5 ms·
I think many people forget that the vast majority of books aren't high art. Your mind goes to Heinlein, Arthur C. Clarke, N.K. Jemsin, or Pratchett. My mind g
by theshrike79 2mo ago
I think many people forget that the vast majority of books aren't high art.
Your mind goes to Heinlein, Arthur C. Clarke, N.K. Jemsin, or Pratchett.
My mind goes to Ice Planet Barbarians[0] or Crimson Worlds[1] (both written by actual humans, but I think they are good representations of their genres)
There are so many books in the romantasy genre specifically that could be just mad libs templates for AI Generated books.
The people who read them don't care about the plot, they want specific kinds of tropes in the book. They look for enemies-to-lovers, 7 foot tall men, tiny women and other very focused traits (ages, races, LQBTQIA+) in the books. They are consumable fun, not something anyone expects to be stored in the Library of Congress for future generations because they were so earth-shatteringly insightful.
Yes, AI authored (or assisted) books won't bring us the next Culture books by Iain M. Banks, but the next generic romantasy or self-published military scifi books could very well be. And nobody will notice - or care. It's 200-300 pages of entertainment that hits just the specific itch you had.
[0] https://www.goodreads.com/series/151379-ice-planet-barbarians https://www.goodreads.com/series/151379-ice-planet-barbarian...
[1] https://www.goodreads.com/series/97149-crimson-worlds https://www.goodreads.com/series/97149-crimson-worlds
- Planktonne 2mo agoYou're underselling those books and overselling AI; people have tried generating romantasy and power fantasies, and it's very obvious that it's not up to par. People want tropes, sure, but that's not the same as wanting trash; our culture is built on satisfying narratives treading well-worn paths, and there's a skill to it. Pratchett, for example, was only able to do what he did because he was deliberately playing with existing expectations; his work wouldn't exist without the stuff you denigrate to build off.
- theshrike79 2mo agoWhat's the difference between "trash" and "tropes" in your mind? For example the good old Harlequin books were pretty much trash: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harlequin_Enterprises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harlequin_Enterprises But when the expectation is trash, they deliver. They're the Hallmark Movies of books. It's not Citizen Kane, but sometimes you just want a predictable plot of a big city girl coming back to her home town and falling in love with the rugged local man.
- Planktonne 2mo agoThat's what I'm saying; even the 'trashiest' of human literature is an awful lot more sophisticated than AI madlibs.