5 ms·
This is pretty awful analysis. It conflates aggregate statistics (e.g. GDP) with per-capita ones (birth rates, cost per child). And it's headline is a clear
by ajross 14y ago
This is pretty awful analysis. It conflates aggregate statistics (e.g. GDP) with per-capita ones (birth rates, cost per child). And it's headline is a clear lie designed to draw clicks.
Demographic change is a real challenge, and all industrial societies are heading for that kind of cliff. Japan's is larger than most (but smaller than China's), and they are going to get there first. But this isn't the kind of disaster being posited. It means, broadly, that for a generation or so society will be burdened by a disproportionately large elderly population, and caring for them will require resources that we'd prefer to spend on other things. But eventually things will return to a steady state, just with fewer people. We'll manage.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoBirthrate is 1.39 per woman. No, that will not reach a steady state. That's a constant decline.
- lotsofpulp 14y agoIf I recall correctly, ~2.3 children per woman is the replacement rate, i.e. keeps population steady. Of course, changes in longevity / infant mortality may have changed that statistic. Edit: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate#Replacement_rates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_fertility_rate#Replacemen... According to Wikipedia's source, replacement rate is ~2.1 for developed nations, so I would guess Japan is definitely not at a replacement rate at 1.4. Of course, replacement rates are just to keep population steady, but I would think a country with too many old people is still somewhat of a problem, unless you could figure out how to take care of them and/or make them productive.
- eriksank 14y agoWell, the problem won't be for just one generation. If the birthrate remains the same, the same problem will repeat itself generation after generation. One child per woman means: 32 - 16 - 8 - 4 - 2 - 1. Furthermore, it seems no problem to cut the birthrate, but virtually impossible to push it up again.
- ajross 14y agoTrue, but not of the form we're seeing (e.g. the base for the exponent surely isn't 2!). (It also bears mentioning that other factors like increases in working lifetime and overall lifetime counteract the birthrate decreases). Right now we're seeing a "cliff" due to a change in the birthrate due to the very rapid change to an industrialized urban economy. That won't repeat.
- nmcfarl 14y agoMistercrow asked the question above -I'll ask it here: Why do you think it won't repeat? To my knowledge no other modern society has had a birthrate drop like this - to below this radically replacement and has then stabilized the birthrate at the replacement rate (or above). This really could be free fall...
- DigitalTurk 14y agoBut is there a (modern) society that had a birthrate drop like this and perished as a result?
- tomjen3 14y agoNo modern society has seen the birthrate drop like this at all, regardless of the outcome, so we are in a bit of undefined territory. That doesn't mean it is bad, just differnt (which is enough to get a lot of people needlessly alarmed, sadly).
- tomjen3 14y agoVirtually impossible? Hardly. One generation where the average is 10 children per woman will boost the economy and permanently change the demographics; it may sound completely unrealistic, but it was the norm only a few generations ago. And no, it didn't end when a lot of the children stopped dying in childbirth, as my grandfather had something like 8 brothers, and all of them made it into adulthood just fine.
- greenyoda 14y ago
- mistercow 14y agoYes, there are some statistical flaws in the article, but the general point that Japan's population aging and that this is a problem is true. You say that things will return to a steady state, but why do you believe that?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- w1ntermute 14y agoIt also depends on culture. The article says that Japanese women don't find Japanese men as attractive partners because of low pay, long working hours for them, etc., but there's also the fact that young Japanese men just aren't that interested in having sex or pursuing women. This cultural phenomenon, known as Sōshoku danshi (草食男子), or herbivorous men[0,1], has to end if things are going to turn around. These men are more interested in their hobbies and personal grooming. This image summarizes the problem well: http://i.imgur.com/SUVEp.jpg http://i.imgur.com/SUVEp.jpg In fact, it's often the opposite of what the article states - there's a trend among women called Nikushoku joshi (肉食女子), or carnivorous women, where the women are actively pursuing men out of necessity. 0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbivore_men http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbivore_men 1: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/24/AR2010102403204_pf.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10...
- nacker 14y agoThe cultural changes you mention are not specific to Japan, they are global. For an in depth analysis of the issue I suggest F. Roger Devlin's classic paper 'Sexual Utopia In Power': http://dontmarry.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/sexualutopia.pdf http://dontmarry.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/sexualutopia.pd...