2 ms·
I'm curious if you've taught calculus? Do your students remember limits by the end of calculus? Most studies show that students DO NOT RETAIN limit concepts (
by johnnyb_61820 2mo ago
I'm curious if you've taught calculus? Do your students remember limits by the end of calculus? Most studies show that students DO NOT RETAIN limit concepts (ESPECIALLY epsilon-delta ones). It is used as a crutch and then largely discarded before anyone is actually comfortable/familiar with them.
By being a little handwavy at the beginning, you can then tell Dorothy that she's had her ruby slippers with her all along, and by this time they recognize the power and importance of the concept.
In some ways, it is good to be able to explain, from the ground up, why each piece is in place. But, sometimes, understanding how to build a student requires knowing when we need to temporarily handwave something away so that it is actually meaningful when they get it. And then, doing that so they don't maintain a false conception is also important, which is why handwaviness is often helpful ("this is kind of like dividing by zero, but kind of not, and we will get to the distinctions later so just trust us for the moment").
- srean 2mo ago> Most studies show that students DO NOT RETAIN limit concepts Is that so ? I would not have guessed. I am not being sarcastic. Going by experiences of my own high school cohort I would have claimed that limits had a more lasting impression. BTW I enjoyed your arxiv paper on 2nd order derivatives.
- johnnyb_61820 2mo agoHere's an interesting paper on the topic for epsilon-delta proofs: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.05187 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.05187 Also see Table 2 of this older paper for limit thinking in general: https://u.math.biu.ac.il/~katzmik/sullivan76.pdf https://u.math.biu.ac.il/~katzmik/sullivan76.pdf
- srean 2mo agoThanks.