3 ms·
They don't draw similar criticisms at all... I actually have heard similar criticisms to the ones that Dijkstra made of every one of the modern equivalents. F
by btilly 14y ago
They don't draw similar criticisms at all...
I actually have heard similar criticisms to the ones that Dijkstra made of every one of the modern equivalents. For similar reasons. And I believe that my comparison touches on why each of those criticisms is paralleled.
I freely admit, though, that the weakest parallel is to Java. Programmers who are not enamored of deep object hierarchies despise those designs when Java programmers try to implement them in any language. But love of deep object hierarchies is not unique to Java (though it does tend to be extreme there). Nor is Java as crippled as COBOL.
As for COBOL and other use cases - I would be willing to bet large sums that it would have had many other use cases had the people programming in it had access to computers that could run it for a reasonable price.
And finally, I did not post that comparison to slag on languages. I posted it to provide context for Dijkstra's quote. In fact I, personally, have spent a lot of my professional life programming in Perl - which is one of the languages that I offered up for criticism. And I freely admit that the criticism is not entirely unfounded.