3 ms·
One of Kurzweil's arguments in his response is "...the design of the brain (like the rest of the body) is contained in the genome. And while the translation of
by simonsquiff 14y ago
One of Kurzweil's arguments in his response is "...the design of the brain (like the rest of the body) is contained in the genome. And while the translation of the genome into a brain is not straightforward, the brain cannot have more design information than the genome"
However the brain's design information is the genome, the laws of physics and a universe.
You only have to look at protein folding, and the complexity of the resulting molecule and how that interacts with the rest of the world, so see how much complexity is there outside of the genome - and it's that complex end result that you have to simulate or replicate.
He goes onto say that "..the amount of design information in the genome is about 50 million bytes, roughly half of which pertains to the brain. That’s not simple, but it is a level of complexity we can deal with and represents less complexity than many software systems in the modern world."
As above, this is greatly simplifying the end result that you're trying to replicate - the genome is just the software that's running on the OS/hardware of the universe. To replicate that virtually we'd also need a virtual universe.
- martinkallstrom 14y agoThe virtual brain could use the real world, just as the real brain is. Just like the Google cars and Watson are doing.
- oh_sigh 14y agoThe main complication of protein folding is how the amino acid chain interacts with itself, not its interactions with an external environment.
- polyfractal 14y agoThat proves the point. To be able to fold a simple protein, you have to be capable of simulating the very challenging simulation of "real world physics at an atomic scale". To simulate a brain, you get to do that for a few hundred trillion proteins that make up a brain...and all their interactions with all the other trillion proteins. The complexity doesn't come from the proteins so much as the physics that govern the proteins.