10 ms·
Wil Wheaton on Instagram's new ad policy
- __chrismc 14y agoLink to the same post on his blog, for the Google+ averse: http://wilwheaton.net/2012/12/regarding-instagrams-new-tos/ http://wilwheaton.net/2012/12/regarding-instagrams-new-tos/
- casca 14y agoAxiom 1: Company is collecting and storing personal data that you voluntarily provide Axiom 2: Company does not charge you for this service Axiom 3: Company has no other visible means of income Axiom 4: Company has non-trivial operating expenses Given that this covers a huge amount of "our digital life", there are a few possible solutions: - Keep getting services without paying money but paying with privacy - Identify another way to get the services we rely on to be paid for - Hope that a large benefactor company will buy the services we use and write the operational cost off out of the goodness of their hearts
- thirdtruck 14y agoAxiom 1: Company is collecting and storing personal data that you voluntarily provide. Wil's entire point stemmed from the involuntary nature inherent in much of public photography today. There's a reason that TV shows blur out the faces of people who don't sign commercial usage waivers.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jval 14y ago> Axiom 3: Company has no other visible means of income This is not true. There are plenty of other ways for social sites to make money. If Twitter is doing billions off promoted Tweets, then surely a company like Facebook which has even more data on you can make a similar amount selling standard targeted advertising. What we are seeing here is crossing the line. The worst thing is, this data was acquired under completely different terms and conditions. I never agreed to this when I signed up, and there is the faint scent of bullshit now that the company is trying to turn around years after that fact and retrospectively acquire my data. 'Opt out by deleting' doesn't cut it - we had a contract!
- bad_user 14y agoAll of them did it. Facebook, Twitter, Google, Instagram. First they get popular, then when they're big enough having the luxury of lock-in, they turn to fucking the same users that made them popular. Web 2.0 - taking the milk out of stupid cows that should have known better.
- _delirium 14y agoEven further back, look at what Gracenote did with CDDB, crowdsourcing the data as a community project, up until they decided to lock it up.
- nuclear_eclipse 14y agoThat "contract" you had with all those sites specifically stated that the business could change the terms of the contract at any time in the future. If you don't like that stipulation, then don't agree to those terms and don't use those services.
- jetti 14y agoYou can't just unilaterally change a contract and expect it to be valid. My understanding of things like this is so that if things do change, the company can offer up a new TOS/contract which would supersede the previous.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe problem is that it's a service and they never promised they would keep providing it under the same terms forever. So when they change the terms, you can stop using it, but you can't (if the new terms are enforceable) demand to keep using it under the old terms, any more than you could demand they keep offering the service if they decided to shut it down. On the other hand, we've all now all got always-on always-connected computers in our pockets that already have more computing power than typical web servers a decade ago, so maybe somebody will write some software and that whole personal server thing will finally take off soon.
- jerf 14y agoWil's point about companies using information about you that you did not provide, and in fact have no relationship with, business or otherwise, is a more interesting one. For some people, contact information is a very sensitive matter, and celebrities are the uninteresting case, compared to those being stalked, witness protection, etc. How are we going to deal with this? Especially in light of the fact that the data is essentially unprotectable. It is not often observed that "DRM in general is impossible" doesn't just apply to media conglomerates, but to people as well; there's no way to DRM your phone number or address, either. So that's pretty much out. What's next?
- bad_user 14y agoThe problem here is not that "DRM in general is impossible" and I fail to see how DRM could solve the issue with Instagram, even if DRM wasn't totally broken. Facebook can access your phone contacts and Instagram can access your photos only with your consent. You're willingly giving them that data. The far bigger issue here is that services like Instagram can take and use your data without your consent indirectly. If I give your photo or your phone number or your location to some service and that action brings you harm, who's to blame and whom can you sue? I'm not a lawyer, but I bet it's not going to be Instagram or Facebook or the other offenders out there ;-) And DRM here is meaningless.
- jerf 14y agoYou don't own somebody's phone number because you have it in your contact DB. You are willingly giving them the phone numbers of everyone in your phone book... your contacts are not giving their consent to having their data sent wherever. DRM would, hypothetically, solve the problem of giving your phone number to somebody but not allowing them to share it further without your consent. Except, of course, it doesn't. By the way, because after years on the net I can see this coming from miles away, let me draw a distinction in advance between "I personally don't care about my number being shared without my knowledge out of other people's contact book to arbitrary third parties", and "I don't think anybody else should ever care about having their number shared out of somebody else's contact list with arbitrary other third parties." They aren't the same thing, and if you want to argue the latter point, that can be done without trying to argue that there isn't any consent issue at all, which is simply false. Whether you consider it right or wrong, some things are happening that some people don't want to occur.
- tomjen3 14y agoIf you take a picture of me and upload it on instagram, I have not agreed to their tos and have not voluntarily given them anything. So no, this does not exactly compare with facebook.
- genwin 14y agoThat sounds like the kind of gray area lawyers love. In the years it takes for the court dust to settle, though, you may want to avoid having your picture taken.
- shawn-butler 14y agoYou don't really have any rights to your image taken in a public place. Gets a little dicey when your image is used in a way that could be viewed as you endorsing something, like an ad or a service. For that I use a pretty blanket model release form, but it's a grey area. Unless you are rich and famous. They have their own set of rules.
- anonymouz 14y agoDepends on the jurisdiction I suppose. In Austria, and I believe also Germany and maybe Switzerland, I do have a "right to my own image". That means I'm allowed to control the publication and use of an image if me, with some exceptions (i.e., if I'm not the main motive of the image but just a member of a crowd).
- shawn-butler 14y agoGermany and Austria have some of the most strict privacy laws in the world so they are a good example of the extreme case. In Germany, you do not control the use of the image, only its publication. That is I can take your photo in public and hang it on my own wall. Publication of public figures is pretty much universally allowed. Use of your image taken in public for data purposes (not published) remains controversial. If I take your photograph and you cannot be identified in it, I can publish it without your permission, (say in a crowd or in front of a building as you note, etc)
- kmfrk 14y agoAxiom 5: Company X's only chance of monetization is by IPO or acquisition by Company Y. If Company X is acquired by Company Y, goto Axiom 1 through 5 for Company Y. Independence is also important, when it comes to privacy. I don't know how Tumblr is doing - it seems like it's under some pressure to do a better job of monetization - but there's been this idea of a bubble in social media for years, and it we are beginning realize that in some way we were right. It's just that we didn't consider that companies would pursue the sinister solutions to their fiscal quandaries. Makes you wonder how this makes the investors look.
- pitchups 14y agoAxiom 5: It is possible to monetize free services in numerous ways without violating the privacy of your users, reneging on a TOS they signed earlier, and generally destroying their trust or expectations of fairness.
- res0nat0r 14y agoNote on all of the TOS' they state they can change it at any time in the future for any reason, and you agree to this before you click 'I Accept'.
- rythie 14y agoThese companies do all of the above deliberately until there is no viable competition left. This is a situation they competely created over several years. It's not surprising people are upset when the mass trial period ends and there are no competitors left to move to.
- declan 14y agoYep, we all recognize that companies actually have to cover operating expenses (and I suspect that most people here are capitalistic enough to say a company should ideally make a profit). But if you're going to change the rules once you have millions of users, a prominent notification as opposed to inserting language into the middle of a terms of use policy would seem to make sense. I think Instagram users would be much more willing to listen if the reason and justification for this policy shift were clearly explained and users clearly notified.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jdechko 14y agoAnother possible solution is to do without said service, and realize that there are other alternatives that won't sell your personal information. I've dumped Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Google (with the exception of Reader, and occasional searches when DDG doesn't work right). I can share pictures (Group MMS & Shared Photostreams) and find out what people are doing (texting, phone calls & email) without giving up that information.
- adrianbg 14y agoWhy don't online businesses start offering privacy-conscious customers the option to pay for their services? This seems like a pretty obvious alternative to paying with privacy. I doubt they would even have to charge much for it to be profitable. Also: "axiom"? How about "fact"?
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe problem is that the people willing to pay are exactly the people the advertisers most want to reach. The whole point of all this privacy invasion is to target the people with money who are willing to spend it. You take those people out of the pool and offering a free service no longer makes any sense, because nobody wants to pay to reach the people too cheap to buy stuff. Which leaves you with a pay-only service, competing with a free-only service that consequently has ten times as many users (and therefore much stronger network effects), and the pay service goes out of business. The true problem with all of this is that we're using services for things we should be using products for. You want to share photos with friends? We could do that in 1999 with AOL Instant Messenger. But now Facebook and Instagram have a better UX -- and it has nothing to do with whether they're services. What we need is an open source P2P Instagram. No ads, no paying anybody anything, just photo sharing.
- adrianbg 14y ago> The problem is that the people willing to pay are exactly the people the advertisers most want to reach. So charge more. Instagram et al are trying to make money, not serve advertisers. If privacy-conscious people are willing to pay more than advertisers that's great.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThat would only make the problem worse. The trouble is that the users (including the privacy conscious users) have to go where their friends are to interact with their friends. And the majority of users are not willing to pay money for more privacy, so the advertising-funded service gets the majority of the users, and the privacy conscious users can then either give up their privacy or lose the ability to interact with their not so privacy conscious friends. And they choose the first option in droves (or there just aren't enough privacy conscious people left), so there is no real market for the alternative. I mean think about it: It's not like offering a paid service is rocket science. If there was money to be made there, why isn't anyone making a billion dollars offering it? Why aren't you? Maybe it's an untapped market and no one else has had the vision to serve it. But this is kind of one of those money where your mouth is situations. If you think that market is lucrative enough to be worth chasing, do it. If not, well, apparently no one else does either, so here we are.
- dgurney 14y agoBetter way for Instagram to move forward: Change the app to $0.99 and avoid this advertising shitstorm-in-waiting.
- st0p 14y agoIn the long run, this is not a viable business model. Servers might get cheaper every day, but you're still going to have to pay for them every month your service is up and running.
- shanev 14y agoFacebook makes $36/user per year, on average. They are mostly about photos. Instagram knows this. $0.99 will be cutting it way too short. I don't understand why companies like this don't just offer an ad-free pay option with a stronger privacy policy as an alternative to their free option and make everyone happy, except the total freeloaders who want free and their privacy protected. Seems to work fine for Flickr.
- clarky07 14y agoCan I have a link for that stat? If I recall they are around 1 billion users. I'm quite certain they didn't make 36 billion last year... Actual numbers - 4.64B revenue. 400M profit. http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=FB http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=FB
- baddox 14y agoThere's a big difference between being surprised by behavior and simply not liking it. Being surprised by Instagram's intent to monetize is unreasonable, but it's fine to dislike it.
- easytiger 14y agocan't see how this won't become a shitstorm
- pretoriusB 14y ago>So Instagram is now going to use photos taken by its users in advertising, and they may or may not disclose to viewers when the advertising is happening. No, they are NOT going to do that. It's 2012. Why are people --and especially someone like Wheaton-- behaving like it's 1994 and they are learning this "web" thing for the first time? I've seen the same bloody story play up 10 or 20 times. They made a BS change on their license terms, they are is gonna be a small fuss from their users about it and they are gonna revert it. It's not like Instagram-the-company even intended to do that in the first place -- most likely they screwed up the phrasing but meant something extremely more limited (like: we'd have be able to use your pics when advertising Instagram-the-app itself). Instead, people are acting like Instagram was really going to sell their photos and not pay them, and like this thing won't be revoked in less than a month. That is absurd. Why? 1) The backslash from the users, especially with 2-3 active competitors against the company (Twitter, which added photo filters to its app, being the latest heavyweight). 2) The lawsuits from users their photos they did attempt to sell. 3) It's not a way to make money, anyway. Instagram is not a Getty Images like company -- and limited size pictures with cliched filters is not exactly a stock image market. Getty actually partners with Flickr, which has actual photos of ALL kinds and PAYS the photographer if it uses the pictures, but it's not like anything lucrative came out of it, for either Flickr, Getty or the users.
- imgabe 14y ago> The backslash from the users Yes, this backlash from users is exactly what's happening. You can't simultaneously try to dissuade the backlash from happening and depend on it to prevent the undesirable events from taking place.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>Yes, this backlash from users is exactly what's happening. You can't simultaneously try to dissuade the backlash from happening and depend on it to prevent the undesirable events from taking place. No, but I CAN and AM expecting people participating in the backlash: a) NOT to behave like it's the first time they are seeing this b) NOT to behave like this move was intended as perceived, and c) NOT to behave like this wont be reverted pronto. And I expect this especially from internet savvy people like Wheaton, who have seen this play out tens of times on the nets with similar licence changes... Had Wheaton written something like "I'm sure this is another one of countless examples of ill-thought and quickly reverted license changes" I would be totally OK. The way it is now, it's like someone writing "Oh, my god, Charlie Brown was tricked again by Lucy, I don't believe it!!!!" for paragraph after paragraph. Not to mention that I also presented several other reasons besides the backlash why this is a non-story (for one, it's inconceivable as a business move, when a competitor, Twitter, just turned on "kill mode", second it doesn't make sense as a monetization tactic, it's not like hipster filtered photos are a stock photo favorite, or stock photography itself is a large market).
- zipop 14y agoHow Instagram uses celebrity photos is not at the top of my list of concerns.
- camus 14y agoInteresting. There are a few things though : - Facebook did prove it : most users dont read/care about TOS ( CGU here ), as long as they get stuff for free. You can do the most outrageous things with user data ( google ), people dont mind as long as they get value out of the service. > Seth Green walking through an Urban Outfitters, does that mean Urban Outfitters can take that image and use it to create an implied endorsement by Seth? - Unless walking through an Urban Outfitters requires agreeing with TOS before entering it, the exemple is irrelevant. When you sign up for facegoogram , you basically sign a binding contract. Wether the terms are fair , or even legal or not, it is another issue.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- OafTobark 14y agoI'll be honest. If it wasn't for Big Bang Theory, I'd have no clue who this guy was. Even with reference to Star Trek, I can't remember his character. Not sure why I'd care about his opinion on a semi-tech related topic (I know, not about me and my own opinion).
- mpyne 14y agoI'm pretty sure this is posted because it's a fairly-well-known blogger (which Wil is, now) talking about the Instagram TOS topic and not just because it's some redshirt from Star Trek.
- hellweaver666 14y agoWil was never a redshirt. He was the son of the ships doctor who (if I remember rightly) became the ships ensign, joined Star-Fleet and later went off to explore other planes of existence with an alien known as "The Traveller".
- FootballMuse 14y agoRedshirt (ensign): http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/File:Wesley_Crusher,_2366.jpg http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/File:Wesley_Crusher,_2366.jp...
- jpitz 14y agoDespite his attire, Crusher was not a redshirt: http://gamerjargon2.wikispaces.com/red+shirt http://gamerjargon2.wikispaces.com/red+shirt
- EdiX 14y agoYou are the first person to complain they can't remember Wesley Crusher.
- debacle 14y agoBecause he's very active in the digital rights arena (and especially video games).
- jfb 14y agoA blog post musing about the threat to agency posed by free to use services that rely on farming personal data for revenue posted on … Google Plus?
- aroberge 14y agoThere is a HUGE difference between a company using personal data about you to target marketing to you, and company taking data (photos in this case) provided by you (or by a third party about you) and using it to market products to others. If I see an ad about (insert product name) in my (insert Google product) stream, it is something that only I can see. If you see a picture of me (perhaps uploaded by a "friend" to a site like instagram) used to advertised products to you, then my privacy has been severely breached.
- notatoad 14y agoGoogle has an ad network. I know they are collecting data about me and using it to deliver targeted advertising to me. I also know that the information google collects on me is their competitive advantage, and it's in their best interests not to sell it to a 3rd party. You should only be afraid of services that have to apparent revenue model, because you've got no idea what they're doing with your data. When the use of your data is clear and well known, you can make an informed decision on whether or not to use the service.
- jws 14y agoThe celebrity angle is interesting here. I eventually killed a little product because it was too hard to legally acquire face shots of celebrities and it just didn't have enough zing without pictures by names. If enough celebrities used Instagram, and Instagram could figure out their accounts, they could open autopaparazzi.com.
- polshaw 14y agoWikipedia? And surely you could just buy shots of them?
- pavel_lishin 14y agoMaybe there were too many to reasonably buy for a small product, or maybe the names were generated 'on the fly'?
- jws 14y agoQuantity, price, administrative overhead, and dynamic creation all played into it.
- joonix 14y agoWhat? There are plenty of photo services that will license you photos of celebrities. Getty Images for one. We're not talking about publicity shy people here.
- tghw 14y agoIt depends on the use. If you are using the photos for news purposes, then yes, this works. But if you are using it for commercial purposes, then you would also need a release showing that the person (celebrity or not) received sufficient compensation for the use of their likeness. Without that, you can be sued very easily.
- phjohnst 14y agoI think that's less the issue here than CBS likely holding the commercial rights to Kaley Cuoco and Melissa Rauch being used together in anything that would look like an ad. Presumably it will be in violation of Instagram's TOS to post the kind of pic that he talks about. (See Rights 4.(ii) ) But as he alludes to, it should make it interesting when someone does.
- wtvanhest 14y agoIt seems that the vast majority users are 100% OK with giving up some level of privacy for free service. I consider myself fully within that group and do not mind targeted ads for example. I believe where users draw the line is when a service uses their content to distribute to others for a fee. Using images, essentially intellectual property, is not OK with me. Nor am I a fan of Facebook using my name in sponsored likes. The later bothers me less, but it still annoys me that it is happening. Part of this is the fact that when you first logged on to facebook, you viewed it as a way to share in a fairly private network with your friends. Now your habits must change to protect yourself, but you have no alternative (yet). I don’t have an answer to the problem with how free networks should grow, but personally, I am opposed to any use of my content as a distribution or free use of images. Now I feel that I have to protect myself by not posting photos to facebook in case they one day change their policy.
- shizzy0 14y agoYou are the product.
- debacle 14y agoThe celebrity angle is an interesting one, because based on previous contracts a celebrity may not be able to grant Instagram the rights it outlines in its TOS - they may already be granted to another entity.
- ianstallings 14y agoThis is dubious at best. He doesn't use it, he's not a lawyer, and his grasp on what they are doing is plain wrong. I'm not saying that privacy concerns are moot. I'm saying Wil Wheaton is your typical self-proclaimed geek these days. He shoots from the hip at anything that might trounce his sense of entitlement.
- div 14y agoWould you mind elaborating on how his grasp on what they're doing is plain wrong ? Specifically, how is his example of a celebrity's silly picture being used by Instagram to advertise a silly product plain wrong ? I also fail to see how he comes across as entitled in his post. He's merely expressing a concern, one that, at face value, seems to be pretty valid.
- stevesearer 14y agoI feel like most people complaining about the whole 'Instagram will use photos in advertisements' make it seem like the advertisements are going to be on television or newspapers, etc. Or that said advertisements will say "Celebrity X uses IG, you should too". To me is seems like the ads are going to be more along the lines of promoted restaurants and/or venues using photos the people you follow have taken. IG basically knows where everyone goes based on people voluntarily tagging images, and can now serve ads based on that in the same way FB serves ads from pages you like. An ad that says, 'Your friend recently went to X (with a photo they took at said venue)', is a pretty engaging advertisement in my mind.
- peterevans 14y agoSo what, in his grasp, was wrong? I'm curious. He says "Instagram is now going to use photos taken by its users in advertising, and they may or may not disclose to viewers when the advertising is happening" -- is that incorrect? That's pretty much the only assertion he makes that could be factually wrong. Everything else in there is his opinion, which isn't "plain wrong"; it's just his opinion, just as it is yours that he's "your typical self-proclaimed geek these days" and "shoots from the hip at anything that might trounce his sense of entitlement."
- zaidf 14y agoMeanwhile just to read this post, I must accept some google+ TOS and create my nth g+ account: Mobile terms of service By tapping 'Accept', you agree that Google will use your location in this product and accept the Mobile Terms of Service.
- BitMastro 14y agoNo you don't. You need to join g+ only to reply to the post, but didn't I need to join HN to reply to your post?
- zaidf 14y agoWere you logged into a google account? I was logged in and got the above screen. I was not trying to reply--kind of hard to when you can't even read the post.
- jonursenbach 14y agoIf I open the link in an incognito window, I can read the post just fine.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI didn't get a prompt on desktop or mobile.
- pseut 14y agoI got the same thing because I was signed into gmail. After I logged out I could read the post w/out having to accept g+.
- rmc 14y agoJust as we have a "do not track" option for our webbrowsing habits, we're going to need to have something similar for other aspects of our increasingly-digital lives: Sounds like the EU's Data Protection law. Making it illegal to store personal information about people unless they have opted in, etc.
- goatcurious 14y agoDoes paying for a service help keep my data private? For example, if I'm a paid user at Linkedin - does that mean they would treat my data differently than that of the free users?
- drcube 14y agoNo. It used to be that you didn't get ads on cable TV because you already paid for the channels. Then the ads came anyway. Just because you pay for an internet service doesn't mean you avoided the privacy concerns that plague free services. At best you just postponed them.
- goatcurious 14y agoAgreed. Exactly my problem with the catch all argument that all these concerns will go away if we buy the service.
- IheartApplesDix 14y agosorry everyone, internet is closed.
- alpb 14y agoGoogle+ is no different: 11.2 you agree that this license includes a right for google to make such content available to other companies, organizations or individuals with whom google has relationships for the provision of syndicated services, and to use such content in connection with the provision of those services. 11.3 you understand that google, in performing the required technical steps to provide the services to our users, may (a) transmit or distribute your content over various public networks and in various media; and (b) make such changes to your content as are necessary to conform and adapt that content to the technical requirements of connecting networks, devices, services or media. you agree that this license shall permit google to take these actions.
- 89a 14y ago"Wil Wheaton on… PLEASE PLEASE DON'T FORGET ABOUT ME PLEASE" Would be a better title
- takluyver 14y agoThe current version of the TOS say, in part: When you upload or otherwise submit content to our Services, you give Google (and those we work with) a worldwide license to use, host, store, reproduce, modify, create derivative works (such as those resulting from translations, adaptations or other changes we make so that your content works better with our Services), communicate, publish, publicly perform, publicly display and distribute such content. The rights you grant in this license are for the limited purpose of operating, promoting, and improving our Services, and to develop new ones. IANAL, but I don't think that includes a right to sell (sub-license) your content.
- minwcnt5 14y agoYup, this came up during the uproar when Google changed their privacy policy earlier this year. IIRC this language is needed to let them share your data across services. e.g. showing your profile photo as part of their social search results might quality as "publicly display". Google's current privacy policy includes the statement: "We believe personal information should not be held hostage and we are committed to building products that let users export their personal information to other services. We don’t sell users’ personal information."
- epsylon 14y ago"If you're not paying for it, you're the product being sold."
- 89a 14y agoIronic he's posting this one G+ and probably has a Facebook account. Why do people give him the time of day
- tghw 14y agoWhile he's very much on the right track here, his mention of celebrities muddles the point somewhat. In most states (perhaps all), it is illegal to use someone's likeness for advertising without their consent. This is regardless of their status as a celebrity or not. This is why photographers who think their photos might be used commercially should get model releases from any identifiable persons in their photos. They should also give copies of those releases to any company that wants to use the photo commercially, so that company can defend themselves if the model tries to sue. The Photo Attorney blog has a more detailed article about it: http://www.photoattorney.com/2009/05/when-you-definitely-need-model-release.html http://www.photoattorney.com/2009/05/when-you-definitely-nee...
- wheaties 14y agoSo what you're saying is that unless it's a photograph of themselves or a shot sans people, they won't be able to use it?
- mistercow 14y ago>In most states (perhaps all), it is illegal to use someone's likeness for advertising without their consent. This is regardless of their status as a celebrity or not. It's not all states, and it's not entirely clear cut in many states (it depends on how the likeness is used), and their TOS does give permission to use your likeness (which means that if the person in the photo is also an Instagram user, they have a tougher case). But Instagram would certainly be playing with fire if they tried that with a celebrity, and I don't think they would. It's your ordinary folks who can't afford to lawyer up against a huge corporation that are more likely to be affected by this.
- rescripting 14y agoI think the point you're making here is separate from the original article. It's always been a bit of a grey area that you can take a picture of someone and post it on InstaFlickaFacebookOGram without their consent. However Will's point is that Instagram's new agreement may compromise a user's ability to manage their personal brand, because their photos are no longer their own. If I'm Will Wheaton and I post a photo of myself having a good time at Disney Land, I don't want Disney Land taking that photo and using it in their ads. Since it's a photo of myself the photo release issue isn't the problem, since I've forfeited that right to sue by agreeing to Instagram's new agreement.
- mistercow 14y ago[Obligatory IANAL Warning yada yada] The question of whether they can use someone's likeness is an interesting one, and the answer to that apparently varies from state to state. Instagram could probably get you to sign away the right to use your own likeness in their ads, but that wouldn't apply to people who don't use their service. I'm not sure how jurisdictions of other states apply (any actual lawyers want to weigh in?) but Instagram is based in California where (if you can believe it), publicity rights are quite strong (even dead celebrities get protection there). There's a little gray area that Instagram could exploit there, but I think the example Wheaton described there would be a pretty easy meal for Rauch's lawyers. At the very least, Instagram's legal team would almost certainly say "fuck no" if the marketing department showed them an ad like that without getting permission to use her likeness.
- andrewcooke 14y agopart of the problem here is that wil wheaton's price for "selling his privacy" is higher than that of many others (largely because he is a celeb and so has more earning potential there), but the current mechanism has no way to manage a range of values. it's possible a more sophisticated "privacy market" could solve these issues.
- taylorbuley 14y agoThis is yet another reminder that if you're using a product and not paying for it then you are the product.
- pokstad 14y agoWhile tech related sites like hacker news get concerned about these matters, I'm pretty sure most Instagram users don't care about these privacy policies just like most Facebook user's haven't cared. They get to use a fun cool product for free and everything else happens behind the scenes (out of sight out of mind).
- danboarder 14y agoThe direction Instagram is going is similar to what Facebook does already with what I'll call "endorsement advertising". I've noticed ads where it says something like "your friend Dave likes Verizon", with a clear link to an ad. I then ask Dave if he recently "Liked" verizon and he says "No, but maybe a year ago or something for a contest". So they are selling our likes as endorsements to brands already. Instagram wants to do this with photos, I expect. A photo of you driving a Prius might link to a Toyota brand page after you follow the Toyota instagram profile, for example.
- songgao 14y agoThis must be off topic but it's the first time I know Wil Wheaton is a real person. I thought he was a virtual figure in The Big Bang Theory...
- MartinCron 14y agoStop whatever it is you are doing and watch Star Trek: The Next Generation.
- 001sky 14y agoif I'm in someone's address book, and they use an app that grants the developer full, unfettered access to their address book, I've now had my information given without my consultation or consent to a developer, and I never even knew it was happening. == It used to be "pick your friends wisely" But now, that's before the meaning of the term was of a different sort.