4 ms·
Very cool. It would be nice to see a breakdown of where the energy he received while plugged-in at home came from. I think it's great that we are reducing our d
by whalesalad 14y ago
Very cool. It would be nice to see a breakdown of where the energy he received while plugged-in at home came from. I think it's great that we are reducing our dependence on fossil fuel, but at the end of the day if the energy to power that car is being generated by dirtier or more costly ways... it doesn't really matter.
- josefresco 14y agoIt does because instead of directly burning said fossil fuel, you are indirectly burning it. This abstraction if you will allows change or improvement to the source of the electricity in a way that you cannot do with gasoline.
- hadem 14y agoCan you further explain? Maybe I misunderstood you but if the power plant generating the electricity is equal to the automobiles burning the fuel, in the end, isn't it a wash? Similar to hybrid cars. They are better for the environment but that isn't that offset by the production of the batteries needed for the hybrid engine?
- w1ntermute 14y ago> if the power plant generating the electricity is equal to the automobiles burning the fuel, in the end, isn't it a wash? No. By abstracting the source of the energy, we can make one change in the method of power generation and immediately make a large number of electric cars "clean". So if we replace a coal plant with a nuclear or hydroelectric or solar plant, then everyone charging their electric cars with energy from that plant will suddenly be using clean energy. This isn't possible with the millions of gas cars out there, because they are only capable of using gas.
- schiffern 14y ago>Similar to hybrid cars. They are better for the environment but that isn't that offset by the production of the batteries needed for the hybrid engine? No. The oft-cited "Dust to Dust" report has been thoroughly debunked: http://grist.org/article/dust-to-dumb/ http://grist.org/article/dust-to-dumb/ For just one example, they assume (with no real justification) that a Hummer will last 300k miles and a Prius just 100k. Invalidating that single assumption flips the result, and it's not the only one. There's a false equivocacy going on in our heads when we fall victim to this kind of misinformation. "One advantage vs. one disadvantage. They must cancel out!" This is why it's important to do quantitative analysis. In reality, the addition of a battery and motor only adds about 10% to the embodied energy and disposal impact of a car, which itself is dwarfed by the fuel burned in its lifetime (by about 3:1). The interesting question for me is: why do people worry about the Nickel in their car's battery but not in their car's steel-alloy frame?
- mc32 14y agoIIRC, what worries some people is the REEs that go into the mfg of electric batteries. REE mining tends to be dirty and tends to be, for now, in counties with little in the way of enviro regulation monitoring mining methods, etc.
- starpilot 14y agoConsider the range of efficiency of driving depending on mode: 0 mpg - stopped at a light 15 mpg - typical city driving 35 mpg - typical highway driving A powerplant is always running its turbines. It's like car motor that is always on cruise control on the highway, without giving up energy to stop in traffic or throttle down.
- reportingsjr 14y agoKeep in mind that power plants do indeed spin their turbines down and spin them up again. This is due to the greatly increased demand for electricity during the day and reduced demand at night. This is why electricity is cheaper at night. They want people to move energy intensive stuff to run at night so it smooths out the grid energy usage cycle. The peak energy usage is normally right around dusk, since that is when people are getting home from work, lights are coming on, etc. If people charge their cars at this time that only makes things worse. Hopefully we get smart chargers that slow charging at this time, so while it doesn't cause a huge peak the car is still charging, and then increases charging power during the night. Just a thought.
- iyulaev 14y agoif the power plant generating the electricity is equal to the automobiles burning the fuel It's not. Even the worst, dirtiest coal plant is going to be more efficient than your car engine, since it converts much more of the energy (given of as heat) into electricity. Economies of scale definitely apply to power plants.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- whalesalad 14y agoYou're right but then you get into a whole new can of worms: the inefficiency of energy storage and transportation. Gasoline loses less energy over time and distance than electricity does. And storing electricity in batteries is also 'lossy' as well.
- tadfisher 14y agoKeep in mind that there is a variable cost to transport the gasoline as well; you need to fuel tankers, power refineries, and fuel the trucks to transport the fuel to the pump.
- r00fus 14y agoYes, it would be a pretty ridiculous situation where the EROEI [1] calculation would favor gas-powered car engines vs. coal-powered electricity pumped through grids and stored in batteries. Gas powered motors are still less brittle than grid-powered ones - it'd be tough to power a military force on grid power for example, but at that scale we should be using local fission powerplants anyway (ie, nuke subs). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_returned_on_energy_invested http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_returned_on_energy_inves...
- pilom 14y agoFortunately all of these calculations have been done by scientists. http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c20/page_131.shtml http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c20/page_13... TLDR: Electric vehicles still win, but only just barely when you include the battery manufacturing costs.
- whalesalad 14y agoThis is a very good point. Like throwing a load balancer in front of a server. You can then replace that server or put 10 in it's place and the outside world has no idea. Similarly, if you unify the ways to receive energy into one single interface: a power plug or wall outlet, it makes it easier to change what's going on in the background. Thanks for your comment it really opened up my brain.
- mgkimsal 14y agoI'd come here to mention the abstraction aspect. This idea is probably the least discussed when talking about cars/power, and we tend to veer towards other specific fuels. "Oh, electric cars are no good - we need hydrogen cars!" Or something like that. Who's saying that? Seemed to be energy companies, but it's IIRC. Electric cars allow for any energy source to be used (as well as multiple), in the generation of the electricity. I suspect a lot of people don't want that flexibility/freedom, and would instead prefer to lock down a few more generations of drivers to one specific type of fuel, even if it's not gas.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoI've thought about this benefit too, but never had a nice way to describe it. Thanks.
- kelvin0 14y agoActually not too long ago Elon Musk mentionned this point, the fact that ultimately electricity does come from fossil fuels in many cases. And of course this is not good. However, he made some good points: * Fossile fuel electricity generators (utilities power plants) are often times more efficient than burning the same amount in your car * Also, all the electric infrastructure needed to distribute electricity is much 'greener' than the system needed to distribute fossile fuels to your local gas station. So even though the power is from coal, it's production/transport/consumption makes it more efficient than simply using your 'gasoline' powered car. As much as these are interesting points, I have not broken down the real impacts Elon mentionned, but I thought they made a lot of sense.
- potatolicious 14y ago> "Fossile fuel electricity generators (utilities power plants) are often times more efficient than burning the same amount in your car" Replace "often" with "always". I don't know of any power plant that's less efficient than an automobile engine. The efficiency increase just by going to fossil fuel grid power is pretty insane all by itself, even accounting for transmission losses. Even if we just kept burning fossil fuels in our power plants, and converted all cars to electrics, the efficiency increase would be incredible.
- mmanfrin 14y agoPower-grid energy is tremendously cleaner than a car's combustion engine.
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoNot to mention I'm sick of breathing in smog and diesel exhaust. Heck, I live in Chicago. I can't imagine what its like in LA. In the summer, on a clear day, I can look out my office window westward from the lakefront and see a thick cloud that covers everything past a certain distance.
- anigbrowl 14y agoLA is actually pretty pleasant these days, because California has had very strict laws on fuel particulates for a while now. Also, a lot of people in California's coastal cities drive Priuses and similar cars which burn very little gas.
- c1sc0 14y agoMaybe it doesn't matter in the ecology department but it very much makes a difference in the geopolitics one.
- afterburner 14y agoSee http://www.teslamotors.com/goelectric#electricity http://www.teslamotors.com/goelectric#electricity (Thanks to hatberet further down) Shows the electricity production by state; nowhere does using an electric produce more CO2 than a gas car.
- rorrr 14y agoIt does matter. Even if we're generating energy by burning fossil fuels, the turbines at the plant are so much more efficient than the car engines.
- schiffern 14y ago>if the energy to power that car is being generated by dirtier or more costly ways... it doesn't really matter. Maybe theoretically, but if you do the math then even 100% coal isn't dirty enough – the Tesla Model S gets 24 MPGe in that case, compared to just 17 MPG for the BMW M5. Energy cost compares favorably as well – charging in Hawaii (37¢ per kWh!) would only cost 14¢/mi, compared to 20¢/mi for the M5 (@$3.50). The question has never been, "which is the cheapest/cleanest to operate?" Batteries have been the clear winner for some time. The challenge that faces EVs is, "does the high initial price of batteries negate the lifetime savings?" We're not there yet for family cars, but for full-size luxury sedans it seems to have arrived.
- TylerE 14y agoI'm not so sure about that. In my Golf TDI I have a demonstrated of $0.114 per mile. That's in less than ideal conditions, with lots of city driving. If I drove almost all highway, I'd be getting more like 45mpg rather than the 34mpg lifetime I have, so at the current price of diesel ($3.90/gal) that'd be more like 8.6c/mile.
- jcampbell1 14y agoAre you seriously comparing a VW Golf to an BMW M5 or Tesla S?
- SeanLuke 14y ago> In my Golf TDI I have a demonstrated of $0.114 per mile. Hawaii is a worst-case scenario. Many electric vehicle owners (including Tesla) see about two or three cents per mile.
- schiffern 14y agoAnd the Model S is being compared at less than ideal conditions by using the most expensive electricity in America. At California prices it costs 6.5¢/mile, and at average US prices it costs 4.7¢/mile. When you use Tesla's Supercharger stations it's free.
- joshhart 14y agoNot necessarily true. One could put a coal power plant in the middle of a desert where it presumably doesn't affect the environment & population as much as it would have otherwise.
- halviti 14y agoIf we relied more on electricity than fossil fuels, you know renewable energy would continue to grow even more than it already is. This is not something to just write off for no reason. Also, not everyone lives in America. 100% of electricity in my country comes from renewable resources.