3 ms·
This is a very nice and heartwarming piece -- especially the part where the OP can't board the helicopter and has to drive hundreds of miles alone, into the nig
by bambax 14y ago
This is a very nice and heartwarming piece -- especially the part where the OP can't board the helicopter and has to drive hundreds of miles alone, into the night, not knowing what might happen to his wife and their (yet unborn) daughter. Must have been a very long drive.
Like many others however I was a little surprised, and, yes, disappointed with the "God" part at the end. Is this what it was all about?
What does "God" has to do with any of this? Can't one love their children, their partners, their siblings, with all their hearts, and leave it at that...?
What is "the personification of all that is Good"? What is Good? (Good for you may be bad for someone else; absolute good is hard; historically, Gods have not been known to be good: they were jealous, mean creatures). And even admitting there would be some "absolute good", why would it need to be "personified"?
The finale reads a little like this: Gods other people believe in are "false Gods", and guess what? the God I believe in / custom built to my specs is the One True God.
This, for me, I'm sorry to say, ruined a perfect moment.
- stephengillie 14y agoI also felt this was a great story ruined at the end. The author is talking about the terrorific (terror-filled) ride of his daughter's birth and young life, then flops over to a children's tale about one all-powerful being wanting more followers than a different all-powerful being. What do these all-powerful beings have to do with his daughter and her struggle to live? What does it have to do with all of the doctors and nurses who cared for his daughter? Why thank this all-powerful being who did nothing for your child, but take for granted all of the people who worked to help her?
- discreteevent 14y agoAll I can say is that if you have a sick child who is suffering and in danger it is quite different to any kind of trouble you have experienced before. It is very hard to take this on your own shoulders. It helps a lot to have a feeling that there is something bigger out there. You don't have to call it God. But logic etc is of no help in this kind of situation as it is by definition out of your control. This is where all your established positions mean nothing. So whether it is true or not that there is something else I imagine that the feeling that there is is what helps many people keep it together when they would crumble if they felt there were only people and logic in the universe, there's nothing out there, we live, we die, we are just machines that are programmed to reproduce etc. Keeping it together at a time like this can be very important so you take whatever help you can get. And if you feel you got it then it would be untrue to yourself not to be grateful later.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoI think it says a lot about you that you're so excited to fight with someone who believes in an omnipotent god that you've projected that belief onto Paul Buchheit and have taken up the fight on Hacker News. You might be better off finding someone who actually believes that. From what I tell by reading his actual words--and of course such summaries are fraught with peril--Paul's god is the collection of structures which offer "unconditional love" in the world. I see no mention of omnipotence. Then to answer your questions: 1) He described being 'reduced' to unconditional love during his daughter's struggle. 2) Nothing, really. He seems to be talking about the doctors and nurses only as background information for his experience. 3) Paul didn't thank his god in this post at all, nor did he disregard the doctor's and nurses. In fact, most of his story has to do with the doctors and nurses and what they did, and very little about gods. You seem, again, to be projecting the beliefs of... well, I don't know who... your parents? Sarah Palin? ... on Paul.
- ScottBurson 14y agoWell, I like Paul's little story, and I share his belief that God does not sow fear and hatred, and that when one is confronted by claims about what God allegedly thinks or says, asking whether these reflect unconditional love is a great way to tell how much weight to give them.