3 ms·

Compacting context compacts context. So Claude forgets a lot during compaction.

• Maxatar 2mo ago
  Compacting mostly gets rid of reasoning tokens, and honestly it would be nice of reasoning tokens did not constantly follow every follow up query. Asking even a simple/trivial question can have Claude use thousands of tokens. Compacting is good for getting rid of those.
  • troupo 2mo ago
    I've had Claude immediately fall back to its usual verbose style immediately after compaction. To be fair, I've had it do that immediately after re-reading the output style instructions, too. My chat history is filled with "Yes, I broke the language rule. Let me rephrase that and update my memory. — You already have that in memory — Yes, true, I ignored that" (because "Memory" is a yet another .md file)
    • strbean 2mo ago
      Claude Code supposedly supports a "post-compaction" hook, so you could have it automatically run the prompt "We just compacted the context, quickly refresh yourself on the rules in CLAUDE.md etc..". Depending on what you've got in those files, maybe that will just use up all the context again though.
      • troupo 2mo ago
        > supposedly supports a "post-compaction" hook, so you could have it automatically run the prompt Keyword "supposedly" :) I've had it in my settings forever, and still... Asking it to analyse and fix the issue it produced a plausible "my training supercedes/overrides settings especially if triggered by certain words in the phrase" (paraphrasing the long text)
        • strbean 2mo ago
          > Keyword "supposedly" :) > I've had it in my settings forever, and still... Checks out! I've never used it my self, so it I figured it likely didn't work at all.