3 ms·
It’s funny how the quality of the average commit message has gone up, now that we rarely read or write them directly anymore.
by pseudosavant 1mo ago
It’s funny how the quality of the average commit message has gone up, now that we rarely read or write them directly anymore.
- amarshall 1mo agoHas it? Most of the LLM-generated commit messages and PR descriptions I read are needlessly verbose and miss the point: elucidating the why of a change rather than the what. If I actually pose a question based on them the author often tells me “yea that was some AI generated nonsense, I rewrote it now”.
- asdfsa32 1mo agoYou may be confusing articulate and confident with useful and accurate.
- fartfeatures 1mo agoThey really aren't. AI commit messages are much more thorough and correct than some of the stuff I've seen humans do over the years e.g. Fix, Fixup, Fixed some Stuff, Should work now, Definitely should work now etc etc etc.
- kqp 1mo agoIf you can’t tell how this is a non sequitur then it’s very likely you, too, confuse articulate and confident with useful and accurate.
- realusername 1mo agoI definitely prefer a "fixup" to a three paragraph meaningless word soup which doesn't cover why the commit is there either
- rimliu 1mo agoNah, most often they are just long-winded beatings around the bush.
- pseudosavant 1mo agoNot really. In my experience, the average human written commit messages were almost always useless 1-3 word "Should work non" kind of messages. The agents had a low bar to clear.