21 ms·
Why we still love board games
- lmm 14y agoWorth noting the article's a couple of years old, as anyone who plays Dominion will realize. I'm always amazed at how much innovation is going on. With board games you'd think that the best ones would all have been figured out decades ago, but it seems like more are being invented than ever.
- d4rti 14y agoThe variety and refinement in game mechanics is great. Browsing BoardGameGeek by mechanic[1] can be useful for new board game selection. [1] http://www.boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgamemechanic http://www.boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgamemechanic
- luu 14y agoWhat's interesting to me is new board games aren't just variants on existing games; there's noticable innovation in board game "technology". If you ever play board games from the 80s and 90s, they often feel dated and clunky, even more so than video games from the same era. I recently went back and played some classic Avalon Hill games that were popular when I was a kid. I can't believe me and my friends spent so much time playing them when we were younger. Depending on the game, a full game might take 5 or 10 hours. For many games, the majority of the time is spent rolling dice, looking things up in tables, and moving stacks of counters around. And that's when you're lucky enough to have a chance to do anything -- there's often half an hour or more of dead time when you're waiting for other players to make their moves. By contrast, if you play a game of Dominion, it's possible to finish a game in 15 minutes. You'll have to make a larger number of important tactical and strategic decisions than you would in most six hour long games from the 80s and there's zero idle time [1]. Even with games that use modern game technology, you can see a noticeable improvement over time. Puerto Rico introduced a move selection system that allowed for serious tactical planning (10+ moves ahead) in a lightweight [2] game that could be finished in half an hour (with experienced players). But, the game wasn't perfect. One weakness was that the player turn order was fixed and very important. If you play a game with one weak player and three strong players, whoever goes after the weak player is almost guaranteed to win. Conversely, if you have one strong player, whoever sits down to the left of that player is going to get crushed. Caylus fixed that by building a mechanism to change turn order into the game itself. Caylus was wildly popular for a year or two, but it's rare to see people play it now. Ironically, the game designer was too good at removing the element of luck for the game to be popular. If you ever played on BSW (an online board game service), you probably ran into 'Alexfrog', who had a record of something like 431 wins and 2 losses. You can predict, with very high probability, the outcome of the game based solely on who's playing, and most people don't like being crushed by the same players over and over again. Another issue the game had was that the gameplay was almost purely tactical. There were only a few viable strategies, so games all had a similar feel to them. Agricola and Dominion fixed the problems Caylus had by adding significant randomization. Not only does that add strategic variety to the games [2], it also means that anyone can win any given game. It would be fun to sit down and draw out a board game tech tree. It might hard to make a decent visualization, though, because of the huge span, plus a high degree of multiple inheritance. [1] There may be some idle time with certain strategies on some of the newer expansions, due to the incredible amount of shuffling required. You can avoid this by playing here: http://dominion.isotropic.org/ http://dominion.isotropic.org/. I tend to play on isotropic even when playing face-to-face games because it's 2x faster normally, and there are some pathological cases where it's over an order of magnitude faster. [2] I'm using 'light' to refer to how cumbersome and complex the game mechanics are. Examples of 'heavy' games are Enemy at the Gates (which has over 1000 counters) and ASL (which has something like 500 pages of rules). [3] Both games do this by strongly randomizing the initial state of the game, and adding a small degree of randomization throughout the game. Technically, Caylus also randomized the initial state, but the initial random state in Caylus was minor; it was just barely enough keep you from pre-computing an opening book, the way you can in chess. Even in Dominion tournament games, where most players have played thousands of games, it's common to see wildly divergent strategies, because neither player has played on a board with a similar starting state, so they both have to figure out the best strategy in real time. I always cringe when that happens, and I realize I'm playing an inferior strategy. It doesn't really help that you can see what they other player is doing, because if you realize that her strategy is superior and try to switch, you'll be doing the same thing, but N turns behind, which is pretty much a guaranteed loss [4]. Your only hope, at that point, is some combination of superior tactical play and luck. [4] Well, not always. A hybrid strategy can work in some cases. It depends on the strategies and the stage of the game. It depends is a safe answer to pretty much any strategy question, which is what makes it interesting.
- lmm 14y agoDominion lets you spend all the time making decisions rather than waiting for other people by having hardly any interaction between players; at times it can feel like a time trial race. I tend to prefer Tanto Cuore; while it's largely a direct rip-off (and the art puts some people off) it gives you more attack options, and the balance shifts to allow a wider variety of strategies (Dominion I find duchies are almost entirely irrelevant, and anything other than going for the high end rarely works). So it's an improvement, but it's so similar I suspect we're converging on the ultimate form of that kind of game. I still need to try Agricola.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoThe "flavor" of Dominion play is hugely dependent on the cards you're playing with. If you feel like there isn't enough interaction between players, I'd recommend giving Intrigue a try. Alchemy generally is a weak set, except for Posession, which is just a completely miserable damn card to have in game for the amount that players can use it to mess with eachother. Prosperity also brings an entirely new way to win to the game: through tokens, which you can accumulate quickly by buying things like Duchies for cheap and then trashing them as quickly as possible. We have a few house rules that allow us to "tune" each game before it starts, and we've had a huge variety of games as a result: everything from 15-minute time trials like you describe, to Dominion "golf" (most negative points wins!), to hour-long slug fests that leave me wanting to flip the table in aggravation. (edit: I've done my fair share of aggravating others though too -- ended up abusing a village-king's court-torturer combo badly enough at one game night that torturer was pretty much forever after banned; the same night a different table got me back with a consistent militia-masquerade 1-2 punch that left me flopping around in the game like a fish out of water. Anyway, there are all kinds of ways to play this game, so if you're finding it repetitive, you're probably missing something!)
- bmj 14y agoI concur about Intrigue, but I don't mind the Alchemy set. During one game with the Familiar, my brother-in-law and I actually managed to deplete the Curse card supply.
- phatbyte 14y agoLately I've been buying some of my child board games like Monopoly, Cluedo, Hotel and such... I noticed that people are going back at this type of games, and I can see it why. It's an awesome excuse to invite some friends to your house, setup a game, get a few drinks and just play, talk and have some fun. You can't do this with videogames. Also, you'de be amazed at how much a good strategy boarding game can reveal of someone's personality.
- lmm 14y agoSeriously, try some modern, German-style boardgames like those described in the article - settlers if you play with people who pay attention, something slightly less interaction-heavy (san juan?) if you don't. You'll be amazed how far game design has progressed since the ones you remember from childhood.
- d4rti 14y agoThere are also a number of excellent collaborative games, such as Pandemic, or the new(ish) and very quick Escape: The Curse of the Temple. These are great if you want a less competitive atmosphere.
- saraid216 14y agoI'd add recommendations for Cosmic Encounter, whose mechanic of destiny makes its competitive nature a lot more amenable to my tastes, and Flash Point, which is like Pandemic but about firefighters rather than CDC people and would probably be a lot more accessible to kids.
- StavrosK 14y agoDobble is amazing for everyone, and it's great fun to explain it for the first time ("each two cards have only one shape in common, you have to find it") and hear people go "That's it? That's easy!" and then shout in frustration when they realize it's almost impossible :P Also, Jungle Speed, Cockroach Salad, Halli Galli are pretty fun speed games. Tokyo Train is a classic for four people as well.
- cletus 14y agoCached: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:QnHbzVYOm-cJ:timharford.com/2010/07/why-we-still-love-board-games/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:QnHbzVY... German-style boardgames are my favourite hobby. I've played probably 300+ different ones now. Perennial favourites include Agricola, Dominion, Ora et Labora (relatively new), Age of Steam and Titan (played this to death in the 90s, not so much now but I still love the game). For me these games are a sweet spot between traditional family games (which tend to be largely luck-based and not very "deep") and the truly deep games of Go, Chess and even Bridge, probably even Poker. The former group is (for me) unfulfilling. The latter group is (again, for me) a massive time sink. You can play a lot of games online now but honestly I don't like that. For me, it is both an intellectual and a social activity. German style boardgames have been around for many years but they saw a renaissance that probably began with Settlers of Catan in the 90s that then exploded in the 2000s with Carcassonne and Puerto Rico and what came after. It's a great hobby, particularly if you can find people to play with (physically) in your area, which doesn't tend to be a huge issue in urban centers. EDIT: to clarify what a "German style" game is (commonly just called a "Eurogame"), it's basically a set of principles. Eurogames: 1. Tend not to be elimination games (all players generally are in the game until the end); 2. Tend to de-emphasize or eliminate direct conflict where your side or units or whatever directly attack those of other players; 3. Tend to minimize luck to varying degrees. Some games (eg Caylus) are perfect information games; and 4. Tend to take 1-2 hours to play; 5. Typically have a central board and a bunch of brightly coloured wooden pieces; and 6. Are often played by 3-5 players but can often be played with 2, occasionally 6, rarely more. These are not hard and fast rules. Contrast this with what are called "Ameritrash" games (which isn't as derisive as it sounds).
- yycom 14y agoThanks for telling us about your favorite hobby, how many you have played, where it fits in your personal spectrum, that it has been around for many years, and giving us some titles! But, what is a German-style board game?
- hendrik-xdest 14y ago
- yycom 14y agoOn iPad: how do I get this in the google cache??
- RaSoJo 14y agoThe link to the original content on FT would be easier: http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/1aab09a4-8fb2-11df-8df0-00144feab49a.html#axzz2F1syyIU9 http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/1aab09a4-8fb2-11df-8df0-00144...
- anakha 14y agoJunta is an example of a older well playing board game if you have 5-7 people. Especially good for a mature crowd and with appropriate props like hats and sunglasses. http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/242/junta http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/242/junta
- eru 14y agoIf you have seven people who like that kind of game, and have enough time on their hands, the 1900 variant of Diplomacy is also worth a try. But make sure they can separate backstabbing in-game, from behaviour in real life.
- michaelochurch 14y agoBoard games are discrete and closed, often in a well-thought-out and beautiful way. It's generally intended as a social experience, but the discrete world makes the game possible to take apart and analyze, so that if you want to dive deep into the game, you can. It's up to you what kind of experience you want to have. If you want to play today and forget who won tomorrow, that's fine. On the other hand, if you want to get analytical about why starting that external conflict in a game of T&E was such a good (or bad) move, you can do that as well. In a continuous, real-time computer game, you can't as easily reason "to the bottom" because the mathematical microstructure is hidden, and often emergent. Germany, Hungary, and to some degree, France, have a really strong (tabletop) gaming culture, which is a really cool thing. I tend to think that games confer a lot of benefits not just for "weird gamer types", but for everyone. It's a lot easier to get to know people over a board game than when there is nothing "in the center" to talk about: can people really carry on a 2-hour conversation about the fucking weather? I'm a weather geek and even I would prefer not to (possibly because I know from experience that it bores most people). I actually think there's space in the world for a "board game cafe" niche. Instead of board games being a fringe activity that require corralling people, I don't see why there couldn't be a revival of the culture where a person can walk into a coffee shop at any time and find a game.
- kriro 14y agoI love to analyze games and as a programmer there's quite a bit of neat stuff you can do due to the discreteness. Build DSLs for the game logic or strategy, the whole field of AI, modelling of games as FSM, Petri Nets whatever seems interesting. There are quite a few of these cafes. They have game collections and you can rent a table+game and pay for the drinks. You can also bring you own etc. the atmosphere is usually pretty nice/relaxed.
- michaelochurch 14y agoAre you taking this Coursera course, in April? https://www.coursera.org/course/ggp https://www.coursera.org/course/ggp It looks really interesting.
- mikeknoop 14y agoHaven't seen these mentioned yet, and I recommend both: Powergrid: Unique because there are no dice involved; a game of economics Steam: Unique because there is a bank (partly tied to your score) that you can borrow against to build pieces faster
- throwaway1979 14y agoI love powergrid! I recall the last two turns require a lot of calculations. When I played with non-mathematically oriented people (most people in my life), they got frustrated.
- jdludlow 14y agoPower Grid has a lot of simple arithmetic. You're adding numbers in your head constantly. Barring a runaway leader, the endgame tends to have a slingshot effect where the person who is "leading" is actually behind those who are currently in 2nd or 3rd place. Timing this come-from-behind win is a big part of the fun for me. It's the #6 game on BoardGameGeek [1], and well deserved to be there. Saying that "it's filled with math" doesn't make it sound all that exciting, but there's a good spacial element, an auction system that gets quite tense at times, and opportunity for "screw you" behavior that actually pays off. The winner is typically the one who was most efficient and has made some clever plays to keep his opponents out of his chosen markets. [1] http://www.boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgame http://www.boardgamegeek.com/browse/boardgame
- T-hawk 14y agoI found Power Grid to be significantly improved by keeping a calculator on hand for all that addition. How much of my hundred can I bid on this power plant? Well I need four oil this turn at what might be seven cost each, and I want to buy three houses at fifteen, so that means forty five plus twenty eight is seventy three, so I can spend up to twenty seven in this auction. There's no reason to force all that mental arithmetic, and it really sucks if someone loses because they missed carrying a digit mentally. Just use a calculator to abstract away the math and speed things up.
- ygra 14y agoSomething I found quite nice was a web series by Wil Wheaton: TableTop (http://tabletop.geekandsundry.com/ http://tabletop.geekandsundry.com/) which basically consists of a round of people playing a board game, explaining the rules and generally having fun doing so. The nice part is that you can experience how the game is played and whether you might like it or not – much better than just with a verbal description or review on Amazon. Of course, for cities that have such a thing, a dedicated board game shop where you can try out games is even better, but those seem to be rare, even in Germany.
- jdludlow 14y agoMinneapolis has an embarrassment of riches on this front. We have game shops everywhere and dozens of public groups that meet regularly. There's also a monthly gathering that typically runs Friday to Sunday (16 hours each), and sells out its 90 person capacity almost instantly. The groups are very newbie friendly, which is typical for this hobby.
- kriro 14y agoI've always had this hypothesis that if a country has a strong cultural background in games people tend to have good critical thinking skills c.p. The case study for this would be Germany. Either way I'm pretty convinced playing board games with children is an excellent thing to do to foster their development (sadly in this day and age it almost seems spending any time with your kids puts you way ahead of the curve already as far as parenting goes). It's fun, too. Crowdfunding seems to work pretty well for board games btw. And I wouldn't be shocked to hear that passionate board gamers make good startup guys (poker players seemingly do)
- eru 14y ago> Either way I'm pretty convinced playing board games with children is an excellent thing to do to foster their development Planning. Simple arithmetic. Social interaction. Patience. Sure, that's going to be useful.
- PussyRiot 14y agoMy main problem with board games is that they're too expensive sometimes.
- kriro 14y agoIf I'd do a ROI analysis on all my board games most of them beat out lots of other social activities. If an average game lasts maybe an hour and you play it with an average of 3 players that's 3h of entertainment per play. 10-15 Euros per hour of entertainment seems very reasonable so most games actually tend to pay for themselves after just one play if oyu look at it that way.
- archon 14y agoAnd with sites such as boardgamegeek, there isn't as much risk involved unless you're buying just-released games. I've had my copy of Dominion for over three years. I got it on sale for $30. I've played literally hundreds of games since I bought it. Granted, I've added expansions over the years. But let's assume I paid full retail price for the game and four expansions: around $225. I've played at least 300 20-to-60 minute games. Conservatively, 100 hours of gameplay time. $2.25 an hour to entertain myself and 1 to 5 friends is an amazing value proposition.
- jdludlow 14y agoBoardGameGeek also has an active secondary market, lowering the risk of new purchases. Unless the game is utterly terrible, you'll be able to recoup some of your money. The user auctions there fetch high enough prices that I would not hesitate to sell there as opposed to eBay. They also have their own marketplace where users can sell games at fixed prices, but the organic "hey I want to sell these, who wants to give me cash" lists of games[1] are quite successful. [1] http://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/66420/metalist-for-geeklist-auctions http://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/66420/metalist-for-geeklis...
- b0rsuk 14y ago1. You can play at fantasy/SF club. You will only pay a monthly fee, if any. 2. On http://boardgamearena.com http://boardgamearena.com , you can play several dozen board games for free. No flash, it uses HTML5 magic.
- JimWestergren 14y agoI absolutely love board games and card games. And I love to think about game mechanics. If I would not be a web developer I would love to work with this kind of game development. I have developed a version of Magic the Gathering which is played with a normal 52 card deck (one deck per person) with much more simple rules and good strategy (better?) and less luck. I have played it around 100 times and the rules are finalized. I think I should translate the rules to English. A note about Monopoly, the new card game Monopoly Deal is actually quite good as a family game with simple rules and around 20 minutes.
- endersshadow 14y agoI'm very curious--is there a way for me to play this game? I'd love to get the rules from you and try it out. I loved the mechanics in Magic when I was younger, and I'd love to not have to buy all the cards and worry about building a deck, and just be able to play the game with my fiance without telling her it's Magic.
- eru 14y ago> [...] I'd love to not have to buy all the cards and worry about building a deck [...] You might also want to try the booster draft format of Magic.
- JimWestergren 14y agoI will get back to you once I have translated it. Shoot me an email.
- b0rsuk 14y agohttp://code.google.com/p/magarena/ http://code.google.com/p/magarena/ Magarena is a GPLed program to play almost Magic: the Gathering. There is only a small rule modification to simplify AI calculations: the defender chooses how combat damage is distributed, not the attacker. Magarena doesn't have ALL the cards - only close to 3000 - but it has disturbingly good AI. Several AI algorithms to choose from, in fact. It plays like a bastard, and despite having a few flaws (sometimes it performs suicide attacks, it doesn't save cards for later, is bad with activated abilities and doesn't guess what card you might have in hand) you will dearly regret underestimating it. More cards are coming, but each new mechanic needs to be coded separately.
- RTigger 14y agoLove this article. I think the end captures it perfectly - there's really nothing else that gets the same social interaction as board games. At work we use board games on a daily basis for team building, usually play a 1-hour-or-less game over every lunch. It's amazing how quickly you get to know someone and how those relationships build and blend into your work as well. You can see how someone teaches a new person how to play the game, how they interact with alliances and respond to attacks from other people. Some 1-hour games we play for reference, if anyone's interested: Dominion - Already discussed in another post :) (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/36218/dominion http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/36218/dominion) 7 Wonders - Drafting based card game where you interact with your immediate neighbours (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/68448/7-wonders http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/68448/7-wonders) Race for the Galaxy - Card game where action choices enable other players (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/28143/race-for-the-galaxy http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/28143/race-for-the-galaxy) Lords of Waterdeep - D&D themed worker placement game (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/110327/lords-of-waterdeep http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/110327/lords-of-waterdeep) Stone Age - Most "german" game of this list, worker placement and resource gathering with dice (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/34635/stone-age http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/34635/stone-age) Space Alert - co-op game where the main game mechanic is "communication" (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/38453/space-alert http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/38453/space-alert) Galaxy Trucker - fun tile-based spaceship construction game (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/31481/galaxy-trucker http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/31481/galaxy-trucker) The Resistance - 2 out of the 5 players are secretly spies (http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/41114/the-resistance http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/41114/the-resistance) I wrote this list out in a bit more detail on my website: http://rtigger.com/blog/2012/12/14/board-games-are-great/ http://rtigger.com/blog/2012/12/14/board-games-are-great/
- JimWestergren 14y agoWow, sounds like real fun to work there :)
- peapicker 14y agoWe play a lot of those on game-lunch Fridays... also popular at our lunches: Core Worlds ( http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/98351/ http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/98351/ ) Quarriors ( http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/91536/ http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/91536/ ) Infinite City ( http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/46807/ http://www.boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/46807/ ) We occasionally have a Saturday game day among friends for longer games, but these three are great less-than-an-hour games. Core Worlds is about an hour, the other two will get you 2 to 3 games in in an hour.
- itemshoppe 14y agoQuinns from Shut Up & Sit Down did a fantastic talk about the current "Board Gaming Golden Age" at GameCity this year! http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4921146 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4921146
- intinig 14y agoI would have never expected a thread like this to pop up on hacker news :) Anyway I have to weigh in and suggest to try a game I produced with some friends (by co-founding a publishing company): Al Rashid (http://www.yemaia.com/al-rashid http://www.yemaia.com/al-rashid -- http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/127282/al-rashid http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/127282/al-rashid). I think most people with a development background are naturally disposed towards liking eurogames, and in my case to work on one :)
- cpeterso 14y agoThe Ludemetic Game Generator [1] is an amusing, and often inspiring, fictional game generator. It randomly combines BoardGameGeek.com's game category and mechanics keywords to create a new game. Some random examples: * Web Tycoon in Space: Categories: Expansion for Base-game, American Indian Wars, Mythology. Mechanics: Commodity Speculation, Hand Management. * Popbid: Categories: Music, Territory Building. Mechanics: Auction/Bidding, Modular Board. [1] http://kevan.org/ludeme http://kevan.org/ludeme
- javanix 14y agoAlso enjoyable is building and designing a board game from the ground up. Similar to software development in that you need constant iteration, much different in that it takes forever to implement and test those iterations.
- vampirechicken 14y agoI miss playing 8 board, 5 flag roborally marathons.
- smoyer 14y agoMy daughter has been an avid board-gamer for several years and just started the 3D board game club at the University of Alabama. Look it up if you're in the area and want to find a group to play with! http://cw.ua.edu/2012/10/29/3d-board-game-club-introduces-new-way-to-interact/ http://cw.ua.edu/2012/10/29/3d-board-game-club-introduces-ne...
- henrik_w 14y agoNot strictly a board game (nor German-style), but I'll just mention the card game Set too (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_(game) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_(game)). It's quick to play, both adult and children can play together, and you can play against each other or work together to find the sets. We've brought it to a ski trip with two other families, and it was a hit. Maybe it is well known, but I hadn't heard of it until I read about it here on HN (Peter Norvig had simulated the odds of not finding a set, http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1303797 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1303797). Having played for a while, I ran my own simulations. The results differed a bit from Peter Norvig's. I wrote it up here: http://henrikwarne.com/2011/09/30/set-probabilities-revisited/ http://henrikwarne.com/2011/09/30/set-probabilities-revisite...