6 ms·
Alan Turing: Scientists call for pardon for codebreaker
- EiZei 14y agoHow about a blanket pardon for anyone ever convicted of consentual homosexual relationships?
- elssar 14y agoAlan Turing's contributions to science and the war time effort were immense, and immeasurable. However, granting a pardon to him and him alone won't mean much. He was guilty. The law which he broke was draconian, no doubts about it, but it was the law at that time. I do not think he was the only Briton who was oppressed because of that particular law. If there is a pardon, and there should be one, it should be granted to everyone who was convicted under that law.
- brnstz 14y agoI agree any pardon should be a blanket one. I wonder about semantics though. Is someone really "guilty" of breaking an unjust law? It's like saying someone is "guilty" of freeing a slave. An unjust law is no law at all, and usually people have to break it before it is changed.
- saraid216 14y agoAs far as I know, no one has been pardoned for freeing slaves, either.
- justincormack 14y agoVery importantly slaves were allowed to be freed, by a court of law in the UK.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somersetts_Case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somersetts_Case
- elssar 14y agoGuilty of breaking the law of the time? Semantics? Guess you could say "he broke a law. There shouldn't have been such a law, but unfortunately it was there, and he broke it."
- mindcrime 14y agoIs someone really "guilty" of breaking an unjust law? No. An unjust law is no law at all Agreed. So, in this case, a "pardon", now that I think about it, isn't exactly the right thing, in a sense. I mean, it's a nice token gesture, but it still implies that a law was actually broken. An apology for being victimized by a non-law would be more appropriate.
- elssar 14y agoInteresting point. At first I was gonna say semantics, but in this case it matters. Guess they need to phrase it better when they start quashing the convictions.
- darkarmani 14y ago> He was guilty. That the only time a pardon is needed.
- nicholassmith 14y agoThe most sensible thing to do with the situation is the blanket pardon, but I can't see it happening. I think they've made blanket apologies before (slavery springs to mind), but never a blanket pardon.
- Nursie 14y agoI can't see that happening right now. The PM has announced that Gay Marriage is going to become a thing here imminently. It's a weird bill because it actually forbids the state church from performing homosexual marriages, not even leaving it open for the church itself to decide, but it does allow other churches to make their own decisions and civil ceremonies to take place. This is a major step (IMHO) but it has had the usual backlash of small minded folks spouting on about family values and how their rights are being eroded (?!) so politically a blanket, retroactive pardon seems very unlikely. Baby steps...
- stan_rogers 14y agoThe Church of England is in a bit of a weird position here. It's not so much that Parliament has unilaterally decided that the C of E shall not perform same-sex marriages, but that, as the established Church with the monarch at its legal head, it is as much a creature of advised royal decree and legislation as it is of the 39 Articles or the General Synod (represented by Canterbury). That results in areas of church law originating outside of Parliament winding up in legislation.
- justincormack 14y agoAnd the C of E did not ask to be treated differently from other churches. Bizarre Tory oddness as always.
- _stephan 14y agoOr better: retroactively declare the old law null and void and pay compensation to all victims that were prosecuted under it.
- meaty 14y agoThis is exactly what they should be doing, but they will downplay it as all the publicity will actually detract from the current ruling elite's appearance (even if it wasn't them who made the law up).
- Crake 14y agoThey probably all committed suicide. It's a really common end for GLBT, unfortunately.
- 7952 14y agoOr create a memorial. It is in fashion at the moment in the UK. If all you are offering is a gesture, it may as well be something tangible.
- jgrahamc 14y agoAs people on HN probably know I'm opposed to this: http://blog.jgc.org/2011/11/why-im-not-supporting-campaign-for.html http://blog.jgc.org/2011/11/why-im-not-supporting-campaign-f... Most importantly I find the following line from the letter disturbing: "To those who seek to block attempts to secure a pardon with the argument that this would set a precedent, we would answer that Turing's achievements are sui generis." They are arguing that Turing uniquely deserves a pardon because of his genius. That itself would set a terrible precedent because it would appear that the eminent Lords believe that being a great man puts you above the law.
- elssar 14y agoIn that blog post you point out that there was a legislation in the British parliament that would roll back convictions of gays, and that it was close to becoming a law. Whatever happened to it?
- meaty 14y agoI think they got bored and continued to roll out more draconian surveillance laws instead which are obviously of more interest to the political elite... I have very little faith in the government to do the right thing.
- jgrahamc 14y agoIt became law on May 1, 2012 when it received Royal Assent. http://services.parliament.uk/bills/2010-12/protectionoffreedoms.html http://services.parliament.uk/bills/2010-12/protectionoffree...
- elssar 14y agoSo isn't this new petition kinda irrelevant?
- laumars 14y agoI'm inclined to agree. I really wish that things could have turned out different for Turing and think the law was -at best- completely idiotic. But pardoning someone for a law in force at the time sets such a dangerous precedence. Not least of all because -as great a man as Turing was- every other victim of this law would them equally deserve a pardon too (and you know what's going to happen next; some of the less reputable descendants of the aforementioned will no doubt sue the government for an absurd amount of damages). This is one of those instances where I think the government are in a no-win situation. Either option is crappy.
- Svip 14y agoLed to his suicide? I think that is assuming too much. I've read plenty of material suggesting his suicide was an accident, considering his new experiments with drugs, while generally appearing content to the people around him. Now, obviously, he could have been masked this whole thing by playing a game, and the experiments was purely a cover for killing himself. But that doesn't make sense to me; why didn't he leave a note? Why would Alan Turing kill himself without letting the whole world know what happened? The lack of clearcut evidence (and what seems like a strange way to kill one self; there are plenty of easier choices) leaves me to believe that his death was accidental and not a suicide.
- Jtsummers 14y agoRe contentedness: I said this last time this topic came up. It is not uncommon for suicidal people to seem happy or at peace once they've committed themselves to the act. The stress that causes the desire has been in some sense resolved, they know it will be over soon. Re note: Not everyone leaves a note. None of the people I've known who killed (or attempted) themselves left notes, though most of us could guess at why. What would he have said in a note? A quick google search suggests that only about a quarter of suicides leave a note. EDIT: Re method: People kill themselves with all sorts of methods. A poisoned apple could've struck him as ironic, poetic, or perhaps easier to use than pills or a gun. Overall though, suicide is a messy business. Method, motive, behaviour of people who commit or attempt it is all over the map. Sometimes you can (in retrospect) say that it was obvious, many times you can't. Some people are good at acting happy or at least not sad. Others pass it off as just being tired. Some will plan out their methods in detail (like a poisoned apple may have been), others will see a bottle or a gun and use it that instant before they can reconsider. However, since some evidence wasn't examined at the time it's impossible to rule out an accident. On the other hand, nothing in the narrative easily dismisses the notion of suicide. This was 60 years ago, any attempt at this point to rewrite it is based on speculation from second hand accounts and has no ability to examine physical evidence to prove the theory.
- darkarmani 14y ago> Led to his suicide? I think that is assuming too much. You mean cutting him off from all of his research and shaming him to all of his peers is assuming too much??
- tubelite 14y agoPardon? Pardon, a pardon?! An apology is what he deserves and what he got. To use words like 'pardon' and 'forgive' carries the very strong connotation that what he did was wrong, and we're being nice by forgiving his mistakes. I mean, half the great men in the history of the last century have had the honour of being jailed by the British. Imagine the Queen issuing a posthumous "pardon" to Gandhi. I can scarcely imagine a worse insult to his memory.
- Svip 14y agoI thought pardons - even posthumous ones - were about undoing a false conviction based on later evidence (or good connections). Of course, the pardon of Nixon does not fall into this category. Then again, I agree with your analogy of pardoning Gandhi.
- tubelite 14y agoUndoing a false conviction is fine, but they really ought to use a better word. Exonerate. Vindicate. Absolve. (Then again, I don't understand the idea of the President 'pardoning' a turkey either. What's the turkey done? Headed a Wall Street investment bank?)
- jerf 14y agoA pardon is a legal term. It is related to, but not equal to, its plain English meaning. Law will forever confuse you if you insist on trying to use plain English meanings. For that matter, you're going to have some serious problems as a programmer, too. There's hardly any term that two programming communities have the exact same definition for.
- peeters 14y agoPardons are not, nor have ever been, about undoing a false conviction based on later evidence. You don't need a pardon in that case; you need an appeal which will overturn your conviction. That's not to say a pardon couldn't be used for this purpose; but the judicial branch can ordinarily handle it itself. Pardons are usually an executive power to to absolve someone (clear their record). Commutation is similar, where you do not negate the guilt but reduce or eliminate the punishment. Both are tools used for various reasons. In Canada, many minor crimes are pardoned years after a criminal has been reformed to clear their record. IMO this is in general a good thing, but then there are cases like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_James_(ice_hockey)#Pardon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_James_(ice_hockey)#Pardo... Pardons and commutes are also used to balance out a flawed justice system or one that has its hands tied (e.g. with mandatory minimums). This can include people being sent to prison for years for minor drug crimes, etc.