3 ms·
From the article: "People will be fluent in every language. With DARPA and Google racing to perfect instant translation, it won't be long until your cellphone s
by tokenadult 14y ago
From the article: "People will be fluent in every language. With DARPA and Google racing to perfect instant translation, it won't be long until your cellphone speaks Swahili on your behalf." That was suggested as a plausible prediction for 2022. The comment to which I reply says,
Given the current state of language translating software, I think this is highly unlikely in the next 10 years. Anyone who is bilingual and has used a translation app knows how woefully inadequate it is for actual communication.
The last time a video demonstration of software in development for language translation was posted here on HN,
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4759620 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4759620
I commented,
To someone who spent years learning Chinese as a second language, and then made my living for years as a Chinese-English interpreter, that was pretty impressive.
The economics of the issue is that a machine interpreter just has to be as good as a human interpreter at the same cost. That's a reachable target with today's computer technology. EVERY time I've heard someone else interpreting English or Chinese into the other language, I have heard mistakes, and I am chagrined to remember mistakes that I made over the years. We can't count on error-free machine interpretation between any pair of languages (human language is too ambiguous in many daily life cases for that), but if companies develop tested, validated software solutions for consecutive interpreting (what I usually did, and what is shown in the video) or simultaneous interpreting (the harder kind of interpreting in demand at the United Nations, where even in the best case it is not always done well), then those companies will be able to displace a lot of human professionals who rely on their language ability to make a living.
And relating that comment to a timeline appropriate for today's thread, I think ten years out is about right for a mobile app widely available at reasonable cost that will displace human interpreters for most use cases that now require human interpreters. As I further commented on the the earlier thread 37 days ago,
Right now a lot of interpreters in the United States make a lot of part-time income from gigs that involve suddenly getting telephone calls and joining in to interpret a telephone conversation in two languages. This is often necessary, for example, for physician interviews of patients in emergency rooms or pharmacist consultations with patients buying prescribed drugs (where I last saw a posted notice on how to access such an interpretation service). The IBM Watson project is already targeted at becoming an expert system for medical diagnosis, and patient care markets will surely provide a lot of income for further development of software interpretation between human languages.
It's still good for human beings to spend the time and effort to learn another human language (as so many HN participants have by learning English as a second language). That's a broadening experience and an intellectual delight. But just as riding horses is more a form of recreation these days than a basis for being employed, so too speaking another language will be a declining factor in seeking employment in the next decade.
If there is economic demand for interpreting between a given language pair, there will be great economic incentive to develop software-as-a-service to do interpreting for that language pair. I would expect Japanese-English and Spanish-English and Chinese-English interpreting all to decline as a human paying occupation by ten years from now, even though international communication will surely increase in the same time frame.
- createmenot 14y agoI agree that software will soon be able to efficiently interpret between two languages. I take issue with the article stating that "people will be fluent in every language". Having access to an interpreter (software or human) does not make one fluent in a language. Actually being fluent provides a much greater depth of understanding than an interpreter can ever approach. An English-speaking businessman who lives in Japan and relies on an interpreter will not be as efficient at his job as one who becomes fluent in Japanese, due to the enormous subtleties and cultural complexities of language.