6 ms·
The grid of 2030: all renewable, 90 percent of the time
- programminggeek 14y agoThis is probably a bad idea, but couldn't you store energy basically having wind/solar power water pumps to pull water from one location to another? Something like 2 lakes side by side with a dam in the middle pulling energy off the transfer between when energy is needed and then water being pumped back in the reservoir when energy is being claimed from wind/solar?
- pstuart 14y agoSomething like this? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helms_Pumped_Storage_Plant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helms_Pumped_Storage_Plant
- programminggeek 14y agoYes, basically that, but using solar/wind to power the pumps, turning the lake into a giant battery to store the energy from the solar/wind power, which seems to be one of the major drawbacks of wind/solar.
- frankus 14y agoThat's an interesting and seemingly obvious approach, so I'm curious why it's not really discussed. I'm guessing that at current wind/solar capacity, any fluctuations can be absorbed by just slowing down the flow out of the reservoir, rather than ever having it reverse. You also need a downhill source of water, which means any dam that's the last one downstream can't really use this approach. You could maybe even get away with an entirely closed-loop system, but if you look at the scale of the problem, you need either a huge pair of reservoirs (lake-sized) or a huge elevation difference (mountain-sized), or preferably both. It doesn't appear economical to build e.g. a tank on a tower.
- mlwarren 14y agoOne of the major reasons pumped storage isn't used more is because the energy loss associated with pumping and storing the water. I can't find the exact amount right now but from a lecture I watched some time back[1], pumped storage is a few orders of magnitude more expensive than using conventional fossil fuel generated electricity per kWh. It's just not very cost effective right now. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MoAFiL1UdSg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MoAFiL1UdSg
- maxerickson 14y agoThe orders of magnitude doesn't pass the sniff test. If it were true, utilities would not be building pumped storage capacity. I can certainly believe the capital requirements are much higher for pumped storage than for natural gas peakers.
- aidenn0 14y agoIt takes a huge space. 1 kWh means moving a metric ton (a cubic meter) of water 400m of elevation. Round trip efficiency isn't great, but also not terrible. It beats the fuel-cell/electrolysis cycle, but loses to batteries. It can be profitable though because energy rates can reach near zero (and even occasionally slightly negative) at night. 99% of installed energy storage is pumped hydro.
- redwood 14y agoAt this point, it's surprising we don't just cut off the flow of existing hydro when we have other sources peaking... e.g. it's what you describe but no need for upward pumping. We do this to some extent, but the reality is we do need to ensure rivers continue to flow for a number of reasons (I guess).
- pilom 14y agoThis is addressed in the "Renewable Energy - Without the Hot Air" Report http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c26/page_187.shtml http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c26/page_18... basically the author says that what you describe is the best option right now but there are only so many places you can put those facilities because they require very specific geography. That being said building lakes and dams is really bad for the river eco system and really expensive to buy land out from under people to flood it.
- dodo53 14y agoI really should get around to reading that. His info theory book/lectures was/were very good. http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/itprnn/book.html http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/itprnn/book.html
- dodo53 14y agoIf you haven't seen already you might be interested in http://lightsailenergy.com/tech.html http://lightsailenergy.com/tech.html; they're working on compressed-air-and-water-vapour storage (also DaniFong posts on HN sometimes)
- hleszek 14y agoWhy don't we have our energy prices directly depending on the availability ? Each house should have a big meter showing the variable price and people will then use energy hungry appliances only when the energy is cheap. This way we act as a buffer allowing better ressource usage. Even better, appliances like dishwashers and washing machines could be connected to the network to read the price level and run automatically when the price is lower than a fixed amount. Even better, for industries which are using energy automatically, they should bid for the excess energy and when there is a big surplus, the energy will be really cheap and will be used instead of going to waste.
- chronomex 14y agoLots of large power users already do this, such as aluminum smelters.
- redwood 14y agoThe argument probably boils down to: the net economic loss in productivity from having every micro-power-user spend time worrying about whether it's a good or bad time to flip the switch, out-weighs the added market efficiency from what you describe. Large users on the other hand, can devote a team to ensure optimal usage around complex / time-dependent tariffs. Great point about smart appliances tho: that will have to wait for full integration of the smart grid and there will have to be a clear incentive to buy expensive appliances... since the overall savings could be fairly minimal (e.g. one less peaker plant) it's harder to provide benefits for millions of users. Again "demand response" e.g. turn-down-on-demand for large power users (perhaps even large building airconditioner loads) makes sense to target first. There is no doubt a lot of interesting tech potential in this area... but utilities move so so slow.
- frankus 14y agoThere's already something called time-of-use metering, which is like what you're suggesting but based on long-term trends rather than a spot price. Right now it's only cost-effective with large loads, and only economical if it's largely automated. (By point of comparison, most people already can't be bothered to switch off a 100W room light when they leave. That means we just don't GAF about saving pennies per hour if it means we have to push a button every so often). However, seeing how heating and cooling are the only residential loads that are really worth worrying about, and both can typically be advanced or deferred by an hour or so without any problems, you could probably solve 90% of the problem by smartening up a handful of appliances in each home. Industrial users can often do similar things. A cold storage facility, for example, could do most of it's cooling when power is cheap and then coast through the expensive periods. And they use enough electricity to pay someone (or buy an automated system) to handle it for them. Once you solve heating and cooling, everything other than cooking (basically lighting and entertainment) is getting more and more efficient every year. And most people don't cook enough to make that a significant load.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoSolve the storage problem first, then everything else follows. Otherwise this is a recipe for disaster. The problem with building out solar or especially wind power generation is that it's unreliable, it doesn't produce power when you want it. This means that you need to supplement power generation with low latency backup systems. Unfortunately, those systems tend to be gasoline-powered generators. Building those and operating them is expensive and also not so beneficial from a total CO2 emissions perspective. More so when you compare the whole system to simply replacing the windmill and the generator with a natural gas generator, which is more reliable, cheaper, and produces less total net CO2.
- don_draper 14y agoGermany gets 25% of their power from renewable energe. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany It's possible
- InclinedPlane 14y agoYou completely ignored my points, some additional facts (Germany is becoming an electrical power importer, relying on France's nuclear plants, is relying more and more on coal, and may end up increasing its CO2 emissions. Meanwhile, the US has actually decreased its CO2 emissions mostly by relying more heavily on natural gas and should hit 1990 levels soon, despite population growth.): http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-30/germany-becomes-net-power-importer-from-france-after-atomic-halt.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-30/germany-becomes-net... http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-08-19/merkel-s-green-shift-forces-germany-to-burn-more-coal-energy.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-08-19/merkel-s-green-shif... http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/new-coal-fired-plants-could-be-key-to-german-energy-revolution-a-854335.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/new-coal-fired-p...
- reitzensteinm 14y agoYes, but that doesn't contradict InclinedPlane's point in the least. It's easy to generate a lot of renewable energy when you've got the old power plants ready to cover any shortfalls in generation capacity. Just because you can acheive 25% under those conditions by prioritizing renewables does not imply that you can push renewables up to 90%+. The wind can stop blowing for quite some time, even on a country wide scale. You either have to store the energy, import it from other countries or have backup power stations to cover the shortfall. The (free) book Without Hot Air is a fantastic read for more information. It's written by a no nonsense physicist that dives pretty deep into possible plans for a future energy grid, including all the messy details. And the details are messy. Any renewable energy plan that doesn't sound like a momentus undertaking is cheating by 1) Only talking about electricity, not total energy 2) Discounting embodied energy of imports 3) Keeping a country sized fossil fuel infrastructure around to fill in the gaps 4) Importing energy Sometimes all four.
- liber8 14y agoThe problem with this article, and nearly all others pushing for adoption of wind power, is that it ignores reality. >>When there is not enough renewable energy direct from source, and the stored energy reserves are insufficient to bridge the shortfall, top up the remaining few percent of the demand with fossil fuels.<< We don't have any way to "top up" the remaining few percent of demand with fossil fuels. You can't simply flip a switch on a coal fired or nuclear power plant and have it instantly produce power. These massive processes need tremendous lead time to start producing electricity. So, in theory wind could provide a lot of power, but since we have no idea when the wind will die and when we will need to "top off" the shortfall, we keep coal fired plants churning. This is one reason why, as the largest utility in Germany states[1], it takes roughly 24MW of wind power to take just 1MW of fossil fuel power offline: "As a result, the relative contribution of wind power to the guaranteed capacity of our supply system up to the year 2020 will fall continuously to around 4% (FIGURE 7). In concrete terms, this means that in 2020, with a forecast wind power capacity of over 48,000MW (Source: dena grid study), 2,000MW of traditional power production can be replaced by these wind farms." Storage, and the near-immediate ability to use what is stored, would help this tremendously, but we don't have that capability, and we don't seem to be well on our way to getting it, even by 2030. [1]http://www.wind-watch.org/docviewer.php?doc=eonwindreport2005.pdf http://www.wind-watch.org/docviewer.php?doc=eonwindreport200...
- InclinedPlane 14y agoIt's a bit of a catch-22. First, you need to build wind/solar plants, which tend to be more expensive than conventional power plants to start with. Then, you either need to invest in R&D for power storage systems and build out those facilities or, more likely, you need to build out conventional power capacity to accommodate for demand when solar or wind is not producing. In the end you've spent quite a lot more money and likely you haven't actually reduced the number of conventional power plants you've built or even reduced CO2 emissions substantially (due to the reliance on less clean conventional power plants during solar/wind down times as well as the CO2 cost of constructing those plants).
- DennisP 14y agoBut you can do it with natural gas. We use gas plants that way right now.
- willholloway 14y agoThe takeaway is electricity prices will fall significantly and the worst climate change effects will be avoided as the market rapidly replaces our fossil fuel infrastructure with a renewable one.
- pressurefree 14y agoeven if i came up with a disruptive idea that was poorly executed https://sites.google.com/site/verticalwindfarm/ https://sites.google.com/site/verticalwindfarm/ it still doesnt matter because everyone gets screwed. http://www.csmonitor.com/layout/set/print/content/view/print/453200 http://www.csmonitor.com/layout/set/print/content/view/print... apparently there is no value in ideas. also the only scholarship i ever got was from Chevron. the irony will save us!
- DennisP 14y agoIt's good to see that there's an optimal solution that gets us reasonably economical power from 99.9% renewables. What I'm wondering is whether we can get there from here. We can't simply dictate the end result we want and have it appear. What we could use now is some kind of economic simulation, taking into account the cost of shutting down fossil plants early, the capital cost of building all that wind and solar (and the upfront capital is the bulk of the cost, since operating costs are low), the actual utilities and regulatory structures currently in place, etc. Then we can see whether what sort of policy changes we might need, to get an end result like this, and what it will cost to put all this in place.
- EEGuy 14y agoWind and solar can be complimentary: Watch the Cal-ISO renewables graph (second graph on on this page: http://www.caiso.com/outlook/SystemStatus.html http://www.caiso.com/outlook/SystemStatus.html ; the first graph is demand and reserves ). On many days, the wind power goes up at night and down during the day, very much in complement, though in larger scale than, solar generation. More solar will more nearly equalize the two -- on good days. California is nowhere near having an overcapacity of renewable sources to worry about; just look at the first graph where the lowest demand (2 AM to 4 AM) is 22 GW on 12/14/2012. The highest the solar gets is not quite 1 GW. The wind is more variable, anecdotally as high as 3+ GW and as low as a flatline near zero for the whole state all day and night.
- SMRTN 14y agoOne great idea, is to store energy by ammonia NH3, split water into H2 and O (brown or grey, and you can actually clean the water this way) by electrolysis at as little as 1.2 V (Stan Meyer) and then using a reverse Fuel cell to bind the N in the air (N is about 80%) to store NH3 at as low as 120 PSI/10 Bar in existing nursing tanks. It can be used to run an existing (lightly converted) diesel generator or a fuel cell again at a higher efficiency level. No need to use H2 which requires massive amounts of energy to be cryogenically frozen or compressed in carbon fibre tanks. And you can run your diesel engine car/truck/train/ship. Another novel and new invention is www.aquionenergy.com who has an environmental battery made of carbon and salt :) Essentially its best to start capping our consumption levels and increasing efficiency. Have a look at the current wasted energy in our system: https://flowcharts.llnl.gov https://flowcharts.llnl.gov