3 ms·
Could you talk about what you think the contradictions between Friedman's and Kahneman's work are? As someone who respects both of them I don't really see many
by Symmetry 14y ago
Could you talk about what you think the contradictions between Friedman's and Kahneman's work are? As someone who respects both of them I don't really see many except for the Permanent Income Hypothesis which, though, Friedman was very proud of it nobody else seems to think of when they talk about him. His work on the role of money in the economy which he got his Nobel for was all very empirical, and when events showed he was wrong about the stability of velocity he was quick to change his views.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm (lazily) using Friedman as a proxy for the whole Chicago School. I think once behavioral economics forces you to abandon the rational actor model, you really have to go back and reevaluate all the places where you (explicitly and sometimes implicitly) assume that economic actors are rationally wealth-maximizing. With Friedman specifically, this is particularly relevant in all the situations where he wanders away from empiricism (e.g. in his role as economic advisor to Reagan).
- nickik 14y agoI very much agree that the ration acter model is BS. Even befor behavioral economics it was BS, I think it should have been common sence. What has to be considerd is that goverment actors are just as dumb ass market acters, with the importend diffrance that there own ass is not on the line. I think the biggest error in 20 century economics has been to think that the general equillibrium model has any relevane to the real world.
- rayiner 14y ago> I think the biggest error in 20 century economics has been to think that the general equillibrium model has any relevane to the real world. We can agree on this part, and I'll further add that it's also a tremendous error to ignore that the equillibrium is dynamic and to ignore or downplay what happens in the intermediate periods during which the system is in disequillibrium.
- nickik 14y agoThe study of disequillibrium is the only thing importend in the real world. To explain how the market reaches equillibrium (mostly only in theory) or how it at least sometimes moves towards equillibrium (mostly in the real world) is what economic analysis must provide. Just like Darwin explained what make evolution work. The Theory behind this is called Market Process Theory, it is mostly created by people from the Austrian School of Economics but also from a lot of swedish economist.