10 ms·
My impression is the opposite - Google Maps' data is so much better that it hardly matters, but this app seriously lacks polish. For instance, it's laggy - iOS
by comex 14y ago
My impression is the opposite - Google Maps' data is so much better that it hardly matters, but this app seriously lacks polish. For instance, it's laggy - iOS 6 Maps doesn't always make 60fps, which is a shame, but this app doesn't even try. Simply panning around (on my 4S) is enough to produce serious stuttering; even the simple transition to the side menu is not smooth. Or consider Street View, which is missing the signature transition as you "move" from one place to another.
edit: Opening the side menu, for its matter, visually seems to depend on hitting a tiny tap target; there is hidden space to the left of the target but not above it, which is the natural place I tried tapping. The menu itself is weirdly designed (giant spacing) and prone to accidental dismissal by someone trying to scroll it.
No bookmarks either.
- packetslave 14y agoFor the side menu, try swiping left near the icon, like it's a "handle" to pull out the menu. Works for me, and it seems to be how they're distinguishing "open the menu" vs. "pan the map left"
- comex 14y agoOh... I didn't realize it was a handle. It looks too much like a vertical ellipsis.
- cbhl 14y agoA vertical ellipsis-like icon is what they use on Android to indicate menus nowadays... :/
- jamie_ca 14y agoFor at least one version of the Android style guides, that's supposed to be the standard for indicating "more menu options are available"
- guelo 14y agoI wonder if Apple has patented their "flip up the corner of the page" animation doohickey from their map apps.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoNow, if there was an easy way to kill/hide driving directions when I don't need it anymore, and return to the plain map, that would be great.
- pooriaazimi 14y ago> No bookmarks either. I think for bookmarks, you have to sign in (with your Google account, or a dummy one) and save them in your account. Not sure though, haven't tried yet (and probably won't, as I don't need it). And I agree about polish. You have a 4S. I have a 4. It barely makes 20 fps.
- FireBeyond 14y ago"I have a 2 1/2 year old phone, and applications, especially animations, don't render as fast". I'm not entirely surprised, admittedly - and depending on your use case (for me, anyway), it doesn't so much matter.
- illicium 14y agoAnimations in built-in apps are buttery smooth, and always have been, ever since the first iPhone. The problem is with newer iOS apps that are either unoptimized or heavily UIWebView based. The newest Gmail app is definitely mostly HTML5, and I suspect this one is as well.
- FireBeyond 14y agoI wouldn't go that far, my ex's 3GS struggled when upgraded to iOS 5, and complaints about that were widespread.
- mtgx 14y agoIs Apple Maps even Apple for iPhone 4? Because if it's not, then it would've probably had the same issues. iPhone 4 had a really slow GPU - one of the slowest around at the time it launched, especially with the "retina display". It consistently scored at the bottom of GPU benchmarks. Remember the iPhone 4S GPU was 7x faster according to Apple.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoYou're certainly right about its CPU being very slow, but still, all other apps that use Apple's UIKit (standard visual elements, like menu bars, sliders, buttons, etc. - it doesn't matter if they're "stock", or are heavily modified/themed) are just as fast as they are on iPhone 5 or iPad 4. GMaps uses something else for the UI (the "slide from side" thing) and that's the problem. Still, I'm not really complaining. As a developer I know it's hard to write something that both pleases you aesthetically, and is performant on all devices!
- cremnob 14y agoIs the lag any better on an iPhone 5?
- carbocation 14y agoYes, I notice zero lag on my 5. I'm connected to fios/wifi, though I can't imagine that being the driver of lag.
- elithrar 14y agoIt's very smooth on my iPhone 5, but it does have moments where you can notice a bit of frame drop (only if you've read this comment thread beforehand). From a UI/UX perspective: + Fonts and text entry are great + Search speed and interface speed are fantastic - The pull-out menu on the right (akin to a hamburger menu) feels a bit odd and it's not immediately clear as to what it does (they are layer toggles for traffic/transit routes/satellite) - I can't figure out how to bookmark my home or work addresses (whilst being logged in) - if there is a way it is not intuitive.
- nsp 14y agoYou're right - it's not intuitive. To set your work and home while logged in, click the person on the upper right and then the gear then edit home or work?
- ghshephard 14y agoBookmarks (while logged in) require you to find a location, and then slide-up to reveal the "save star". You use the slide-up option to "Share" and "Switch to street view" as well. If it's a business, the "Call" / Website / Zaggat(?) rating is available from slide up.
- ajanuary 14y agoTap the person icon to the right of the search bar, from there you can enter home and work.
- packetslave 14y agoI don't have a 4 or 4s to compare with, but I haven't noticed any significant lag on iPhone 5 over Verizon LTE. Even satellite and street view are pretty responsive.
- jarcoal 14y agoSeconded. Apple may have set the bar really low for data, but they set it really high for interface and usability.
- arrrg 14y agoUsability? In this app you can actually switch different modes of navigation (car, on foot, public transport) after the route is displayed to you. That, at least, is something this app has over Apple’s app.
- jarcoal 14y agoBy usability I meant ease-of-use.
- arrrg 14y agoAnd I named an example where the Google maps app has excellent ease of use.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoThat's a nice feature I guess but I agree that the UI is quite bad. Tapping on a spot does nothing. To get a pin you have to tap and hold. Tapping on your new pin again does nothing but make the stupid toolbar bounce. Tapping on the toolbar brings it up partially. You have to swipe it to get the full view. And getting options took me 30 seconds to figure out. There is that stupid tab with 3 little dots. Public transport data is available for Sydney on the web but curiously missing in the app. And asking me to sign in on start up. Really? Get out of my face unless I explicitly ask to sign in through the standard iOS settings app. Of course correct data and great search trumps all complaints.
- taligent 14y agoDid you notice the lack of POIs in Sydney ? Really weird.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y ago
- shock-value 14y agoI'm also on a 4S and it doesn't feel laggy to me. In particular I'm feeling much fewer "hiccups" as new data comes in than I do with Apple Maps. Now, at the same time, it does seem to be locked at 30fps rather than 60 (as in Apple Maps). So it's not quite as silky smooth in that respect, I suppose, but it'll also drain battery more slowly.
- acchow 14y ago> but it'll also drain battery more slowly. Doesn't really work that way, especially in a triple-buffering system.
- shock-value 14y agoCan you elaborate? If you are drawing to the buffers at half the rate (and correspondingly swapping them out at half the rate), how would that not be easier on the graphics processor?
- acchow 14y agoTriple-buffering allows for arbitrary relative speeds. The result is, you draw to the buffer as fast as you can in total disregard of the actual refresh rate. So they're both at "100%" CPU/GPU, but that simply isn't enough for Google Maps.
- shock-value 14y agoI think Google actually locked Google Maps at 30fps though. In other words, I don't think it is actually drawing as fast as the processor would allow, were Google to remove that lock. Otherwise I'd expect to see more fluctuation in the framerate of the app, especially when there isn't much detail on the screen (similar to Apple Maps, which is obviously not locked to 30fps).
- dakrisht 14y agoZero lag on a 4S and a 5 - not sure what's wrong with your device... Great release, you can swipe from the outside edge of the display to open the sidebar, not a big deal. This release is fantastic and will only get better with time
- ebf 14y agoPanning isn't as smooth as Apple Maps, but the map draws itself way faster.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoIt's fine on iPhone 4 too.
- ghshephard 14y agoI've been playing with both of them, side by side for about 30 minutes. Google maps feels about 2x faster. Unlike IOS 6 maps (this is on my iPhone 5), I can't seem to scroll fast enough to get ahead of the map cacheing. I definitely feel like I'm getting a more FPS than IOS 6 Maps. This suggests this is a CPU/Graphics issue? Re: Side Menu - Unlike those stupid tiny x marks in the notification tray which I can never hit on my first try, I can't seem to miss opening the side menu. Are you swipe-in opening it? It's not a push, but a swipe. Bookmarks are there - you just have to click "save" when you open the item. Then clicking on an empty search bar will bring them up.
- czhiddy 14y agoNot sure how you're getting the 2x fps sensation. On a 4S, using the OpenGL ES analyzer in Instruments while browsing similar neighborhoods at similar zoom levels, I average ~35fps in Google Maps and ~55 in Apple Maps. Not terribly surprising though - Apple Maps would have access to all the private APIs that AppStore apps can't use.
- jan_g 14y agoIt seems that he is talking about how fast new map data/tiles download and display when you are scrolling/zooming the map.
- ghshephard 14y agoI've been playing with it for about an hour - and I think one of the interesting tricks that the Google Maps plays is that, in addition to making aggressive use of cacheing (which the IOS 6 map application does as well) - The Google Maps displays low-resolution version of the map you are moving into, before display the high res. The IOS 6 Maps app tends to display a blank background, so you may be more aware that the entire map hasn't been displayed. It will be interesting to see if there is any server impact, as millions of people start using this Map Application tomorrow. (In both directions - it may be the case that the Apple Map servers will see a drop in use, and increase in performance)
- nicholassmith 14y ago
- raldi 14y ago> Opening the side menu, for its matter, visually seems to depend on hitting a tiny tap target You can also get there with a two-finger horizontal swipe.
- therandomguy 14y agoI'm running into a single-thumb problem.
- 89a 14y agoSeems that Google can't program smooth animations even on an OS that was built with them in mind