4 ms·
> Anyone promoting the idea of subverting the constitution through perceived loopholes should really question their principles. What is the purpose of the Cons
by rdtsc 14y ago
> Anyone promoting the idea of subverting the constitution through perceived loopholes should really question their principles.
What is the purpose of the Constitution? Is it like the 10 Commandments that have been passed down from the sky and now we have to worship it unquestionably? There are large numbers of people in this country that seem to believe so.
So take the gun issue. Why is that in the constitution? For hunting? Protecting from bears? Foreign invaders? Maybe. Would it make a difference now if anyone attacked us if we all carried guns? Probably not. We'll probably use our drones and tanks to fight back. Maybe it was for people to protect from an abusive government? Is that realistic today? You'd need to be able to bear tanks, helicopters and fighter planes if this hypothetical militia is ever to even register as a blip on government's threat radar. So why even bother both defending the idea or trying to find a loophole to bypass it. Both seem rather pointless to me.
Are people defending themselves better with guns? Canada and other countries have legal guns and don't seem to have issues with such crimes as we saw recently. Some countries outlaw guns and experience much worse violence. Is there any credible study that shows a linkage between legal arms position and violent crime?
- staunch 14y agoArguing about the merits of second amendment (or first amendment, for that matter) is reasonable. Suggesting that the government pass laws that subvert The Constitution is not.
- arjunnarayan 14y agoRight. This is the Scalia philosophy. Don't like the constitution? Go ahead and amend it.
- staunch 14y agoThis is the American philosophy. We've been amending The Constitution since shortly after it was created.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoTrue. Even the gun control issue is hovering around the 2nd Amendment. And then there was the whole amendment to ban alcohol that was then reversed with yet another amendment. So... let's not get locked into some false idea that things can't be changed. We need to focus on what changes (if any) make sense and when. Maybe changes don't make sense right now... but if the first argument is "but the Constitution says so" then look at what actually got it to say so... it was a change.
- Zak 14y agoIt's about policy and mechanism. Let's assume for a moment that severely restricting ownership of firearms and ammunition is a good policy. The mechanism necessary to do it in the straightforward way - a constitutional amendment - is almost impossibly difficult. Perhaps a roundabout mechanism would be easier. If that sort of thing was allowed by the courts (it isn't), similar end-runs around the constitution could be used to do things you might not be so happy about. The fourth amendment, for example says people have the right to be "secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures". It doesn't say anything about tapping your phone or using a laser microphone on your window, but the courts have held that it means a warrant is required to do those things just as it is to search your house. It's much easier to change policy than mechanism. You probably don't actually want a mechanism for bypassing constitutional rights at will in place.
- Lazare 14y agoExactly. The point of the constitution isn't to protect the popular rights; popular opinion will do that. The constitution is there to protect the unpopular rights; the ones that, for whatever reason, seem out of place, outdated, downright silly. (The same argument applies to individual rights. The right to free speech protects both popular and unpopular speech, but you don't actually need protections to talk about how awesome a cure for cancer would be. It's the unpopular opinions that need protection. And people say "well, I support free speech, but that shouldn't mean these people get to spill their filth and hate in public venues!" But that's exactly what it means; the only purpose a right to free speech serves is to protect what is (for now) deemed dangerous, stupid, crazy speech. Because just because something is unpopular now doesn't mean it will always be.) There's always some wonderful reason why abridging some fundamental right is a good idea. Terrorists. Communists. Neo-nazis. Actual nazis. School shootings. Pearl Harbour. The 1919 Anarchist Bombings. And in retrospect, sometimes they were good reasons, but not always. And so we have constitutional rights specifically to stop us from enacting the really obvious clever solutions to the problems of the day. That's the point.
- rdtsc 14y agoWell ok but what is the purpose of the gun amendment? This is getting back to my original question, do we know the purpose and use of the Constitutions or are we just following it like a holy commandment passed down from above? I can see the purpose of the "Free Speech" it makes sense today more than ever. What is the purpose of the "right to bear arms" how does it apply? You say: > The constitution is there to protect the unpopular rights What if unpopular rights are those that kill children. What if there was other crazy stuff written in there. Would you still defend it because it was signed by a few guys that started a country a while back in 200+ year ago? > And so we have constitutional rights specifically to stop us from enacting the really obvious clever solutions to the problems of the day. > And so we have constitutional rights specifically to stop us from enacting the really obvious clever solutions to the problems of the day. Ok but doesn't that imply that the founding fathers somehow foresaw the advent of nuclear arms, school shootings, the internet and created a concise set of laws that would prevent us from sneaking in laws by creating loopholes. I doubt they did.