2 ms·
In the rare cases when the minimum wage law changes behavior, unemployment is the typical result (see American Samoa's recent troubles, for example). Well, whi
by _delirium 14y ago
In the rare cases when the minimum wage law changes behavior, unemployment is the typical result (see American Samoa's recent troubles, for example).
Well, while we're exchanging anecdotes, we've got an $18/hr minimum wage here in Denmark, and unemployment is quite low. The main effect is that wages are more compressed than in the US. It does help that there's an aggressive upskilling program, so people automated out of a job get free education to move up to sectors with more demand.
One way of thinking of it is that a higher minimum wage, coupled with technological advancement and a strong education system, just accelerates the automation curve. Today's $10/hr labor will be tomorrow's automatable-for-$2/hr labor anyway. So people in those jobs are going to have to switch to something else in the near future. Why not automate 'em a few years earlier, and get a jump on both deploying new tech and moving people into something better? Then you can export the resulting tech, too.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm not referring to levels, but to rates of change. When the min wage was recently raised in American Samoa, large employers (e.g. Chicken of the Sea) immediately made plans to shutter their facilities and replace humans with machines. Why not automate 'em a few years earlier, and get a jump on both deploying new tech and moving people into something better? Because it would be more efficient to invest in automating other processes? Suppose you have two processes - one process (call it A) costs a human $12/hour, another (B) costs a human $6/hour. You only have enough money to invest in automating one. It's obviously more efficient to automate A. If the minimum wage is raised to $12/hour, then the market signal to automate A preferably to B is lost.
- heynk 14y agoGood point, but that also assumes the cost to automate A and B is the same
- PeterisP 14y agoJob A costs 8+ human hours a day, and Job B costs 8+ human hours a day for something that doesn't really deserve a human at all; simply some humans are so desparate that they need to do it. The market signal is intentionally changed from "automate A preferably to B" to "it will make financial sense to automate both A and B, do it".
- _delirium 14y agoYes, I think that is the likely outcome if availability of capital is not the constraining factor. And my read of the U.S. economy is that availability of capital is not the constraining factor currently: lots of companies are sitting on huge piles of cash that they don't know what to do with. So they'd happily automate any A or B if it made financial sense to do so, i.e., if ratio of labor cost to robot cost favored the robots.