4 ms·
It's certainly longer and more flowery, but a lot of it upon even the shortest reflection rings hollow: And while the translation of the genome into a brain
by angersock 14y ago
It's certainly longer and more flowery, but a lot of it upon even the shortest reflection rings hollow:
And while the translation of the genome into a brain is
not straightforward, the brain cannot have more design
information than the genome
How could a Game of Life grid possibly have more state or require more storage than the ruleset for generating it! Gasp! This is just sloppy on his part.
We do need to understand in detail how individual types
of neurons work, and then gather information about how
functional modules are connected. The functional methods
that are derived from this type of analysis can then
guide the development of intelligent systems.
I suspect this reflection would be about as useful in developing new intelligent systems as meditation on the semantics of various MIPS instructions would be for developing new processor implementations. He's looking at the wrong level.
The Google self-driving cars (which have driven over
140,000 miles through California cities and towns) learn
from their own driving experience as well as from Google
cars driven by human drivers.
A vacuous statement--to what degree does a Kalman filter "learn" from its state estimates of speed or similar? His statement may well be technically accurate, but its explanatory power is wanting.
~
All the buzzwords and nerd feelgood talking points are there, but I'm very put off by the random anecdotes and clumsy assertions.
- T-hawk 14y agoHow could a Game of Life grid possibly have more state or require more storage than the ruleset for generating it! Gasp! It can't have more state. The initial conditions have just as much state as any later generation. The initial state is {off, off, off, off, off, off, ... }. That's just as many bits as any later stage. What you really mean is that the initial state is easily compressible. (Run-length encoding can express an entire empty grid in two numbers as length, value.) And that's pretty much what Kurzweil means, actually the Game of Life is a great analogy here. The genome is a compressed data set, which doesn't express or exhibit anything useful in itself, but can be decompressed using external inputs of organic matter and energy to procedurally generate the neurons that will form the intelligence.
- kd0amg 14y agoIt can't have more state. The initial conditions have just as much state as any later generation. The initial state is {off, off, off, off, off, off, ... }. That's just as many bits as any later stage. That encoding is only viable if you restrict the game to a finite grid.
- dbaupp 14y agoWhile true, the infinite case is of no interest here: a brain is finite. (Many infinite grids require an infinite amount of information to store, and clearly many of our assumptions break down there.)
- dbaupp 14y agoThe initial conditions in the game of life isn't normally all-off, because then every generation would be all-off. In any case, the amount of information in the game of life is merely (initial state, number of iterations) which is certainly finite for a finite board.