4 ms·
I find Microsoft's explanation of the facts to be quite logical. How many users are actually going to interact with an onscreen keyboard using the mouse cursor?
by kevingadd 14y ago
I find Microsoft's explanation of the facts to be quite logical. How many users are actually going to interact with an onscreen keyboard using the mouse cursor? It's already been stated that the supposed exploit doesn't affect the touch keyboard on Win8.
- chris_wot 14y agoAs has been pointed out, at least one bank has a mouse controlled pin keyboard.
- meaty 14y agoSomeone needs to fire their UI guys
- kevingadd 14y agoAre you seriously suggesting that given nothing other than a small window into mouse position and modifier keys (the latter would be useless for a mouse controlled pin keyboard), an attacker would be able to not only identify when the user clicks, but when they're visiting the bank and the alignment of the pin keyboard? And then somehow leverage this information by itself to attack someone without having any of their other personal information? It is certainly information that COULD be useful as part of an attack, but it seems utterly ridiculous that just mouse information would somehow enable you to compromise the security of someone's bank account. Private information should certainly remain private, and I don't doubt that this leakage will be fixed one way or another, but this really seems more like paranoia than anything else unless there's at least a concrete description of how the data provided is enough to actually inflict harm. Lots of potentially useful data is exposed by browsers (and browser plugins) every day; this isn't the only bit.
- JungleFruit 14y agoAs previously stated. This could be used to potentially track entropy of encryption key generation(such as trucrypt or, the new MEGA sites implementation, any site or program that employs mouse-movement/key binding for entropy.) Mega Screenshot: http://cdn.thenextweb.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/files/2012/12/A9h3qnnCQAEhJUc.jpg http://cdn.thenextweb.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/files/2012/... Security Thread on Bank Login virtual keyboard: http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/22774/my-bank-makes-me-enter-my-password-using-the-mouse-whats-up-with-that http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/22774/my-bank-ma... Just something an idiot can think of so, any black-hat is just having fun @ this point.
- kevingadd 14y agoThank you for a more concrete justification. I think I agree that the two links you provided are examples of use cases that could actually be exploited just using the position of the mouse.
- brudgers 14y agoAll internet malfeasance isn't Nigerian banker spam. The vulnerability could be exploited in a whale phishing expedition. One cannot assume that the attacker does not know the specific hardware and software configuration. Nor can one assume that the attacker does not know which website is being accessed. In addition, the ubiquity of IE makes the collection of analyzable data from which patterns may be extracted practical, e.g. one could probably learn to identify specific virtual keyboard layouts. Finally, given the degree to which persons are identifiable while browsing, and the persistence of tracking data, finding whales is perhaps more likely than many people might imagine.
- chris_wot 14y agoWhat's a whale phishing expedition?
- lotharbot 14y agoIn ordinary phishing attacks, malware is sent to the largest possible group with the goal of getting the largest number of backdoors / account credentials / whatever. In "spear" or "whale" phishing, the attack is targeted at specific individuals; whales are high-value targets such as corporate executives. In such cases, the attacker might e-mail a personally-addressed fake subpoena, invoice, or memo using another exec's name.
- to3m 14y agoThe layout of the PIN keyboard at my last bank was randomized for each logon. I always thought this paranoid, but it's now looking prescient...
- ygra 14y agoSlightly tangential to the overall discussion, but I always wondered ... wouldn't even randomisation have to make sure that the key labels are readable with assistive technologies (e.g. not use images without alt attribute or even an image map for the complete keypad) and in that case be accessible to any input logger that bothers to log what controls are clicked? Or are they actually allowed to shut out users with disabilities altogether?
- to3m 14y agoAs I recall, the buttons looked like just ordinary text links in a coloured table, presumably with javascript callbacks for the clicks. So I suppose they'd have been screen reader-friendly enough for use by the blind and so on, while still being random enough by default to defeat mouseloggers, and keyboardless enough by default to defeat keyloggers.
- desas 14y agoING Direct in the UK randomise the position of the keys on the keyboard for each login attempt.