5 ms·
I'm not the biggest fan of Microsoft in the mobile world, but until they launched Windows 8, I actually thought the idea of the "hybrid" device might work, and
by mtgx 14y ago
I'm not the biggest fan of Microsoft in the mobile world, but until they launched Windows 8, I actually thought the idea of the "hybrid" device might work, and may be the future of both tablets and PC's. You can use it as a PC when you need it, and as a tablet, when you don't. Best of both worlds, right?
Wrong. When I started using Windows 8, I realized it's actually the worst of both worlds. If you want both in the same package, then you have to live with a ton of compromises. Here are some of them:
1) You can't have a large screen, if you want to use it as a tablet, too. Maybe 11" at most, and that includes hybrid devices more like Surface, with light weight tablet parts, and detachable keyboard. The ones like Lenovo Yoga are completely unusable as tablets, unless you intend to use a "tablet" on your desk all the time, at which point, what's the difference compared to just using a touchscreen laptop?
2) Then 10-11" screens are not very usable for real work as a PC, so you have to compromise a lot in that, too.
3) 10-11" is pretty large and heavy for a tablet, and it seems most people are starting to gravitate towards 8" or smaller tablets, which makes it even more likely that people will want the tablet and the PC as 2 different devices in the future.
4) If you want a "hybrid", then you're forced to use x86 chips, and unless you want the performance of a netbook, you need Core chips inside. These have 3 major drawbacks: low battery life, heat/noise, and high price tags.
5) Windows RT devices, while a bit better on the tablet part, because of the ARM advantages (better battery life and more competitive prices), can't seriously be called "hybrids". They only have Office for PC use.
6) 13" or higher "hybrids" are also a joke, as you can't seriously use them as tablets.
7) You're still forced to use or avoid the "touch mode", even when you want to use it as a PC. I consider Windows 8 worse for a PC user than Windows 7. I brings a lot of new stuff that are there to annoy the PC user, not help him. Whatever small benefits it has over Windows 7, they are not worth it for the worse user experience. And this is for the more "techie" of the PC users. For "normal" mom and pop users, they are going to find it even worse, after using XP/Windows 7 for so long, and now having to basically learn and unlearn a ton of new stuff, which is not easy for this type of user.
So whichever way you go, either more towards the PC part, or the tablet part, you're going to run into major compromises, if you want to use a single device as both PC and tablet. So I don't think anymore that hybrids are the future, as they seem to do either one part pretty badly, or be mediocre at both. You're better off keeping these two type of devices separated.
- batiudrami 14y agoI assumed that (not now, but in 5 years time), you'll bring your 7" or 10" tablet home, plug it into its dock (a-la laptop docks now), which will hook it up to your full size mouse and keyboard, and your 27" high resolution monitor. It'll have enough processing power to do what most people need from a machine, and when you need to go out, you grab it out of its dock, and all your programs, files and settings are with you, running on their tablet-optimised version. This is the end game as I see it and I'm pretty convinced this is what Microsoft is planning for. If that's the way it goes, they have a huge head start over Apple who are insisting on keeping OSX and iOS separate.
- mbreese 14y agoThis has already been tried by OQO in the early 2000's. Verdict was: it was a nice concept, but ultimately didn't work real well. The OXO ran a full copy of Wondows, so you theoretically had the same experience with the small built in screen and the full docked mode. Unfortunately, getting things switched from tablet to PC mode didn't seem to work real well. Ultimately, the tablet was too big and the docked PC was underpowered. If you want a dock able experience, I think we'll see something closer to the Linux transformer tablets. It is an ordinary tablet, but when plugged into a dock, the dock has a more powerful processor (and more energy hungry) and takes over. In this mode, the tablet isn't much more than an external hard drive. I think it was Lenovo that made these, but I can't remember.
- cpeterso 14y ago> you'll bring your 7" or 10" tablet home, plug it into its dock (a-la laptop docks now), which will hook it up to your full size mouse and keyboard, and your 27" high resolution monitor. Why stop there? The dock will probably have its own processor that can run the tablet apps faster, possibly enabling desktop features. Microsoft could really push this because they own the desktop market but have a weak toehold in the tablet market.
- danieldk 14y agoThis is the end game as I see it and I'm pretty convinced this is what Microsoft is planning for. If that's the way it goes, they have a huge head start over Apple who are insisting on keeping OSX and iOS separate. I don't see much of an advantage for Microsoft here. Metro is another world than the traditional desktop, and Metro applications are only really fit for tablets and phones. So, a hybrid will probably keep a desktop/tablet UI separation. Since iOS and OS X build on the same technologies, Apple could, if they wanted to, release a hybrid system in no time. In fact, the iPhone/iPad simulator already uses Cocoa Touch on the same architecture and platform as OS X. Besides that, Apple has an App Store filled with tablet apps and desktop apps. Not just tablet apps.