the above are improbable. I will eat my shorts the first time one of these back-scatter vans actually finds a real car-bomb.
- epoxyhockey 14y agoThe image of the RadPRO SecurPASS in that link is outrageous with respect to actively exposing individuals to x-ray radiation. Inmates are x-rayed every time they return from work detail. Why do we have to learn the lesson over and over again that x-ray radiation causes cancer? I hate the arguments that it only hurts us a little bit each time.