3 ms·
Which of course is why she didn't say it. A Judge will often do something like: It's wrong because of X, but even if X doesn't apply then it's still wrong beca
by ars 14y ago
Which of course is why she didn't say it.
A Judge will often do something like: It's wrong because of X, but even if X doesn't apply then it's still wrong because of Y.
It's telling that she didn't do that here. (Unless she did and the article just doesn't mention it.)
For example (from this same ruling):
> U.S District Judge Lucy Koh noted that Samsung claims to have "worked around" using different technology than the Apple patents found to have been infringed such as the iPhone's popular "pinch to zoom" feature.
> And even if that's a false claim, the judge ruled, Apple's demands to yank the Samsung products from U.S. shelves and bar future sales was too broad of a punishment in devices built with technology backed by hundreds of patents each.
Quoted from: http://bigstory.ap.org/article/judge-denies-apple-request-ban-samsung-phones http://bigstory.ap.org/article/judge-denies-apple-request-ba...
- eridius 14y agoI don't think that's analogous. In your quoted example, if the judge left it at just the "because of X", then someone could come along and say "here's why X doesn't apply", and she'd have to revisit it. But this way she's saying "even if you disprove X, my ruling stands because of Y". However, in the case of inadmissible evidence, it seems there's no risk of someone coming along and saying "but it is admissible after all", because it's pretty clear that it's not.