3 ms·
Actually, the article (among other things) expresses concern about one of these nominees having taken part in one of the most notorious acts of scientific censo
by gruseom 18y ago
Actually, the article (among other things) expresses concern about one of these nominees having taken part in one of the most notorious acts of scientific censorship in our time. I didn't know that, and the author's concern seems reasonable.
Edit: I'm talking about Scientific American's vendetta against Bjorn Lomborg, during which they not only refused to publish his response, but threatened to sue for copyright infringement when he put it online, denying him permission to quote the passages he was defending himself against. If I recall correctly, Lomborg did as SA demanded (crippling his own rebuttal), which prompted one of the founders of Greenpeace to put the whole thing up on his own website, saying that while he didn't agree with Lomborg he disagreed with censorship more.
- Retric 18y agoAt the cost of ~5% of the US GDP/year for 20 years we could get our net carbon emissions below 10% of where they are today. Granted few people seem to think this is a worthwhile investment (I don't know), but it's not like it's pie in they sky fairyland talk either. One approach would be: Solar home / hot water heaters for every home / building in the continental US. (Pointless in Alaska) This would pay for it's self fairly quickly so IMO it's a good idea. Power the grid with a combination of Wind, Thermal Solar, Hydro, and Nuclear, with large grid connected energy storage systems. This pays off in the long term, but it's expensive. Electrify the nations highways, so electric cars can cross the country without backup power. Also add charging stations to most parking lots. This is where things get really expensive and there is not an off the shelf solution for this. So, the real question becomes how far down that path you take before the costs outweigh the benefits. Which is where knowing how much damage you get based on what level of carbon output. While politicians might not like the answers, it's a reasonable scientific debate, with a definitive answer.
- ewanmcteagle 18y agoIt's not a scientific debate and there may not be a definitive answer. This is where smart people often go astray. Not everyone has the same preferences or treats risk in the same manner. Anytime you start saying cost-benefit analysis you have to deal with the issue that there isn't one cost-benefit analysis. That makes it not science. 5% of GDP is huge but it doesn't have the same effect on each person in a society. There's also no way to take 5% of GDP without undesirable side-effects and those also have unpredictable distribution.
- gruseom 18y agoI see no connection between my comment and your reply.
- Retric 18y ago"author's concern seems reasonable" though I read it as concerns implying you agree with the articles ideas. If your are only talking about that one point I am sorry.