3 ms·
I would upvote this a million times if I could. The whole concept of the "Singularity" confuses hardware with software. Yes, hardware technology has followed a
by crazygringo 14y ago
I would upvote this a million times if I could. The whole concept of the "Singularity" confuses hardware with software.
Yes, hardware technology has followed an exponential rate of improvement, and there's no obvious reason to believe that will stop.
But software certainly hasn't. Programmers today still deal with the same issues they dealt with 30 years ago. Separately, we've figured out some cool pattern-recognition techniques, but there's absolutely nothing indicating "exponential" growth in how smart our programs are.
Yet the "Singularity" depends primarily on software, not hardware. And all this talk about getting around it by just "scanning in" actual brains and simulating them on hardware... well that still doesn't show how those simulated brains are suddenly going to get smarter than our own.
(And then you've got a whole lot of human-rights and personhood issues when you start dealing with actual seemingly conscious brains running on silicon, with real childhood memories, real emotional desires and whatnot -- I mean, they would basically be actual people, not some kind of abstract AWS brainpower cluster...)
- bloaf 14y agoI'm not sure that the software/hardware break is as clear cut as that: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/07/software-progress-beats-moores-law/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/07/software-progress-b...
- crazygringo 14y agoKurzweil makes the same point in his rebuttal. But all he (and the article) is talking about is speed improvements to algorithms. Singularity-type AI is not about the speed, and it's not about complexity in terms of number of moving parts either (a million-line code base might be larger than a 10,000-line one, and more complicated, but not necessarily any more conceptually complex). What matters for the "Singularity" is conceptual improvements. We're still writing brittle computer code that crashes a compiler upon a single slightly misspelled constant name or missing comma, where the intention would still be crystal-clear to any human programmer. I don't see any kind of "exponential" progress whatsoever relating to the fundamental building blocks of artificial thought, which is what the entire "Singularity" premise is based on.