3 ms·
I find it extremely unlikely that someone can conceive of and take the time patent something so novel that someone, somewhere, hasn't already tried it at least
by astrodust 14y ago
I find it extremely unlikely that someone can conceive of and take the time patent something so novel that someone, somewhere, hasn't already tried it at least once.
In those rare cases, it should be a requirement to produce a detailed description of the method by which the desired result is achieved, and that the patent would cover that specific method.
"Attaching a computer to a database" is not a method. A very specific driver format employing particular protocols is.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoThat's at the heart of what it is to be a patent. It is neither an idea, nor a specific device. Its supposed to be a technique or method or something equally slippery - thus all the lawyers have something to argue about.
- ahlatimer 14y ago> it should be a requirement to produce a detailed description of the method by which the desired result is achieved In theory, that's how it is. In order to receive a patent, you must first "reduce it to practice". That doesn't mean you have to build it yourself, but it does mean that you have to describe it in sufficient enough detail that a person of "ordinary skill in the art" should be able to actually build it. In practice, that doesn't happen. Part of that is that a lot of really general patents got through in the 90s, as the article states. Another part is that patents are written in such thick legalese that you almost need formal education just to make sense of the language, and most people in software won't even bother.
- rayiner 14y agoThat's exactly what a patent is! You don't patent "communicating wirelessly between two devices." That's a result. Instead, you patent something like OFDM, a particular, novel, way of achieving that result. Infringement is only found if someone else not only achieves the same result, but does so in substantially the same way. Even further, the scope of that way is cabined by prior art--you only get to claim protection over the parts of that mechanism that are actually novel.
- shasta 14y ago...in theory...