4 ms·
That is not true in any but the most literal sense.
by thfuran 3mo ago
That is not true in any but the most literal sense.
- card_zero 3mo agoIs it true in the sense relevant to climate change?
- Retric 3mo agoNo, a 3 foot tall sapling and a 300+ foot tall monster are both one tree but have very different impacts on the climate. Fast growth commercial forests have high density because the individual trees are relatively small with a vastly smaller amount of root mass.
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- catlikesshrimp 3mo agoAlso, a five year old pine or teak isn't anywhere near a fifty year old mahogany
- kolinko 3mo agoIf I remember correctly, the youngest trees convert the most co2 (makes sense, they grow the fastest).
- Retric 3mo agoNot on a per tree basis. Young forests sequester more carbon per year because you aren’t losing old trees, however sustainable harvesting changes the dynamics here. IE a 50k year old natural forest is very close to carbon neutral, but you can harvest wood from an old forest and change the equation as you don’t need to let dead limbs or trees rot. Unfortunately when you cut down an old forest and convert it into a young one the old forests root mass rots thus releasing a great deal of stored carbon.
- kolinko 3mo agoGood points about the roots. TIL.
- unsnap_biceps 3mo agoClimate change is a lot of different things. For the statement that the count matters and a "tree is a tree", Carbon sequestration? A giant redwood stores more carbon than a fir. Healthy ecosystems? Different trees fit into different roles in a healthy forest. The loss of biodiversity? Once a forest dies, a new forest somewhere else doesn't bring back the lost biodiversity. In theory, Carbon sequestration is the closest to "a tree is a tree", you can plant large amounts of fast growing trees can capture more carbon over time, but that's specifying the later tree, which then matters.
- card_zero 3mo agoWhy did you mention ecosystems and biodiversity? Is the idea that those store more carbon, too, or was it just gratuitous? Edit after downvote: but why though? It looks like conflation of climate change with the entirety of environmentalism. That is a misleading thing to do.
- remoroid 3mo ago[dead]
- cucumber3732842 3mo agoIf you cut a bunch of crappy pines and borderline brush (beyond whatever trivial square foot exemption they give you) the environmental authorities will be on your case same as if you cut down a 120yo hardwood forest. Can't have your cake and eat it too. Either they're all the same or they're not.
- deadbabe 3mo agoThere is only truly literal sense.