6 ms·

It is distressing to hear someone on hacker news describe this, and the history of Syria over the last couple decades, as something that might be "propaganda" a

It is distressing to hear someone on hacker news describe this, and the history of Syria over the last couple decades, as something that might be "propaganda" and "partisanship." My god, man - do you even slightly follow the news? Are you really that unaware such that you feel there is some degree of question over just how horrific the Assad regime was for Syrians?

SanjayMehta 2mo ago
Why do you care? It's their country, let them mess it up as much as they want. That's the problem with you Westerners, you stole and genocided people around the entire world, and when you were finally thrown out, you come back to pass judgement and impose your own dubious morals on other people.
- stevenwoo 2mo ago
  Was reading book by Sue Black on forensic anthropology , Written in Bone, and she recalled incident where she was an expert witness for commission in Qatar, she confirmed the veracity of eyewitness and photo evidence of Assad Syrian regime of torture - for Arab instigated investigation. Not just Western values.
  - SanjayMehta 2mo ago
    [flagged]
    - donotredeem38 2mo ago
      [dead]
    - DigiEggz 2mo ago
      Hardships any country faces always affect innocent people. For example, immigrants were affected by the opioid crisis, so how does the flimsy, sad idea of "group karma" hold up here? Sharing uphelpful, embittered opinions like this only spreads pain that wraps back around and bites you, in the end. Treating the suffering of people as a sport or spectator event, by proverbially pointing your finger and laughing, is repulsive and puts you exactly in the same league as the people you detest.
      - podocarp 2mo ago
        No, I get their point if you ignore the stuff about karma. It does stoke anger when you say "we know better than you" and try to fix other nations' governments though. This is the same kind of shit where the government says "we know better than you how to live your life", and starts meddling in citizens affairs. Furthermore, let's be real. All such cases of "help" have never had altruistic goals in mind. I have never heard of a nation stepping into the affairs of another and actually "helped" and left with nothing in return. In ancient times it's mostly just an excuse for invasion. More recently, Osama started out as "help" against the Russian invaders. Saddam Hussein being installed and then toppled was also "help". Iran, was also due to "help" against the monarchy. I can't find a single instance where the help actually worked or was even meant to be true help. We cry for democracy but how many South American democratically elected governments have the leader of the free world toppled? Again, since ancient history the "help" part of the action is always just propaganda and an excuse to go forward to take advantage of some current crisis.
        SanjayMehta 2mo ago
        Your comment about "the stuff about karma" is an example of what is annoying about "western culture." You push your desert cult's evangelism and whine when governments push back on your funding evil missionaries (see the latest brouhaha about FCRA, for example). Senators and even JD Vance are now screeching from their pulpits. But the US has FARA and that's good? You can push your desert tribalism and that's good? Learn about karma.
      - SanjayMehta 2mo ago
        My views are shared by the majority of the "third world" or "the global south" or as I prefer it: the global majority. Why does this matter? As the formerly colonised catch up and surpass the West, what do you think will happen? Take a look at China? What you condescendingly call "embittered," is reality.
    - stevenwoo 2mo ago
      I was neutral and responded to your comment. The approach portrayed in the book is pretty clinical and she sticks to things that she can back up in court as factual to the best of her knowledge, it was kind of surprising to come across anything in the book that was remotely topical.
LAC-Tech 2mo ago
[flagged]
- duxup 2mo ago
  What were you saying? What about that story is propaganda?
  - SanjayMehta 2mo ago
    Everything

SanjayMehta 2mo ago

Why do you care? It's their country, let them mess it up as much as they want. That's the problem with you Westerners, you stole and genocided people around the entire world, and when you were finally thrown out, you come back to pass judgement and impose your own dubious morals on other people.

stevenwoo 2mo ago
Was reading book by Sue Black on forensic anthropology , Written in Bone, and she recalled incident where she was an expert witness for commission in Qatar, she confirmed the veracity of eyewitness and photo evidence of Assad Syrian regime of torture - for Arab instigated investigation. Not just Western values.
- SanjayMehta 2mo ago
  [flagged]
  - donotredeem38 2mo ago
    [dead]
  - DigiEggz 2mo ago
    Hardships any country faces always affect innocent people. For example, immigrants were affected by the opioid crisis, so how does the flimsy, sad idea of "group karma" hold up here? Sharing uphelpful, embittered opinions like this only spreads pain that wraps back around and bites you, in the end. Treating the suffering of people as a sport or spectator event, by proverbially pointing your finger and laughing, is repulsive and puts you exactly in the same league as the people you detest.
    - podocarp 2mo ago
      No, I get their point if you ignore the stuff about karma. It does stoke anger when you say "we know better than you" and try to fix other nations' governments though. This is the same kind of shit where the government says "we know better than you how to live your life", and starts meddling in citizens affairs. Furthermore, let's be real. All such cases of "help" have never had altruistic goals in mind. I have never heard of a nation stepping into the affairs of another and actually "helped" and left with nothing in return. In ancient times it's mostly just an excuse for invasion. More recently, Osama started out as "help" against the Russian invaders. Saddam Hussein being installed and then toppled was also "help". Iran, was also due to "help" against the monarchy. I can't find a single instance where the help actually worked or was even meant to be true help. We cry for democracy but how many South American democratically elected governments have the leader of the free world toppled? Again, since ancient history the "help" part of the action is always just propaganda and an excuse to go forward to take advantage of some current crisis.
      - SanjayMehta 2mo ago
        Your comment about "the stuff about karma" is an example of what is annoying about "western culture." You push your desert cult's evangelism and whine when governments push back on your funding evil missionaries (see the latest brouhaha about FCRA, for example). Senators and even JD Vance are now screeching from their pulpits. But the US has FARA and that's good? You can push your desert tribalism and that's good? Learn about karma.
    - SanjayMehta 2mo ago
      My views are shared by the majority of the "third world" or "the global south" or as I prefer it: the global majority. Why does this matter? As the formerly colonised catch up and surpass the West, what do you think will happen? Take a look at China? What you condescendingly call "embittered," is reality.
  - stevenwoo 2mo ago
    I was neutral and responded to your comment. The approach portrayed in the book is pretty clinical and she sticks to things that she can back up in court as factual to the best of her knowledge, it was kind of surprising to come across anything in the book that was remotely topical.

LAC-Tech 2mo ago

[flagged]

duxup 2mo ago
What were you saying? What about that story is propaganda?
- SanjayMehta 2mo ago
  Everything