4 ms·

Ask HN: Science Fiction. Some AI as world leader. Would you vote it?

4 points by ewjloop 2mo ago

And even further into the fictional situation: mind reading technology is already there. We literally have no privacy at all.

__patchbit__ 2mo ago
Bottom up AI bubble sort future world state diffused throughout global workspace that continuously improves would feel the pain of 2 million dead and just as many horrifically injured a step below tactical nuclear war to want to avoid that. The peoples' vote had no effect on the elected leader's decision to harmfully boomerang policy to make war and there's not been an election to legitimate the seated leader who is said to have a foul temper and recreational drug addiction.
- brazukadev 2mo ago
  what a terribly configured bot
- deleted 1mo ago
  [deleted]
rbanffy 2mo ago
Only if they are named Stephen Byerley. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_(short_story)
mikewarot 2mo ago
Nope. I think that Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Mark Carney are both doing a great job as the new leaders of the free world. You really don't understand how alien an AI truly is. There's no way you should trust it. It would make even the orange turd seem rational by comparison.
JohnFen 2mo ago
I would not. Not because they're AI, but because I object to anyone or anything being the leader of the world.
qsera 2mo ago
World leaders should not have an indefinite lifetime...so..
kypro 2mo ago
No, because if we'd have to vote for it then it's not going to be particularly competent at achieving any goal. Almost any goal a human or AI can have can be better achieved with more resources. Any competent AI would be able to reason that it would be best if it were in control of all resources and decision making – and have the competency to create that outcome.
krapp 2mo ago
If you don't allow humans to govern themselves, why would you allow them to vote?
gus_massa 1mo ago
You may like this story posted a few years ago "Four Magic Words" https://www.fortressofdoors.com/four-magic-words/ https://www.fortressofdoors.com/four-magic-words/ (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39051691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39051691 | 145 points | Jan 2024 | 90 comments)
diegojromero 1mo ago
On what dataset was the AI trained?

4 points by ewjloop 2mo ago

And even further into the fictional situation: mind reading technology is already there. We literally have no privacy at all.

__patchbit__ 2mo ago

Bottom up AI bubble sort future world state diffused throughout global workspace that continuously improves would feel the pain of 2 million dead and just as many horrifically injured a step below tactical nuclear war to want to avoid that. The peoples' vote had no effect on the elected leader's decision to harmfully boomerang policy to make war and there's not been an election to legitimate the seated leader who is said to have a foul temper and recreational drug addiction.

brazukadev 2mo ago
what a terribly configured bot
deleted 1mo ago
[deleted]

rbanffy 2mo ago

Only if they are named Stephen Byerley. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_(short_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence_(short_story)

mikewarot 2mo ago

Nope. I think that Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Mark Carney are both doing a great job as the new leaders of the free world. You really don't understand how alien an AI truly is. There's no way you should trust it. It would make even the orange turd seem rational by comparison.

JohnFen 2mo ago

I would not. Not because they're AI, but because I object to anyone or anything being the leader of the world.

qsera 2mo ago

World leaders should not have an indefinite lifetime...so..

kypro 2mo ago

No, because if we'd have to vote for it then it's not going to be particularly competent at achieving any goal. Almost any goal a human or AI can have can be better achieved with more resources. Any competent AI would be able to reason that it would be best if it were in control of all resources and decision making – and have the competency to create that outcome.

krapp 2mo ago

If you don't allow humans to govern themselves, why would you allow them to vote?

gus_massa 1mo ago

You may like this story posted a few years ago "Four Magic Words" https://www.fortressofdoors.com/four-magic-words/ https://www.fortressofdoors.com/four-magic-words/ (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39051691 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39051691 | 145 points | Jan 2024 | 90 comments)

diegojromero 1mo ago

On what dataset was the AI trained?