6 ms·
EFF: Stop Congress from Reauthorizing the Warrantless Spying Bill
- halviti 14y agoWith the amount of effort that the executive branch took in order to get this legislation, even going as far as attempting to invoke the states secret privilege [1], I wonder what sort of public outcry it would take to actually get this unconstitutional legislation off the books. Furthermore, if it could be done, I wonder what would become of the 10's of billions of dollars in facilities and equipment that have been squandered by the government to spy on its own people in the name of freedom. I would love to hear ideas on how we can get this message out to the average population, and actually get them to care about it. Sadly, I think a lot of people don't care. Which is almost more worrying than the legislation itself. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_secrets_privilege#AT.26T_and_NSA_wire-tap_case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_secrets_privilege#AT.26T_...
- w1ntermute 14y agoIn my experience, the sad truth has been that most average people have responded to this issue by saying that they have nothing to hide and don't mind since it helps catch terrorists. Normally, you could expect Republicans to oppose a big government program like this, but, as we all know, as soon as you say the word "terrorist", they're all suddenly in favor of big government and big spending.
- Shivetya 14y agoSadder still, the press would be all over this if the Republicans were pushing it, instead they are complacent. As a conservative I can say that in my experience that Republicans are rarely against big government. In the recent election many I know had to hold their nose as neither Romney nor Ryan were true conservatives.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- chimeracoder 14y ago> Normally, you could expect Republicans to oppose a big government program like this, but, as we all know, as soon as you say the word "terrorist", they're all suddenly in favor of big government and big spending. It works on both sides of the aisle. I'm too embarrassed to count how many progressives I know who opposed the FISA wiretaps, the PATRIOT act, and Gitmo under Bush, yet bent over backwards to find ways to excuse Obama for taking each of those policies even further.
- rayiner 14y agoSo as a Democrat whose opinions have evolved on the subject, it's not just blind partisanship. A lot of the fear-mongering about the PATRIOT Act that was waved around in 2001 just hasn't come to pass, and it has been watered down over time. The same thing with Guantanamo. The Supreme Court pretty much smacked down the Executive between 2004-2008, and the fears never materialized. This is the list of defense attorneys for the Guantanamo Bay detainees: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_attorneys#Guantanamo_detainees.27_defense_attorneys http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_attorneys#Guanta.... This isn't a big scary shadowy thing anymore--the place is crawling with lawyers now.
- graue 14y agoScroll up a bit on that same page, and it sounds like there are serious abuses.
- flyinRyan 14y ago>A lot of the fear-mongering about the PATRIOT Act that was waved around in 2001 just hasn't come to pass What? The PATRIOT act has almost exclusively been used for non-terrorist cases. I.e. we were lied to about what it was for. And if you think how Gitmo has been used "wasn't that bad" I'd like to know what would need to happen for you to think it actually was bad.
- cbc0201 14y agoFirst, your "Take Action" link doesn't work. Second, I don't really care if "NSA's Supercomputers" are scanning my emails, text messages and even my phone calls. They're not really interested in my activities. Third, I'll let you in on a little secret, Its not just overseas communication! If it keeps safe, what do I care!
- darkarmani 14y ago> If it keeps safe, what do I care! Ah! This is the crux. What if these efforts make you LESS safe? The more people knowing where you are, how much money you have, etc, the easier it is to commit crime against you. You do have private information that keeps you safe. This is why kids aren's supposed to tell strangers on the phone that they are home alone. Which is more likely? You are injured in a terrorist attack or your information is leaked?
- SnowWhiteWinter 14y agoWhat a paradox... The Theater of security & the futile attempt to maintain the illusion of control. The sacrifice of pseudo-freedoms for spoon-feed ignorance. We as a species, have already passed the point of no-return. Rouge A.I. threats will be the only true distraction to the current state of global surveillance, and only because the allocation of resources will so chaotic to attempt to deal with them. If YOU don't care about YOUR communications being intercepted, you have just fucked-over all of the next-generation off-spring/relatives. YOUR ENTIRE FAMILY TREE, FOR THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, just for your lack of "care"... This is humanity @ its lowest.
- mtgx 14y agoNew account and first comment here, just to post that NSA can look at your e-mails if they want? I wonder if you're just someone working at NSA and FBI, and who's pushing for these laws. We know that they use "persona management" software to be part of the public conversation.
- jeremyarussell 14y agoI find myself agreeing with you, this guy is too much. (Also did you notice how he think's we are all liberals?)
- alrs 14y agoI live in California. I just called Feinstein's office and registered my opinion. According to the staffer, Feinstein supports the extension. Her office can be reached at (202) 224-3841. I called Boxer's office as well. After dialing <3> to speak with a staffer, it rang several times and then hung up. (202) 224-3553.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> Feinstein supports the extension. Her office can be reached at (202) 224-3841. Don't let this stop you (or anyone) from calling, but it's going to take a lot to get Feinstein to switch her stance on this.
- malandrew 14y agoOut of curiosity, why? Is Feinstein one of the main proponents of the extension or something?
- chimeracoder 14y agoFeinstein has always been one of the best friends of the law enforcement lobby. Which has made her one of the most disappointing senators on issues of privacy, drug policy, etc. It's especially disappointing given how out of line her beliefs are with certain areas of California, but that's what often happens when a massively diverse state elects a single representative democratically.
- wjamesg 14y agoGood for you, I encourage more to do the same. I interned for my Congressman on Capitol Hill a few years ago. In my opinion, volume calling is the best way to actually get heard. Web forms, emails, faxes: much less so. U.S. citizens, Contact your U.S. Representative: http://www.house.gov/representatives/find http://www.house.gov/representatives/find Contact your Senators: http://www.senate.gov http://www.senate.gov
- alrs 14y ago
- mcantelon 14y agoWho's pushing for this? Where does support for this come from?
- crusso 14y agoIt comes from voters who are too apathetic or ignorant to understand the value of basic Liberty. Any other finger-pointing is pretty meaningless.
- mcantelon 14y ago>It comes from voters who are too apathetic or ignorant to understand the value of basic Liberty. No it doesn't. Voters aren't complaining to government about this stuff. Someone else is pushing for this. These sorts of ideas don't come from nowhere. >Any other finger-pointing is pretty meaningless. No it isn't. If we know who's pushing for this we can possibly persuade them to stop. Politicians aren't going to stop if someone is donating to their campaigns and there isn't a massive public outcry, but a special interest pushing for this might be easier to reach (or, if they can't be reached, they can be exposed, increasing the chance of the kind of public outrage that politicians might actually react to).
- rayiner 14y ago> No it isn't. If we know who's pushing for this we can possibly persuade them to stop. Politicians aren't going to stop if someone is donating to their campaigns and there isn't a massive public outcry, but a special interest pushing for this might be easier to reach (or, if they can't be reached, they can be exposed, increasing the chance of the kind of public outrage that politicians might actually react to) This is an oft-repeated but utterly wrong characterization of the political process. It fits a compelling narrative for some people, but it has no basis in reality. Here is the basic truth: it takes neither public outcry or big donations to get politicians to do something like this. Wal-Mart, Lockheed, etc, don't need to grease any palms to get a Congressperson to jump at their command. No, all they have to do is use some magic words: "jobs," "terrorists," etc. Politicians are a deeply paranoid bunch. They are paranoid of being labeled "soft on crime" or "soft on terrorism" or "bad for jobs." And they are deeply paranoid about these things because they are trigger words for the public. A good example of this is how Obama fell over himself to compete with Romney about who could be more pro-coal. Why did Obama swing so hard on that issue? Not for fear of losing donations. The "clean coal" lobby gave $240k to Obama's campaign. That's nothing in a campaign that raised over $1 billion. No, he did it because "anti-coal" is a buzzword, not just for people in coal mining states, but for blue-collar Democrats who equate "anti-coal" with "anti-industrial jobs" and the more liberal elements of the party. The same thing is true of terrorism. There is not a huge public outcry saying "make us safer" but there doesn't need to be. Nobody wants to be painted as "pro terrorist" and the fear of terrorism is still a great way to get a project through the DOD or NSA.
- AutoKorrect 14y agoin the end, this would mean nothing. Think about it: the President already has an extra-Constitutional kill list, why stop there?
- rayiner 14y agoWhat extra-Constitutional kill list? I'm a strong proponent of civil rights, but the rhetoric around the issue is a bit ridiculous. The Constitution doesn't have all of these things you think are in there, and both Due Process and the extra-territorial application of the Constitution are much fuzzier concepts than your rhetoric contemplates. The Constitution is not the be-all, end-all of what should limit governmental action. At the end of the day, we have a democratically elected government. And voters consistently elect people who believe in the god-given right of America to kill any foreigner who poses a threat to the country, with no process at all. Opposition to this policy is, like gun control, something Democrats abandoned at the national level with Clinton in order to keep the party from being swallowed up in obsolescence. I don't agree with it, but you can only fault a President so much for doing what people want him to do.
- StavrosK 14y agoIt's bills like this that make me hope that encrypted communications software like Silent Circle[1] becomes widespread. It's a good way to make large-scale wiretapping impossible. Disclosure: I currently work at Silent Circle. [1]: https://silentcircle.com/ https://silentcircle.com/
- tomjen3 14y agoYeah, that is not going to have any effect. What the military-industrial-congressional complex wants, the military-industrial-congressional complex gets.