4 ms·

Lost me at “low AI exhaust from those setting technical direction should raise questions” Wonder what Linus Torvalds’ AI exhaust is??

schipperai 1mo ago
I’d agree Linus is an exceptional leader. And I don’t think most rules apply to him.
pydry 1mo ago
Linus used it to make some toy software I believe.
- oliculipolicula 1mo ago
  [Disclaimer: no AI whatsoever was used in any part of the following; sorry if you can't verify that, though] I've come to think that one unequivocal upside of "affordable ASI" would be to bring about a world of discourse where discursers would hesitate to think of (not to mention carry) themselves as experts. What would be the point? Everyone already knows that everyone has direct access to an expert. [Perhaps it reminds me of Le Guin's thoughts on tech X power, especially as represented in The Dispossessed ] it would seem to be not just rude, but even snide, to bias your interlocutor towards not carefully verifying the dependencies of your exhaust! [In your example, Linus, as a sneak preview of that alt-world in ours, is probably totally OK with not being regarded as an expert in making toy software] Widely dispersed and affordable AI would help because it (certainly, imho) makes the alternative, "trust but verify", so easy [No need to think about the downsides of checking out and pointing Claude at lines of Linus' toy!] And it would be strictly easier than using cloud chatGPT to sow misinformation because there are extra steps in that (--- nonsockpuppets would be inclined to verify the gist of everything they are about to say as indeed misleading) [As a bonus, this seems compatible with TFA, non-ideological anti-anti-intellectualism, and https://engines.egr.uh.edu/episode/1495 https://engines.egr.uh.edu/episode/1495 if, in that "non-anarchist" alt-world, we all assume that technical leaders should be different (not more, not less) than expert engineers Should exceptional technical direction setters strive to stay anonymous..? Or use sockpuppets? Moral as well as practical quandaries..! ]

schipperai 1mo ago

I’d agree Linus is an exceptional leader. And I don’t think most rules apply to him.

pydry 1mo ago

Linus used it to make some toy software I believe.

oliculipolicula 1mo ago
[Disclaimer: no AI whatsoever was used in any part of the following; sorry if you can't verify that, though] I've come to think that one unequivocal upside of "affordable ASI" would be to bring about a world of discourse where discursers would hesitate to think of (not to mention carry) themselves as experts. What would be the point? Everyone already knows that everyone has direct access to an expert. [Perhaps it reminds me of Le Guin's thoughts on tech X power, especially as represented in The Dispossessed ] it would seem to be not just rude, but even snide, to bias your interlocutor towards not carefully verifying the dependencies of your exhaust! [In your example, Linus, as a sneak preview of that alt-world in ours, is probably totally OK with not being regarded as an expert in making toy software] Widely dispersed and affordable AI would help because it (certainly, imho) makes the alternative, "trust but verify", so easy [No need to think about the downsides of checking out and pointing Claude at lines of Linus' toy!] And it would be strictly easier than using cloud chatGPT to sow misinformation because there are extra steps in that (--- nonsockpuppets would be inclined to verify the gist of everything they are about to say as indeed misleading) [As a bonus, this seems compatible with TFA, non-ideological anti-anti-intellectualism, and https://engines.egr.uh.edu/episode/1495 https://engines.egr.uh.edu/episode/1495 if, in that "non-anarchist" alt-world, we all assume that technical leaders should be different (not more, not less) than expert engineers Should exceptional technical direction setters strive to stay anonymous..? Or use sockpuppets? Moral as well as practical quandaries..! ]