7 ms·
No, Really, Regulate the Bullets
- endianswap 14y agoMy problem with this is two-fold: 1. Spree killings still happen without guns (see the similar school attacks in Asia where bladed weapons were used.) 2. This focuses the conversation on the tools used in the incident instead of the source of the problem: mental health.
- beedogs 14y agoIt's about statistics. Reduce the supply of ammunition (especially the kind of ammunition used in assault weapons), and you will reduce the number of mass murders, by a measurable amount. (And yes, I agree that the way the US and most Western countries treat their mentally ill is the major issue.)
- tsewlliw 14y agoIts not about statistics. If it were, we'd be contemplating things like taxing food in inverse proportion to its nutritional content and glycemic index.
- bonaldi 14y ago1. Those attacks were rather less lethal than the ones involving guns. 2. It focuses the conversation on achievable solutions. No country on earth has managed to solve the identification, treatment and care of mental health issues enough that would prevent one slipping through the net. Many, many countries have managed to reduce gun deaths to very low numbers indeed.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sarvinc 14y ago1. I don't think the argument is that firearms are less lethal only that attacks and death will still occur. 2. It focuses the conversation on, what I think is, the actual problem rather than something that is achievable but clearly does not solve the problem.
- bonaldi 14y ago1. The argument is "how about we have less children dying". Which every other comparable country manages. 2. The problem is "being are being murdered with guns in astonishing numbers". You say mental health is the root cause, which may be correct. But the root cause is effectively unsolvable, and other countries show that the _problem_ can be fixed by addressing contributory causes, like the widespread availability of bullets.
- sarvinc 14y agoTo be clear you replyed to a previous poster who made two points. I defended those two points. These are two new points that I'll attempt to address. If there's one argument I cannot tolerate it's a "for the children" argument. Yes great lets have less children die. How do we do that? Killing sprees in China show that you can kill several children with just knives and gasoline. So after the guns we ban knives, we regulate gasoline, we restrict the press and instill a curfew because "for the children." Better yet, while we're just naming stuff that will make us feel better, why not a TSA-like agency for all public places, a Patriot Act to protect us from killing-spree and more warrant-less wiretapping because "for the children." Pedofiles on Facebook; regulate the Internet "because for the children." Can we please find a solution that does not strip freedoms from the sane and law-abiding among us? It won't solve the problem because we are not other countries. I don't say this out of hubris. Without addressing things like the gun-culture we have here or the irrational fear of crimes we have here people will find a way to procure firearms. I'm pretty sure in 10 years 3D-printing will have advanced enough for us to make upper-receivers. What then? Do we regulate computers "for the children?"
- bonaldi 14y ago
- zalew 14y ago> Spree killings still happen without guns (see the similar school attacks in Asia where bladed weapons were used.) compare the number of people killed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rampage_killers:_School_massacres https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rampage_killers:_Schoo...
- nextstep 14y agoI am sick of hearing this argument referencing the spree killings in Asia with knives. In nearly every case, fewer people are killed when the weapon is a knife. Clearly guns are much more deadly than knives.
- onetwothreefour 14y agoNo one was killed in the latest "spree killing" in Asia. Try again.
- sarvinc 14y agoen.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shiguan_kindergarten_attack 12 killed. Knives and gasoline used. It's terrible stuff but let's not argue from positions of ignorance and fear.
- mikeryan 14y agoSeriously, I'm pretty damn solid on the need for gun control, but this plan seems pretty half baked. Trying to regulate the primary components of a bullet seems like it would be a practical impossibility. You thought the war on drugs was a losing battle, try the war on gunpowder.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoNot has hard as you think really. Have you tried to buy more than one box of cold medicine that contains certain elements used in cooking meth? Buy too many and you get flagged. Maybe that isn't the policy everywhere, but it could be.
- aantthony 14y agoDoesn't 'arms' include both the weapons and ammunition though?
- staunch 14y agodefine:arms arms plural of arms (Noun) Weapons and ammunition; armaments: "they were subjugated by force of arms".
- foxhop 14y agoHow would we regulate bullets? People have been packing their own bullets since guns were created.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoOne proposal has been microstamping[1] the bullet casings, although this was really meant for forensic identification, not regulation. I don't know how it could be used to prevent home handloading[2] though. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firearm_microstamping http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firearm_microstamping [2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handloading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Handloading
- tsewlliw 14y agoThat article is utterly unimpressive, and its attempt to be smug at finding a "loophole in the constitution" is absurd.
- staunch 14y agoI wonder if the author would defend so gleefully the idea of the government restricting access to newspaper ink? Anyone promoting the idea of subverting the constitution through perceived loopholes should really question their principles. Also, the word "cartridge" or "ammunition" is what the author means to be talking about here. Bullets are only the metal part that flies out of the gun, not the whole cartridge.
- jmilloy 14y agoAnd the author used the term ammunition and cartridge, so...?
- staunch 14y agoI don't see "cartridge" anywhere and he misused the term bullet repeatedly throughout the article. It's like an article on technology that repeatedly refers to applications as "source code" or something.
- jmilloy 14y agoYeah, no mention of cartridge, sorry. Still, among the plethora of problems with this article, this is a strange one to pick out. I think the idea comes across just fine despite incorrectly using bullet and ammunition interchangeably. In what ways were you confused? In what ways do you think someone else could be confused?
- rdtsc 14y ago> Anyone promoting the idea of subverting the constitution through perceived loopholes should really question their principles. What is the purpose of the Constitution? Is it like the 10 Commandments that have been passed down from the sky and now we have to worship it unquestionably? There are large numbers of people in this country that seem to believe so. So take the gun issue. Why is that in the constitution? For hunting? Protecting from bears? Foreign invaders? Maybe. Would it make a difference now if anyone attacked us if we all carried guns? Probably not. We'll probably use our drones and tanks to fight back. Maybe it was for people to protect from an abusive government? Is that realistic today? You'd need to be able to bear tanks, helicopters and fighter planes if this hypothetical militia is ever to even register as a blip on government's threat radar. So why even bother both defending the idea or trying to find a loophole to bypass it. Both seem rather pointless to me. Are people defending themselves better with guns? Canada and other countries have legal guns and don't seem to have issues with such crimes as we saw recently. Some countries outlaw guns and experience much worse violence. Is there any credible study that shows a linkage between legal arms position and violent crime?
- duopixel 14y agoIf you don't destroy the firearms you aren't destroying the demand. Everybody who has a firearm will probably start by hoarding existing bullets and this will create a black market for ammo. When the local cache is over, it's obvious who is going to fill that need.
- c0ldfusi0nz 14y agoThe author of this article seems to be under the impression that 3D printing a firearm is easy while loading your own ammunition is difficult. With the proper equipment (less than a thousand dollar investment), loading ammunition is only slightly more difficult than baking a cake.
- bridanp 14y agoIt all feels a little like handwringing, doesn't it? We think we can solve the problem by gun control but then you realize there are too many guns out there already that it won't work (or at least not for many years). So we go for the bullets, but then people who grew up around sport shooting can tell us it's nothing to sit down and create dozens of rounds in a free night. My own experience reminds me of loading a dozen shells with my Dad when I was 10 in just a couple hours so we could hunt the next morning. So the idea of limiting the bullets (or at least shells) won't work unless the materials are also regulated. The mental health aspect seems to be one of the best ideas but then that might just depend on universal health actually being put into place. Without it, many people will go without due to the expense of mental facilities. So yeah handwringing. We want someone to do something and fast but none of the options seem easy, quick, or realistic. So we might need to pick the one or two that will work eventually, maybe 5-10 years down the road, and take it from there.
- whatshisface 14y agoMaybe, instead of universal healthcare, we could have a program that tried to fix people that were a danger to society? It would function like a cross between police and public broadcasting, both things already accepted by mostly everyone.
- Trufa 14y agoWhat I really don't understand about this argument, is if hard to regulate guns/drugs or anything illegal, it seems completely impossible to actually stop a bullet black market! If you could get your hands on 20 bullets (a really tiny amount!), you could most definitely cause a tragedy. I'm not saying regulating guns is the solution, it may or may not be, but regulating bullets? That seems naive.
- greyfade 14y agoWhat people don't seem to realize is that ammunition is simple to manufacture at home with untraceable materials. Lead bullets? Go down to the auto shop and ask for a stack of their discarded wheel balancing weights. Take them home, melt them down, and pour the molten lead into home-made dies. Casings? Gather discarded casings and reload them. Dies and tools are commercially available. If there's a shortage of casings, appropriate dies can be relatively easily made and brass can be molded as needed. Gunpowder? People have been making black powder at home for centuries. Smokeless powder is more difficult, but nitrocellulose is not that complex. Primer? Boxer primers are US Patent 91,818. Berdan primers are patents 53,388 and 82,587. Active ingredient is potassium perchlorate, which is easy to get. Regulating bullets will have negligible effect anyway.
- Lazare 14y agoTechnically, the article is flawed. It's easy to make your own ammo. Legally, the article is flawed. The Supreme Court is very very very clear that restricting someone's ability to exercise a right is a restriction on that right; they've said it over and over again about free speech, political donations, the exercise of religion, the right to avoid self-incrimination. and many other areas. Including the right to own and bear arms. Like it or not, the Supreme Court has said - twice! - that you have an individual right to own a gun for, among other things, self defence. That doesn't mean "so you can bludgeon an intruder with it" it means "so you can shoot an intruder with it". With bullets. And any law you make that meaningfully restricts the ability of law abiding citizens to shoot an intruder in their home will not fly without a constitutional amendment which is - needless to say - not happening. And anything which does not restrict the ability of a law abiding citizen to shoot an intrude in their home will not stop future school shootings. (Yes, I know. It's crazy, and it's not how it is in other countries. But it's also objective reality.)
- Zak 14y agoTechnically, the article is flawed. It's easy to make your own ammo. I've reloaded ammunition using commercially available components (cases, bullets, primers and gunpowder). A complete black-market operation would be quite a bit harder, but not harder than say... manufacturing designer drugs.
- greyfade 14y agoYou can even remove bullets from the market and still easily make your own. A proper die can be machined by anyone with the proper tools, and lead can be easily obtained from any auto repair or tire shop, as they frequently discard large quantities of lead weights when rebalancing tires. Adding a copper jacket is also very simple. Primers and (smokeless) gunpowder are the only things that are unreasonably difficult to manufacture at home. And even then, gunpowder recipes and materials are easy to come by.