3 ms·
I've thought about turning this upside down. To any person who is sure they know what has and doesn't have consciousness: If I say I don't have it, can you pr
by xscott 1mo ago
I've thought about turning this upside down. To any person who is sure they know what has and doesn't have consciousness: If I say I don't have it, can you prove me wrong?
As far as I'm concerned, it's a word without a useful enough definition to bother worrying about it.
- goatlover 1mo agoIt's subjective experience. The colors you see, the sounds you hear, tastes, smell, pain, emotion, dreams, inner dialog. The philosophical word would be qualia. I don't understand people who pretend to be p-zombies in these arguments.
- xscott 1mo agoYour definition is not useful enough. There are people missing any or all of those, and any or all of those can be approximated by a machine.
- goatlover 1mo agoI'm not aware of anyone lacking all those experiences who isn't brain dead. What does approximating an experience by a machine mean? A chatbot can pretend to be cold. It can't actually feel cold as it has no body.