9 ms·
How to Download Your Instagram Photos and Kill Your Account
- jstrate 14y agoThere are also free services to migrate your photos to dropbox, drive, etc. Full disclosure and shameless plug, I work for one. pi.pe
- groby_b 14y agoNot to completely derail this into a pi.pe thread, but... a) I'd love to use it, but you're really making it hard to find out what destinations/sources you support. b) There's quite a bit of bandwidth cost, so I'm baffled as to how you can do this profitably. This makes me wary. Which plays into c) Your facebook app requires permission to post on my behalf? Sorry, but over my dead body. Especially since I can't give you money. (I assume it's to upload pictures, but there's no way to know. If you had separate up/download apps, you could sidestep that if I just want to export) So, overall, it's an awesome idea. And I'd happily give you money to do this for me, but you don't let me :) And if you want to make me really happy: Allow me to set up a continuous job, add s3/google drive destination support. Now back to your regular instagram discussion :)
- sek 14y agoYou can skip the permission to post on facebook.
- nthitz 14y agoThe fact that the article uses a crappy Instagrammed photo for the picture is baffling
- hnriot 14y agowhy? seems on-topic and relevant to me. Maybe you missed the irony.
- stephengillie 14y agoThe photo felt like it was also trying to frame Instagram in a harsh light, similar to how articles about violent crime often feature mugshots.
- hadem 14y agoNot necessarily. Someone took that photo and posted it to their Instagram filter, spreading the word to all of their Instagram followers. Seems like the author of the photo could have been trying to get the message to Instagram users.
- hnriot 14y agomany might be surprised that instagram only keep 612x612 images, so if you were hoping to download full resolution images,. you're out of luck... that, however, also makes the whole issue moot since the images are so small to be of little/no use in any commercial sense. flickr's iOS app, by comparison, stores on their server the full resolution image. #nofilter FTW
- grecy 14y ago> many might be surprised that instagram only keep 612x612 images How do we know that for sure? They could easily have the full res versions stored elsewhere. They own them, after all.
- avree 14y agoBecause the resolution shift happens client side, before the photo is transmitted to their servers. They couldn't have the full res version stored elsewhere. That's how we know.
- nmcfarl 14y agoHow do we know the resolution shift happens client side? I did a quick google and found nothing.
- alxndr 14y agoOne could watch the traffic when posting a photo.
- CraigRood 14y agoIt also uploads before you confirm your posting to make the process faster.
- danabramov 14y agoBecause the uploading is damn fast.
- 14y ago
- mikeleeorg 14y agotl;dr: Use this to download your Instagram photos http://instaport.me http://instaport.me Then use this to delete your account http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95760 http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95760
- sp332 14y agoDoes deleting your account actually remove your photos? I've seen some people claim that you can still load the images if you know the URL. Not sure if it's just a CDN that hasn't expired the content yet or if Instagram really keeps your photos after you "delete" them.
- mseebach 14y agoDeleting your account certainly implies that you don't accept the new TOS.
- nwh 14y agoI wouldn't doubt it. I've Facebook URL of images that were "deleted" year ago, but the links still work. I'm not sure what it would take for the content to actually be removed.
- chimeracoder 14y agoFacebook doesn't delete your images for years (if ever). There are links to photos deleted in 2008 (or perhaps earlier) that still work.
- abuella 14y agocheck out www.instabyebye.com built today
- kremdela 14y agoI had the same (great) idea, but your site doesn't do what I thought it would. Instead of being able to download all of my large size images, I now have a publicly viewable listing of thumbnails of all of my photos that are now mirrored on your amazon account. There are no privacy settings, or ability to delete them from your server. I think you should be clearer about the ability to delete them from your server.
- justhw 14y agoSo, how's instaport making money?
- zalew 14y ago'donate' and 'Ads via Adsie' banners on the right?
- podperson 14y agoI think the interesting question here is "how many folks will simply ignore all of this and keep on using Instagram?" -- if privacy scandals were going to hurt user bases, Facebook would long since be gone. I suspect that any loss of users Instagram has suffered are more likely to have been through the dumbing-down of their iOS app than privacy concerns.
- sharkweek 14y agoI will continue to use Instagram, as I don't feel particularly concerned with my photos on there. I'd even feel honored if they were a bit smarter about their approach and planned on asking for permission to use specific photos first. Shit, that would probably have kept this from being a PR disaster and instead become a bonus for some users, as I think it would be really cool to see my photos featured in different mediums.
- podperson 14y agoGood points -- although I suspect that the reason they don't ask permission is they want to be able to transparently do the kinds of things they've been doing with profile pics for years ("your friends love X, click here").
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Shtirlic 14y ago"...except Content not shared publicly ("private") will not be distributed outside the Instagram Services." from the TOS. Seems interesting to me.
- betelnut 14y agoAs far as I can tell, some Android devices also save your photos (with filters) in a separate album, so you may not need to download them from Instagram directly.
- mediacrisis 14y agoThey should. I recently switched from a Droid X running Gingerbread to a newer Android phone, and it was super easy to grab all of my instagram photos (and everything else, really) out of the files directory.
- benlower 14y agoWait. Lot's of people were telling me that lack of Instagram app prevented them from switching to Windows Phone. Turns out lack of that app was just trend setting? :-)
- Pelayo 14y agoDoes anyone what the legal implications are if someone takes a picture of my baby and Instagram sells it to somebody for an ad? Would they need some sort of release? Because I can delete my own photos but what what happens with other people's?
- georgemcbay 14y agoHaving it be a baby confuses the issue because babies can't give consent, but if someone took a picture of you and you're not an instagram user and thus never agreed to their TOS and that photo is used for commercial advertising you'd have a very strong case to sue in many places of the world. Using the identifiable image of a person (even a private non-celebrity) in a non-editorial commercial manner is not permitted in most places, especially (bur not only) if the photo was taken in a place where there is an implied right to privacy (someone's home, etc, rather than outside in public). This is why photographers are anal about making sure all people who are identifiable in their photos sign a model release form if they plan to sell the photo for non-editorial uses. If instagram ran this idea by their lawyers I'm sure they've been informed that they should absolutely never use any of these images for advertising if there is an identifiable person in it because otherwise the risk of being sued for it eventually is far too great.
- dfxm12 14y agoThere are none. They probably wouldn't. You can certainly try and fight it though! Food for thought: http://photorights.org/faq/is-it-legal-to-take-photos-of-people-without-asking http://photorights.org/faq/is-it-legal-to-take-photos-of-peo...
- antiterra 14y agoHow can you say there are none when the very link you provide mentions a release can be required for commercial use? You cannot imply that another person endorses your product or service without permission, and I've never seen an exclusion for babies. One may exist, but that FAQ doesn't say anything about it.
- thelibrarian 14y ago
- isalmon 14y agoI'm really curious why http://instaport.me/ http://instaport.me/ redirects you to http://54.246.82.151/ http://54.246.82.151/ Did anybody else notice that?
- tlrobinson 14y agoI'm seeing that too. They probably just got a massive spike in traffic.
- siglesias 14y agoCan somebody explain to me what the big deal is about Instagram and these new terms of service? I can't fathom that anything but 1% of 1% of photos taken there are good enough to be used commercially, and if folks are so afraid that their pictures of Starbucks lattes will be used in some kind of marketing campaign (in which case they should actually be flattered), what exactly is stopping users from removing location information from the pictures they want to keep private? For me, if the local coffee shop here wants to dig up some pictures I took of their business to help them get more customers, why not let them? I'm not Richard Avedon, and I never, ever, expected to profit from my Instagram photography. I'm more than happy to support small businesses and Instagram. Have a ball, guys. It's all public anyway.
- cryptoz 14y agoHuman-produced carbon output is only like 1% of 1% of the atmosphere. No big deal right? Murderers are only like 1% of 1% of people. No big deal right? ...
- sharkweek 14y agoI think Instagram missed a GREAT PR opportunity here -- Imagine if they came out and made this an "opt-in" option for people interested in having their photos featured. Even with the odds being low, I'd happily participate, as I think it would be ridiculously cool to see my photos featured. I'd imagine they'd easily get enough participation to get them the content they need to experiment with this.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ak217 14y agoFlickr and Google (among others) don't claim the kind of license that Instagram demands in the new ToS. So this is only a big deal in that there are some alternatives that don't suck and are really easy to switch to. If they want to put content users in touch with content providers, they can do what Flickr did: make a way for them to do so. There are a ton of ways to monetize that, too, without dialing it up all the way to "we own your content". I bet most users would love a request system that lets businesses use their photos free of charge with attribution if they click "yes".
- jenius 14y agoRelevant: http://www.theverge.com/2012/12/18/3780158/instagrams-new-terms-of-service-what-they-really-mean http://www.theverge.com/2012/12/18/3780158/instagrams-new-te...
- state 14y agoWhenever something like this happens I immediately look for the open alternative. But, does one exist?
- marquis 14y agoSuch a massive infrastructure is expensive, and given that (arguably) the most useful open system, Wikipedia, constantly has funding drives it doesn't seem viable as a free, large-scale consumer-fronting service. I could see such a service being run as a non-profit perhaps, given some monetization or donations.
- state 14y agoI'd pay for it.
- sek 14y agoTwitter implements this feature, there has been some overlap anyway. I was never sure where to share a picture.
- blhack 14y agoMy god, people, calm down. This isn't instagram trying to use your photos as stock photos. First: they're not good enough. They're snapshots taken with camera phones, they're not marketing materials. Second: that would piss off their users, and no sane company would ever do this. The thing you're seeing in their ToS is an interpretation that allows for this. Expect a statement from instagram confirming that they will change their ToS to explicitly disallow this sometime today. In the meantime: calm down, go outside for a walk.
- Karunamon 14y ago>The thing you're seeing in their ToS is an interpretation that allows for this. Then maybe companies shouldn't amend their ToS to "allow" for things that are so utterly odious. None of the other companies that matter do this, so the claim that this is standard boilerplate is bunkola.
- epaga 14y agoI came here to post almost exactly this. This happens regularly with the big sites - some idiot lawyer writes an overly cautious ToS change, everyone gets up in arms about it, the site writes an apology clarifying (and probably fires the lawyer). It seems common sense to me if you just think it to the end: do you REALLY think taking a photo of me drinking Coke (against my will) would be good advertising? Or selling my photo as a stock photo without compensating me - that that would fly? Really? It seems absolutely obvious to me that Instagram has no interest whatsoever in doing what people are all afraid they'll be doing.
- epaga 14y ago7 hours later: told ya so... http://blog.instagram.com/post/38252135408/thank-you-and-were-listening http://blog.instagram.com/post/38252135408/thank-you-and-wer...
- Karunamon 14y ago>It seems absolutely obvious to me that Instagram has no interest whatsoever in doing what people are all afraid they'll be doing The same question is raised: Why have it in the TOS if it's not going to happen? At the very least it shows a great lack of care for the operation of their business (in which case you should think twice about using the service), at most it shows a complete disregard for their users (also in which case you should think twice about using the service).
- kmfrk 14y agoStill won't help you save your comments/photos commented on and likes all too well, though. I personally find them more important as someone who doesn't submit many photos.
- najhr999 14y agoEverybody is always trying to get something for nothing.
- imgabe 14y agoFor those of you who don't think this is a big deal. Instagram is explicitly stating that they're going to sell the use of your pictures to third parties. They're also going to start showing ads in their news stream. I know the pictures are of too low quality to be plastered on a billboard. That's not the point. What I expect they want to happen is something like this: I post a picture of me drinking a Coke to Instagram. I expect to share this with my friends, and maybe the people who follow me on Twitter. I know it's publicly available, but the chances of anyone beyond my circle of friends seeing it are slim to none. But now, Instagram notices that I posted this picture and sells it to Coke. Now, when Coke starts buying ads on Instagram, my photo shows on total stranger's news streams saying something like "Hey Enjoy a Coke, like this guy here!" So, what's wrong with that? Well, for one thing, I never agreed to be in an ad campaign for Coke. Maybe I don't even like Coke. Maybe MY caption was something like "Ugh, out of Pepsi". For another thing, generally, when you appear in an advertisement for a product, you get paid. Your likeness in the context of a commercial ad campaign has value, and when a company says "Yeah, I'm just gonna go ahead and take that and not pay you anything" the appropriate response is "hell no".
- hkmurakami 14y agoIt'd be even more effective (read: messed up) if they take your coke-drinking-photo and show this in your own friends' feeds as an advertisement, with the kind of caption you mentioned. I experienced the effectiveness of seeing a friend's face on an ad first hand a few years ago, when a friend of mine put up a job-posting ad on facebook with his face on it. My engagement with that ad was ridiculously high and it lead me to go proactively research what his company was about.
- grinich 14y agoWhy is it "messed up" if it makes advertising more engaging? Facebook essentially does what you describe, by showing your friends the posts/ads of pages you have liked. I think it's just a spectrum where ads can become a service. What if Netflix could show me movies that friends have recently watched? Or TV ads rendered client-side to have personal details (adapting to the demographics)? What if I was emailed early about new concerts happening in my area, based on what I listen to on Spotify? And then was encouraged to post to FB when I bought tickets. The last one is a real (Songkick) and is actually one my my favorite services. Though, is it an ad company? They certainly get a referral from Ticketmaster. What if they sold my preferences to Ticketmaster so they could know how to optimize a lineup with listener preferences? What I'm getting at is that people seem really afraid of customization and personalization. Somehow it's "messed up" if ads capitalize on the network they have built; our reaction is that these free services are taking advantage us. It's important to remember, if you are not paying for it, you’re not the customer; you’re the product being sold. This is why Google gives away a browser, why Facebook and Twitter remain free, and why Instagram was worth $1B. That number certainly didn't correspond to an iPhone app and a relatively simple backend tech stack -- it bought their growth, user engagement, and stickiness. And that's exactly what they're going to capitalize on to make back the investment.
- mfringel 14y agoI think what we're actually seeing is users declare that the value that Instagram provides them is not worth a perpetual and transferable commercial license for all photos taken, past and present.
- crististm 14y ago"...will not be able to sign up for Instagram later with the same account name" - I wonder why?...
- juddlyon 14y agoYou're in their casino, you play by their rules. The house always wins.
- kloncks 14y agoWouldn't the simplest fix be to let users opt-in to this? Hell, opt me in automatically by default. But maybe this is the compromise, that way Instagram can make money (as they should) and users don't feel ripped off.
- rwhitman 14y agoNews flash - YouTube also has a TOS that allows them to license and resell your uploaded content and it has worked this way for years.
- grinich 14y agoSortof. They have similar clauses, but the YouTube TOS (similar to other services like Dropbox, Flicker, etc.) gives them a "worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free ... transferable license" to provide the service. Legally, you need a "license" for somebody's content in order to access it and generate a thumbnail. This change in Instagram's TOS is different: Some or all of the Service may be supported by advertising revenue. To help us deliver interesting paid or sponsored content or promotions, you agree that a business or other entity may pay us to display your username, likeness, photos (along with any associated metadata), and/or actions you take, in connection with paid or sponsored content or promotions, without any compensation to you Note, this is essentially what Facebook does when you "like" a company's page.
- iomike 14y agoI feel sleezy using Flickr, because they were doing the same thing, uncredited, and running Flickr images in Yahoo! ads. This has been years ago, but one of the reasons I stopped using Flickr.
- tomflack 14y agoDetails?
- tetomb 14y agoWhy wouldn't they implement a system where you can flag certain photos for promotion and receive a cut if that photo is used for promotion? Why can Facebook only come up with monetization strategies that take advantage of its users?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- itsprofitbaron 14y agoInstagram's new TOS[1] state: To help us deliver interesting paid or sponsored content or promotions, you agree that a business or other entity may pay us to display your username, likeness, photos (along with any associated metadata), and/or actions you take, in connection with paid or sponsored content or promotions, without any compensation to you. In other words, they're trying to monetize Instagram a similar way Facebook is - Sponsored Posts - your photos and associated data can be promoted by companies without having to notify you about it. Furthermore under Section 106: Exclusive rights in copyrighted works aka. 17 U.S.C. § 106[2] Instagram cannot sell your photos and it cannot use your photos and alter them in any meaningful way. Having said that Instagram could have communicated this better as this hasn't helped the situation either. [1] http://instagram.com/about/legal/terms/updated/ http://instagram.com/about/legal/terms/updated/ [2] http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html ==== NOTE: Also posted this at: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4939650 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4939650
- product50 14y agoLove Flickr due to this. See this: http://blog.flickr.net/en/2011/05/13/at-flickr-your-photos-are-always-yours/ http://blog.flickr.net/en/2011/05/13/at-flickr-your-photos-a... Here they have explained how Y! can't use your photos for anything else except for the purpose the content was made available. Additionally, users have the option to make content licensable if they want to using Getty.
- felipebueno 14y agoHahah loved this part: "That’s it. Of course you’ll need to find another photo service to see photos of meals and your friend’s feet." ^_^
- duggan 14y agoAlternative export tool, doesn't require login, open source and can be trivially rehosted by anyone if the traffic overwhelms: Source: https://github.com/duggan/instazip https://github.com/duggan/instazip "Demo" (aka, you can use this unless traffic kills it): http://instazip.orchestra.io/ http://instazip.orchestra.io/ Caveats: bit buggy, running on a free Orchestra plan, wants a very recent browser to run. PRs obviously welcome/sought.
- clark-kent 14y agoIt depends on how instagram implements this policy, they need a policy that gives them enough flexibility to try new things and find out what will stick. It's too early to start a kill your instagram campaign. Why not wait and see how they implement this.
- laurentoget 14y agoI feel bad for the lawyer who wrote that TOS and will be blamed for killing a toy project facebook paid a billion for.
- ck2 14y agoSomeone explain to me how instagram is evil and facebook is okay?
- zemanel 14y agoSometimes when these discussions appear, people talk of alternatives like "personal clouds" or "peer to peer photo sharing and blogging". I know of at least Diaspora but there is at least one other i can't remember the name of, that you can install on your own server but i doubt that these projects in their current form will ever take off and be of any competition to the Facebook/Instagram models, because the technical aspect is just too complicated to the average user (assuming it to be a kind of user that has no existing or minimal skills to install Wordpress on a shared hosting). Was just wondering about this on my way here to the "office" and a solution for this mess regarding user content ownership, privacy and companies "slipping the rug" under the user's feet could be the separation of service provider, the software itself and hosting (where the content is) ? Basically something along the lines of: * the user signing up for the hosting part on his prefered provider (Amazon Cloud, Rackspace, Linode, Google appengine, etc) * the user signing up for his favourite social software provider, let's say as example, software companies that provided on-demand installed software distributions that provided services similar to Facebook, Instagram, Posterous, etc ... including personal e-mail services. Could be addons on a base system or a full distribution per se, rolled on subdomains (photos.bilbobaggins.com, blog.bilbobaggins.com, ... ) * the software provider would be given access (through OAuth or whatever credential system) to roll their software on the hosting provided by the user) * discoverability (ask aggregated public timelines and the sorts) could work based on a system akin to DNS for humans/peer to peer. * a form of standard for interoperability between service/software providers would have to bee in place for the users to be able to switch between them and allow competition. This would mean that: * users would retain ownership of their content since they control the hosting, meaning they could pull the plug on a service provider or switch to the competition. * since much of this can be abstracted from the user as automated devops keep getting better, the technical barrier would be lower. * most of the hosting and networking costs would be shared between the users, so the software providers could focus more on business models relating to a better service/software, much like app stores work these days i guess?