3 ms·

This text is most likely AI-generated. Borderline unreadable.

by pure_magic 1mo ago

ghurtado 1mo ago
There's no borderline about it. When the density of italicized words is about 1:1, I'm out.
postalrat 1mo ago
Most like AI generated? If you can't tell then what's the problem?
- catlifeonmars 1mo ago
  It’s shorthand for “it’s unreadable, but in the way an AI would write it”. I’m not OP, but that’s the issue. If it was well written (even if AI written), there would be no problem. As it turns out, you still need to be a good writer in order to prompt an AI to write well.
- ghurtado 1mo ago
  Wise people tend not to talk in absolutes, because they always realize they might be wrong. Ignorant people are always certain.
  - Zacharias030 1mo ago
    always?
    - ghurtado 1mo ago
      I am one of the ignorant ones, after all, so I'm probably wrong on this. Wait...
  - catlifeonmars 1mo ago
    This is just a rephrasing of the Dunning-Krueger effect, but quantized to a binary domain (ignorant vs wise).
  - 0x20cowboy 1mo ago
    Strong opinions…
paaloeye 1mo ago
def. AI-assisted, both content and style style/nav. Content-wise, it looks legit, but with that amount of stuff, it's nearly impossible to say for sure. Not slope tho!
iamflimflam1 1mo ago
My meatbag or robot scored it as likely a robot and most likely Claude. https://meatbag.atomic14.com/ https://meatbag.atomic14.com/
- mk89 1mo ago
  I just used it on 4 texts. The 1st version was the output from my first (chatGPT) prompt. The 4th was the last prompts of "reduce, make it less AI, etc" of the same original request/output. In all cases it was meatbag. In the 1st case gave chatGPT 0.35. The remaining ones were much lower. EDIT: I didn't ask just to generate some text. The original prompt was very specific, which is most of the time the way I use LLMs anyways. Probably it catches better the "hey just generate this email...".
alain94040 1mo ago
I'm surprised by this comment. It's probably mostly AI generated, but I have no problem reading the first 10 pages, and I found them clear and correct. Might be that we come at this page with different experience and knowledge. I'm not seeing any specifically hard to read AI here.

This text is most likely AI-generated. Borderline unreadable.

ghurtado 1mo ago

There's no borderline about it. When the density of italicized words is about 1:1, I'm out.

postalrat 1mo ago

Most like AI generated? If you can't tell then what's the problem?

catlifeonmars 1mo ago
It’s shorthand for “it’s unreadable, but in the way an AI would write it”. I’m not OP, but that’s the issue. If it was well written (even if AI written), there would be no problem. As it turns out, you still need to be a good writer in order to prompt an AI to write well.
ghurtado 1mo ago
Wise people tend not to talk in absolutes, because they always realize they might be wrong. Ignorant people are always certain.
- Zacharias030 1mo ago
  always?
  - ghurtado 1mo ago
    I am one of the ignorant ones, after all, so I'm probably wrong on this. Wait...
- catlifeonmars 1mo ago
  This is just a rephrasing of the Dunning-Krueger effect, but quantized to a binary domain (ignorant vs wise).
- 0x20cowboy 1mo ago
  Strong opinions…

paaloeye 1mo ago

def. AI-assisted, both content and style style/nav. Content-wise, it looks legit, but with that amount of stuff, it's nearly impossible to say for sure. Not slope tho!

iamflimflam1 1mo ago

My meatbag or robot scored it as likely a robot and most likely Claude. https://meatbag.atomic14.com/ https://meatbag.atomic14.com/

mk89 1mo ago
I just used it on 4 texts. The 1st version was the output from my first (chatGPT) prompt. The 4th was the last prompts of "reduce, make it less AI, etc" of the same original request/output. In all cases it was meatbag. In the 1st case gave chatGPT 0.35. The remaining ones were much lower. EDIT: I didn't ask just to generate some text. The original prompt was very specific, which is most of the time the way I use LLMs anyways. Probably it catches better the "hey just generate this email...".

alain94040 1mo ago

I'm surprised by this comment. It's probably mostly AI generated, but I have no problem reading the first 10 pages, and I found them clear and correct. Might be that we come at this page with different experience and knowledge. I'm not seeing any specifically hard to read AI here.