3 ms·
Flags on HN are user submitted. they are just as emotional as reddit downvotes. If something reveals an uncomfortable truth it gets flagged.
by Gigachad 2mo ago
Flags on HN are user submitted. they are just as emotional as reddit downvotes. If something reveals an uncomfortable truth it gets flagged.
- borski 2mo agoFlags also require a minimum karma, and members with yet higher karma can also undead posts, if needed. HN is actually surprisingly good about this, so I disagree with your assertion.
- dymk 2mo agoWhat does “high karma” have to do with less emotionally driven voting behavior?
- borski 2mo agoYou acquire karma through posting things that are interesting or curious enough that others upvote them. Thus, you build reputation by acquiring karma. It isn’t perfect, but the fact that folks with higher karma can “fix” the emotional flags of folks with lower karma, it helps. Also, I’d recommend re-reading the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dymk 2mo agoYou just explained the mechanism by which the karma number goes up, not explained your theory why you think higher number means less emotional voting.
- j_maffe 2mo agoAlmost all of my karma is from a single post link that blew up randomly. I think this is the case for most users' karma here.
- Gigachad 2mo agoAll that does is reinforce the existing biases. If you post a lot of things other HN users agree with, you get the ability to silence things HN users don't like.
- stingraycharles 2mo agoThreads that get more comments than upvotes are also automatically flagged once they reach a certain threshold.
- ghusbands 2mo agoSo, on a news discussion site, active discussion gets penalised. There really should be a human in the loop on that one.
- stingraycharles 2mo agoThis has been done here for maybe a decade already, and it’s because it’s a signal for “unproductive” discussions. Effectively discussions that don’t get upvotes do get penalized yes.
- danqqqq 2mo ago[dead]