6 ms·
There Is Never a Need to Justify Sharing Culture and Knowledge
- rayiner 14y agoI don't think you have a right to "share" episodes of Veronica Mars. The justification for sharing "culture" is dramatically diminished, in my opinion, when that "culture" is purely commercial. There are a huge number of artists willing to share their culture for free, yet sites like Pirate Bay seem nonetheless to be filled with commercial "culture" not created for the sake of culture itself, but for the sake of profit, and not intended to be shared.
- jivatmanx 14y agoWhat about Hemingway, T.S. Elliot, etc? Practically any copyrighted material still being consumed after, say, 30 years is of significant cultural interest.
- rayiner 14y agoI don't think there is any good reason to have a copyright term longer than 30 years.
- sp332 14y agoThe reason would be to incentivize people to make things which are valuable for more than 30 years. What's the point of making something of lasting value if someone else can just take it after 30 years?
- yungchin 14y ago> What's the point of making something of lasting value if > someone else can just take it after 30 years? Is that really what scholars of behavioural economy and human psychology would tell us motivates makers to make things?
- sp332 14y agoNot really, but it is the stated purpose of copyright in the USA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States#Purpose_of_copyright https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St...
- mtgx 14y agoCopyright was supposed to be 14 years - not 30, and not 100. Your argument doesn't make sense. You can make something of extreme value and still be able to make a lot of money on it for 14 years. Don't forget copyright was also supposed to return the works into public domain. Don't think of it just frm the point of view of an author. Piracy has arisen as "competition" to the much crippled copyright system.
- sp332 14y agorayiner said "I don't think there is any good reason to have a copyright term longer than 30 years." The reason for having a 30 year term would be the same as the reasons for having a 14 year term. Of course the tradeoffs would move around a bit and it's debatable whether there would be a net gain or loss.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoI'm confused. Are you suggesting that since rayiner doesn't think there is a good reason to have the copyright last longer than 30 years then there is no good reason for it to last longer than 14 years... therefore there is no need for copyright at all? I'm not sure the point you are trying to make. Among those that feel copyright has its use, there is going to be differing opinions of just how long that copyright should be. But I think that group would all agree it should be greater than 0 (or else they would not be in that "copyright is useful" group at all). Maybe I'm just misunderstanding your argument. If so, I apologize.
- sp332 14y ago
- jivatmanx 14y agoThe traditional argument for a copyright of "Limited Terms", in the constitution, is that it makes it possible for artists to make a living, terms. Clearly 30 years is adequate for that - only a very small number of works even get consumed after that time. However, you're arguing that an artist has a "natural right" to their work, Forever. And that if it ever enters public domain and is used, it's users are thieves. (it's only possible to "take it" if copyright is considered a natural right)
- sp332 14y agoyou're arguing that an artist has a "natural right" to their work No, I'm not. Forever Definitely not. it's only possible to "take it" if copyright is considered a natural right You can take something that is public property, like a flower from a national park.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- muuh-gnu 14y ago> I don't think you have a right to "share" But you should. > when that "culture" is purely commercial. You dont need a justification at all. You want to share with your fellow people, thats it. People love other people and love to share things they have with them. Sharing is caring. Suppressing that inherently human feeling and urge simply to make somebody make more money is insane. The problem with the whole copyright debate is that the so called "democracy", aka will of the people, is completely and utterly disregarded. The process of law making is completely and utterly driven by special interests and enforced against all public resistence from top down. The issue of copyright is closed up in a dictatorship bubble and fiercely guarded against democracy. The people, and _only_ the people (like in a direct referendum) should decide what they value more: their natural, human right to share useful information with their fellow humans, or to collectively enforce a kind of for-profit censorship in order to incentivize commercial production. No single authority should be able to make such a far-reaching and intrusive decision for them. Such a referendum has never been held, and therefore such laws are undemocratic, and for that single reason alone I and a lot of other people do not feel obliged to obey copyright laws. It is as simple as that. Requirig people to obey and respect copyright restrictions simply because some special interest calls it a law makes as sense as requiring them to obey and respect ius primae noctis only because some special interest calls it a law. To be respected, a law has to be widely agreed upon, and copyright is as widely agreed upon as ius primae noctis.
- rayiner 14y agoIf we're talking about natural human tendencies, I'd argue that any supposed "urge to share" is weaker than the evident urge to control the products of one's own labor. People who know nothing about intellectual property still get extremely upset when they perceive that someone else "stole their idea" or "ripped them off." Also, claiming the copyright regime is not the product of democracy is utterly ludicrous. If people cared so much about this "natural right to share" they would vote out the people who pass restrictive copyright legislation. But they don't. Claiming that the results of the democratic process are in fact not democratic for various hand-wavey reasons is the last-ditch argument of people who don't like the outcome of the democratic process because it didn't come out their way.
- subsystem 14y agoYou missed the point of the post. If sharing would be the default then the work in question would only be restricted as long as the commercial interest (not the "moral" one) was strong enough to warrant such a restriction. So whatever cultural importance a work would have is irrelevant, since it's the restriction that should be motivated and not the other way around. I also think it's a strange argument since there aren't, in most countries, any distinction in copyright between works of cultural importance and other works.
- thomaslangston 14y agoWilliam Shakespeare's plays were commercial endeavors.
- betterunix 14y ago"not created for the sake of culture itself, but for the sake of profit, and not intended to be shared." Are we supposed to care about the intention of the creators? By putting the creators' intentions first, you are promoting commercialized culture -- you are turning pieces of the culture into an exploitable asset. When commercial entertainment is shared, we get non-commercial entertainment. Sometimes it is silly, like the OVER 9000 videos on Youtube. Sometimes it is artistic, like remixes of hit songs. If we want to have a culture that is not controlled by profiteering gluttons, we need to ignore their wishes when it comes to sharing the entertainment they create; otherwise, they will always drown out whatever culture might emerge on its own (as they do today).
- rayiner 14y agoI referenced the intentions of creators not to argue that we should give effect to their wishes, but because intention helps us distinguish "knowledge and culture" from "entertainment."
- betterunix 14y agoWould you say that Moby Dick is not part of American culture? How about Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow? Where do you even draw the line? Entertainment, even utter crap (Moby Dick was originally considered terrible), is still part of our culture.
- scotty79 14y agoI have a cool story to tell you. It's called "Spiderguy". But you have to pay me first. Also once I tell you the story you can't tell it to anyone else. You can just tell them about it. Also if you don't pay me and anyone else will offer to tell you this story then no matter how curious you are you should stick fingers into your ears and not listen to it. Or I'll sue ya. What do you say?
- VikingCoder 14y agoThat sounds great - as long as the story you tell is compelling, and you do it in a way that captivates and surprises me. I support art. If it turns out that your depiction of Spiderguy sucked, I'm less likely to support you in the future. If you want to share your toys, I think that makes you awesome. But if you don't want to share your toys, I don't think you should have to.
- scotty79 14y agoHow do you feel about me suing you for not sticking fingers into you ears when someone else is telling the story and you listen to it because of your curiosity I instigated?
- VikingCoder 14y agoYour scenario isn't remotely real.
- scotty79 14y agoIf I, due to curiosity induced by advertisers of Spiderman go to piratebay and download it (which is as easy and natural as listening in when someone else is telling some story) I can get sued.
- VikingCoder 14y agoYou are aware of the laws of the country you live in. You can ignore those laws, but you may suffer the consequences. No matter what the laws are, no matter if you think they are right or not. There's no mystery involved in this. We can debate whether the laws should change, and that's fine. But you can't claim that you "innocently overheard" my telling of a story - in your scenario, you are actively violating the law. So go find another story teller - one who won't sue you. It's not like it's hard to find them. Don't like the quality as much? So, sponsor the community that won't sue you. Do a Kickstarter. Use Flattr. Share on FB or G+ interesting artists.
- jstanley 14y agoI agree with most of what the article says, with one exception: "We don’t determine what civil liberties our children get based on who can make money and who can’t; we base them on what our parents fought and bled for." Lots of people fought and bled over lots of issues, but the act of fighting and bleeding has absolutely no bearing on whether they were right or wrong. This just seems to be deliberately emotionally-loaded language, and the article would be better off without it.
- graue 14y agoI used Ctrl-F and didn't find the word "determine" or "bled" anywhere on the page. Did you read a different article?
- Falkvinge 14y agoThis looks like a different article - namely, "The Analog Letter: It is entirely reasonable to demand that our children inherit the rights of our parents". http://falkvinge.net/2012/11/06/the-analog-letter-its-entirely-reasonable-to-demand-that-our-children-inherit-the-rights-of-our-parents/ http://falkvinge.net/2012/11/06/the-analog-letter-its-entire...
- jstanley 14y agoOops! My apologies.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tzs 14y agoMaking a copy of something for a friend is sharing. Making millions of copies for complete strangers is not.