4 ms·
I'm somewhat confused. If $500 million in shares are donated by Zuckerberg, does that mean a tax write-off of that amount? Also, to verify, the foundation would
by saurik 14y ago
I'm somewhat confused. If $500 million in shares are donated by Zuckerberg, does that mean a tax write-off of that amount? Also, to verify, the foundation would have to liquidize the shares, right? That kind of instant sell-off would cause massive drops in price... I really hate to ask this (as I honestly don't have anything against Zuckerberg, and really don't feel that "rich people" or "all companies" are evil or anything, as I know some people do), but is this not a massive tax arbitrage? Especially so, given that many people feel that Facebook's stock is overvalued (trading at almost $30 when it "should" trade for less than $10)? Even without any possible benefits to Zuckerberg (which I don't particularly really care about, and which brianpam had an interesting explanation for in his comment elsewhere on this post), doesn't that make this number sound much larger than it would ever really mean to the foundation's bottom line, making this insanely large number somewhat for show? (Seriously: please tell me I'm wrong; I just want to better understand these things.) (Although, thinking more, maybe the "show" is also in the benefit of the foundation, as having a massive donation, the largest in the foundation's history, also looks very good for it, even if the money deflates quite a bit in the process of turning it into cash.)
(edit: Someone, in person, points out they could hold onto the stock and sell it off slowly, or keep it for dividends; I don't think this stock has dividends, and maybe it is actually maintaining its value well--my comment was based somewhat on the premise that the various "overvalued" comments from a few months ago would continue into ever-decreasing prices, but in fact the stock went up at some point from its low-point, so maybe that's where I'm wrong?)
- loceng 14y agoI'm curious about if this benefits him (and/or the company) with tax writeoffs. Just want a clear picture to understand.
- ry0ohki 14y agoDonating stock is not that uncommon, the receiver can choose to sell, hold, or some combination. I'm not an accountant but he should be able to write off the taxes for the market value of the stock at the time of the donation? "Many people" may think the stock is overvalued, but the open market is valuing it at it's current price, so that's what it's worth right now.
- nikcub 14y agoThere is not a lot to write the donation off against. Zuck is on a salary and won't be selling any stock for a few more years. This is straight up just giving away $500M. Zuck wasn't the one who put a dollar value on the donation, that was CNN. Zuck only mentioned a number of shares. He also said he is committed to giving away most of his net worth. There really is nothing that can be criticized here. You could perhaps discuss his choice of how to distributed his wealth, but the fact that he is giving it away, and starting so soon in his life (as opposed to waiting for when he retires), should be commended. And if Facebook "should" be trading at $10, then it would be trading at $10.
- maxerickson 14y agoIt's likely he can carry the deduction forward. (I do understand that he only saves some portion of the $500 million so it doesn't make sense to say he is doing it for tax purposes.)
- loceng 14y agoI imagine once you have a guaranteed $10-$20 million to your name, you'd not need or have any attachment to any money after that.
- maxerickson 14y agoI would at least believe that there is a point where most people start seeing money primarily as a tool (rather than something they primarily exchange for necessities...). My qualification there was mostly intended to deflect the impression that I was sniping. I don't have any much knowledge of high end wealth management, but my understanding of it is that it is very difficult to use a charitable gift to actually make money. There is some tax benefit, but it is always smaller than the gift. Apparently the big charity-as-tax-scam is to establish a bona fide foundation and then stack the board with people you would like to provide with income. But that foundation has to pass a smell test with the IRS, so it is really a tax and wealth management strategy, not a way to escape paying taxes (at least, paying taxes on income that gets used for something or other).
- clarky07 14y agoFB trades an average of ~63 million shares a day. It wouldn't be that hard to sell these in the normal course of business over say a few months without having much if any impact on the share price.
- deelowe 14y agoPeople keep talking about charitable tax write-offs as if there's some sort of profitable benefit to them. Either I'm daft, or there are a lot of people out there who are very confused about the us tax code. How does this in any way benefit Mark? He can only write off a portion of his income (yes, even if he carries it forward). So, he's getting back what, like ~40% of this back as a deduction(depending on what bracket he's in)? It's still 250M dollars out of his bank account. There's no math that makes this work our in his favor. (Is there some kind of trick here that I'm missing like reducing your income, claiming the deduction as unrealized losses, and then hedging against the stock price decreasing over time? Sort of like a short?) I just don't see it. What am I missing here about the tax code that results in any charitable tax write off resulting in a net benefit for the individual? Seriously, I'd love to know how to take advantage of this loophole myself.