3 ms·
If one is fetching emails without SSL, does that mean the data is sent in clear text over the wire? In that case, self-signed do provide greater than zero prot
by belorn 14y ago
If one is fetching emails without SSL, does that mean the data is sent in clear text over the wire?
In that case, self-signed do provide greater than zero protection in regard to ISP surveillance and other passive attacks. (similar to smtp tls encryption, enabled by default by almost all mail servers, and uses self-signed certificates).
- rdl 14y agoI use "real" certs on my START TLS enabled mail servers; it's not that hard to set up, and people should. (free certs from StartSSL, but still "real")
- Nursie 14y agoOnly if there isn't running some sort of self-signed detecting MITM running. Which is not that hard - I made a trivial one that pretends to be a DNS server and hands out phoney addresses, then both forwards and dumps all traffic in ~250 lines of python. But yes, it would stop purely passive attacks, unless I'm missing something.
- RyanZAG 14y agoSure, but this is the same as having a locked door with a window next to it that anybody who knows how can reach through and unlock the door. You can say that having the locked door is better - it will stop anybody who does not think to unlock the door through the window. It also stops any robots that come past who are programmed only to try the door-handle and move on if it fails. Problems start to come in when you put this security on a warehouse and customers leave their secure items inside having been assured that the door is locked. Clearly, anybody can just reach through the window, unlock the door, and take the secure items and the customer is left wondering why the advertised locked door didn't help them. Setting up a MITM mail server for an ISP that will happily proxy between the real server and the requester is as trivially easy as reaching through an open window. When asked, they could just say that it is for 'security purposes' and it helps with 'caching'. If your email provider is willing to snoop on all your email, they're probably willing to tell a few lies also.