3 ms·
This seems too obvious to be considered a paradox. The article says that the discover ran contrary to traditional assumptions, but I wonder if this is true, or
by baddox 14y ago
This seems too obvious to be considered a paradox. The article says that the discover ran contrary to traditional assumptions, but I wonder if this is true, or if so, why it would be the case. Perhaps I just have the luxury of hindsight, but it seems like after the advent of electronic computers, it would quickly become obvious that computers could vastly outperform humans in things like multiplication, or counting words in a large text document, or finding a correct path through a digital maze.
Besides, the distinction between "high-level reasoning" and "low-level sensorimotor skills" seems fairly weak. Checkers already starts to blur the line: the problem space can be modeled as pattern recognition and tactics (like how humans model their own gameplay), or it can be modeled as a "dumb search" through a decision tree (like how a computer algorithm might play). Then you get to something like chess, which has a prohibitively large decision tree to do a "dumb search," then face recognition, then natural language processing, etc.
- shmageggy 14y agoIt's definitely true (that "the discover ran contrary to traditional assumptions"), and they give supporting evidence for this in the article. The history of AI bears this out quite explicitly. Also, the decision tree for chess might be intractable to exhaustively search, but a "dumb search" is exactly how it's done, and it is currently vastly more powerful than any competing method. And you really can't just jump from chess to face recognition and NLP -- they are completely different problems. To wit, chess has perfect information; the entire state of the game is known at all times, and the representation is clearly defined and compact, where none of this is true for sensory tasks. This means the range of techniques available to solve each type problem are completely disparate, and tat there is almost nothing that you can take from a chess program and apply to "lower level" AI tasks.