3 ms·
once you've crossed the event horizon, can neural signals travel in a direction opposite the center of the singularity? They don't have to for your brain and n
by pdonis 14y ago
once you've crossed the event horizon, can neural signals travel in a direction opposite the center of the singularity?
They don't have to for your brain and nervous system to continue functioning. Suppose you are falling feet first towards the singularity, and your feet send a nerve signal to your head. From your viewpoint, the signal travels up your body normally. But from the "god's-eye" viewpoint, the nerve signal from your feet to your head just falls towards the singularity more slowly than your feet and head do, so your feet fall away from the signal and your head catches up with it.
- ars 14y agoAm I falling faster than light? At the moment of the crossing, does the floor of the spaceship look dark? If I can see the floor, then light from the floor is passing the horizon and entering my eye.
- pdonis 14y agoIf I can see the floor, then light from the floor is passing the horizon and entering my eye. No, it isn't. Consider a ray of light emitted by the floor just below the horizon, and suppose that your eye is just above the horizon when it is emitted. By the time that ray of light reaches your eye, your eye will have fallen below the horizon. So your eye will see the ray of light just fine.
- pixl97 14y agoI'm not sure about the just fine. If you were not in a complete free fall you'd be smooshed (I'm guessing W = m · g is nasty at black hole gravities). I guess my question is how fast you'd be traveling by the time you got near/in the even horizon. Anywhere close to 'c' and things would look a lot different.
- pdonis 14y agoIf you were not in a complete free fall you'd be smooshed (I'm guessing W = m · g is nasty at black hole gravities) If you are trying to "hover" at a constant altitude above the black hole's horizon, then yes, the acceleration you would feel increases without bound the closer to the horizon you try to hover. But if you're falling into the hole you clearly aren't "hovering"; it is perfectly possible to fall in while feeling only 1 g by adjusting your rocket power properly. The tidal gravity at the horizon might be very large, or very small, depending on the mass of the hole. If it's large enough, yes, tidal forces would tear you apart by the time you reached the horizon. But that would happen even if your center of mass was in free fall. I guess my question is how fast you'd be traveling by the time you got near/in the event horizon. Relative to what? There is no absolute answer to "how fast" you are going; velocity is relative.
- ars 14y ago> By the time that ray of light reaches your eye, your eye will have fallen below the horizon. In order for that to happen you would have to travel faster than light.
- pdonis 14y agoIn order for that to happen you would have to travel faster than light. Huh? The light ray and you are moving towards each other. Why would you have to travel faster than light to reach it?
- ars 14y agoBecause if you are not moving faster than light, the light ray will cross the event horizon before you do. Eg: The light ray came from the floor 1 foot below the event horizon, and your eyes are 3 feet away from it.
- pdonis 14y agoThe light ray came from the floor 1 foot below the event horizon, and your eyes are 3 feet away from it No, this is incorrect. You are thinking of the event horizon as a "place in space". It's not. It's an outgoing light ray. And "locations" with a given radius inside the horizon are not places in space either; they are moments of time. Here's how to unpack what I just said in more detail. What kind of curve is a curve of constant r (and constant theta, phi if we include the angular coordinates)? Our ordinary intuition about how "space" works says that a curve of constant r is timelike; that is, it is a possible worldline for an object. This means that an object can "stay in the same place" by staying at constant r for all time. If a black hole is present, however, this ordinary intuition is only valid outside the event horizon. Outside the horizon, curves of constant r are timelike. However, the event horizon is a curve of constant r, and it is not timelike: it's null. It's the path of an outgoing light ray. A light ray always moves at the speed of light; it can never "stay in the same place". So you can't think of the event horizon as "a place in space" the way you can think of a curve of constant r outside the horizon. Inside the horizon, a curve of constant r is spacelike. The physical meaning of a spacelike curve is that it is the set of all events that happen "at the same time" for some observer. So a curve of constant r inside the horizon is "a moment of time" rather than "a place in space". So a light ray that is emitted "1 foot below the horizon" is really emitted "1 foot to the future of the horizon". Or, since light travels about 1 foot per nanosecond, the light from your feet is emitted 1 nanosecond to the future of the horizon. That light can't travel "upward" to meet your feet; that would mean traveling into the past. Instead, your feet have to fall through the horizon to meet the light.