8 ms·
Censorship Lift for “V for Vendetta” Shocks China
- hmexx 14y agoMaybe they're coming around to a more effective western technique: "we're good guys" facade combined with stealth oppression :-P I kid.. I kid...
- INTPenis 14y agoBut really you don't kid. You're only afraid of being labeled a crackpot in a tinfoil hat. This is what western media has done, subtle propaganda has made certain words like conspiracy sound crazy. When our history books teach us that conspiracies have been part of humanity for as long back as we can find documents for it. Most likely before. I kid, I kid...
- stfu 14y agoThe problem is in my opinion, that the "conspiracy" websphere is a quite a closed circle. They either go full blown "bow to our UFO overlords", or nothing. I wish there were a few in-between media outlets that had a decent level of sanity and look & feel more linkable for "non believers".
- mtgx 14y agoI have a rule of thumb these days. Anything crazy that I hear the military, NSA or FBI are doing - I take it as being true, rather than a "conspiracy theory". I think I have a much higher chance of being right than not, in most cases. So I'd rather think like that by default, especially with many former "crazy conspiracy theories" being confirmed as true by more recent leaks and whistleblowers. I think most people still think the opposite, though, so even if something big gets uncovered, they won't really believe it to be true "in their hearts".
- criley 14y agoSo you really believe that the government is setting up concentration camps around the country, is going to use the military domestically to round up guns and all dissenters, and Obama is going to seize dictatorial control of the USA then hand sovereignty over to the New World Order? Maybe we just hear different conspiracies but I'm pretty positive that the conspiracy nonsense regarding the government shouldn't be taken as "true by default".
- runn1ng 14y agoDon't forget the Area 52 where they combine alien and human DNA.
- rglovejoy 14y agoRight, because Area 51 is just a decoy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nacker 14y agoThe fact that you are "pretty positive" about that only means that you are the kind of person who is too lazy to investigate the facts. You probably still believe that JFK was killed by a crazed lone gunman, that Pearl Harbor was a complete surprise to FDR, and that 9/11 was NOT an inside job. In other words, you are the kind of complacent rube that makes it all possible, thanks a lot.
- rockyleal 14y agoWell, then you can read the actual serious intellectuals and researchers like Chomsky, for example. Read "Manufacturing Consent", no ufo stuff there just the real deal. There is extensive literature and documentation of what is really going on, but its not going to be part of the narrative, you have to look for it. Assange's new book is another example. There are tons of authors, just follow the thread. Note: HN, any other reading material you would recommend to me or to stfu?
- rayiner 14y agoChomsky is decidedly not a conspiracy theorist. One of the main points in "Manufacturing Consent" is that you can have a healthy production of propoganda without any conspiratorial relationship between the media and government.
- neumann_alfred 14y agoAt the same time, Chomsky ain't dumb. Of course powerful people look out for their own interests; that leads to an overlap in goals with other powerful people, and a defensive/paranoid stance towards those you wield power over. Just like a lot of analog clocks hanging on a wall will synchronize, so will they. Does it have to be explicitly expressed and planned to be a conspiracy? Nah. And if people get sorted and filtered based on how well they internalized rationalizations and outright lies, that's your "conspirational relationship" right there. Though "the government" is hardly the driving force here -- have you even read Chomsky? But yes, Chomsky isn't a pussy and Chomsky pays attention. But what he points out are conspiracies in effect, and they are every bit as sinister as some James Bond BS you could come up with; it's just that "none of this is controversial", no paranoia required.
- rayiner 14y ago> Does it have to be explicitly expressed and planned to be a conspiracy? That's pretty much the definition of "conspiracy." > And if people get sorted and filtered based on how well they internalized rationalizations and outright lies, that's your "conspirational relationship" right there. No, that's not a conspiracy. It might be something else, but it's not a conspiracy. > Though "the government" is hardly the driving force here -- have you even read Chomsky? I read "Manufacturing Consent."
- sbirchall 14y ago“Trust no one! The minute God crapped out the third caveman, a conspiracy was hatched against one of them! ” ― Col. Hunter Gathers, OSI (venture brothers) But to be honest I imagine that the vast majority of so-called conspiracy is just like seeing a face on the moon - we're highly complex social analysers and modern civilisation is at least an order (but more like several orders) of magnitude bigger/more complex than the machinery that has stood us in good stead for however many generations. Hence - we see a ghost in the machine pulling the strings when really "The world is a college of corporations, inexorably determined by the immutable bylaws of business" as is so eloquently put in Network.
- stfu 14y agoI guess the biggest problem is the consistent track record of "the government" lying to the people while "word on the street" had it right. The long history from "smoking is harmless" to "there are WMDs in Iraq" has created the impression, that government is not working for the people but against the people. That might be a wrong impression for most of the services government performs, but in other high profile areas (e.g. "security theater") these situations are set to repeat.
- pnathan 14y agoA lot of conspiracy stuff is definitely coming from the mentally disturbed part of society. But on the other hand, we have to be careful. It is absolutely the case that certain groups conspire for various activities: Lenin & the Bolsheviks, Paul Revere and the US revolutionaries, the Praetorian Guards in ancient Rome, just to name a few. Pertaining more to the usual conspiracy fodder, reviewing the Church Committee reports on the CIA (c.f. "United States President's Commission on CIA activities within the United States" in Wikipedia) does not give great comfort to people who would like to ignore conspiracies. They happen, but they aren't aliens from the Zonker Dimension in snake form.
- Shorel 14y agoI think you will find this interesting: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/14zlhf/what_are_some_conspiracy_theories_you_truly/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/14zlhf/what_are_s...
- eternalban 14y agoActually you have nailed it. And I kid not.
- fatjokes 14y agoYou're not kidding at all. It amuses me how often I hear people rant about other countries' (esp. China) propaganda... and then cite Fox News.
- redthrowaway 14y agoI suspect it was an error on the part of a programming director at the network, and that it will probably cost them their job. To my knowledge, China hasn't taken any steps towards freedom of speech and this would be a pretty weird way for them to start.
- toyg 14y agoTFA mentions that "Xi Jinping assumed office as the General Secretary of the Communist Party of China on November 15th and he may have brought a more liberal attitude with him"... Time will tell, I guess.
- veemjeem 14y agoSomehow I doubt this. Only a few days ago when the news of school shooting broke out, China had a similar incident a day later where a man stabbed/injured 22 children. However, that story was quickly snuffed and the only place you could find out about it was on China's twitter (weibo). I doubt one man could easily hand over the reigns of the media.
- steve19 14y agoHow do you know it actually happened and that it was not just a false rumor spread on social media?
- veemjeem 14y agoAt least in China, the "people" network is usually more trustworthy than the major media outlets. I can understand from the western perspective that we should be doubting social media first. People were posting pictures of the injured children. It's possible that the photos were doctored, but I doubt anyone would go to great lengths doing it. Also, when you stab 22 children, I'm sure it will be big local news at least...
- TeMPOraL 14y ago
- propercoil 14y agoAny insight from a native?
- est 14y agoAnyone who is "shocked" already saw this film via torrent years ago. Anyone who didn't know V before won't care anyway. it's a meh exaggerated by social media.
- ordinary 14y agoIt's the censorship lift that shocks (as in 'surprises', not 'offends') people, not the film itself.
- veemjeem 14y agoYeah, to put this in a USA perspective, it would be like ABC/CBS showing a single naked female breast on primetime TV and being "okay" with it. Usually someone would be fired for that...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- alexfarran 14y agoNot about V for Vendetta, but my when my wife saw Animal Farm for the first time a couple of weeks ago she thought it was pretty accurate. V can be interpreted any way you want depending on who you think the bad guys are. The Chinese government was established by revolutionaries after all.
- clippit 14y agoI'm Chinese and I don't think it's a signal for relaxing censorship or something else. Just yesterday, People's Daily, the core newspaper of CCP, published a critique whose title is "Internet is not a place out of the law". Many Chinese netizen think it's a signal for tightening the censorship.
- ttflee 14y agoI understand these titles as that netizens should not propagate the rumours of corrupted local officials. I'm afraid that the only affairs that matter here are several cases where the anti-corruption inspection was initiated by social-media leaks.
- sparx 14y agoI live in china. I watched this movie last night from major video site in china, and I was shocked deeply by it's availability. Facebook , Twitter, Youtube.... All good stuff still are not accessible . anyway good sign though.
- joshmaker 14y agoWhen I was in China I noticed that English language versions Orwell's 1984 and Animal Farm were freely available in bookstores. The educated elite seems to be allowed to read or watch things that the Chinese government would surpress from getting into the hands of the masses.
- ttflee 14y agoThe Chinese translations are also widely available. However, I noticed that The Principles of Newspeak was removed from the Nineteen Eighty-Four, when the last time I browsed a copy of it in a bookstore. I also bought a translated Animal Farm, with very detailed explanation that maps each paragraph to the historical counterpart in the Soviet Union, several years ago. IMHO, people here usually take these books as some 'foreign' talks, rather than a serious argument to the reality.
- betterunix 14y ago"The Principles of Newspeak was removed from the Nineteen Eighty-Four" This does not surprise me; one of the themes of Chinese government propaganda is the superiority of the simplified writing system, and so I imagine that negative treatments of any simplification of communication would be censored. I saw a Chinese movie a while back, where the king commented on how difficult communication was because of the large number of traditional Hanzi symbols (he also commented that all he wanted was a unified China, which prompted to main character to abandon his attempted assassination of the king).
- MereInterest 14y agoThe movie was Hero, a 2002 movie starring Jet Li. I tended to get a different feeling from that line. The nameless protagonist had asked for calligraphy from his opponent. However, the protagonist did not ask for any of the existing ways to write "Sword", but rather for a new expression of it. When it was written, the protagonist spent a sleepless night examining it, learning every detail and every symbol behind the writing of this single word. It is in this context that the king interrupts the story and says how silly it is to have so many ways of writing it. Rather than being a statement of how it should be, I took it to be a statement of ignorance on the part of the king. The king did not understand how there could be subtleties in words, and wished only for simplification of the language, rather than looking for the meaning behind existing words.
- FarhadG 14y agoDamn! I missed one of my fav movies. I've been living here for only 4 months and I'm shocked to hear they would allow for such a "theme" in their media. Someone probably broke in and forced them to play it on their "backup national channel"
- sageikosa 14y agoPerhaps the censors believed its topic was aimed at Britain, or the West, and didn't look hard at its (arguably distorted) philosophic viewpoint against fascist totalitarianism. I haven't seen the whole movie (prefer to keep my memories of the graphic novel intact, and I trust that when Alan Moore says it strayed from his vision, it strayed). The Italians allowed a film version of Ayn Rand's "We the Living" to be produced because they believed it was a biting criticism of Soviet Russia, before someone realized its philosophic disposition was anti-totalitarianism. Could be sort of the same thing...
- pretoriusB 14y ago>The Italians allowed a film version of Ayn Rand's "We the Living" to be produced because they believed it was a biting criticism of Soviet Russia, before someone realized its philosophic disposition was anti-totalitarianism. Could be sort of the same thing... And why would "the Italians" have a problem with either praise of Soviet Russia or anti-totalitarianism? They are a democracy, you know, and they have both millions of people pro and against Soviet Russia (the communist party was huge in Italy), and pro and against totalitarianism. That said, knowing Ayn Rand, the film would be mostly pro-neoliberal totalitarianism of "special" individuals...
- potatolicious 14y ago> "And why would "the Italians" have a problem with either praise of Soviet Russia or anti-totalitarianism?" The movie in question was made in 1942, during the reign of Mussolini and his facists.
- sageikosa 14y agoYes, I omitted that detail, it was foremost in my mind though.
- pretoriusB 14y agoIsn't it obvious how omitting this detail --that he talks of a 70 year old movie-- changes the whole, err, picture?
- jkeogh 14y agoToo bad it wasn't The Power Of Nightmares (BBC 2004).