3 ms·
Do the people actually benefit in that situation? When a business closes up shop, do other businesses naturally expand their labor force in a linear manner to
by jlgreco 14y ago
Do the people actually benefit in that situation? When a business closes up shop, do other businesses naturally expand their labor force in a linear manner to provide new jobs for the ones that were lost? Ideally the competing businesses will easily expand of course, since they have less competition after their competitor dropped out, but is that expansion linear?
I suppose for some types of jobs it may be. If a coffee shop closes, and it's competitor opens another branch to soak up the extra demand, the additional coffee shop will probably use approximately the same number of employees as the old one fired. But can the same be said of, say, factories? What if the second factory, while filling the same demand as the first, was more successful because it used more effective automation?
- krapp 14y agoThat is a fair point. But what's the benefit in lower wages across the board, to the workers making them and to the economy? Perhaps the answer (at least in the US) would be to reduce the cost of reeducation to facilitate transition, and socialize healthcare? Lower wages might not be so bad where healthcare and education don't represent potential lifetime burdens for people. But then the tax burden for that would fall disproportionately on the poor wouldn't it? And also, there might just not be jobs at all to replace the ones lost. I don't know.
- jlgreco 14y agoFree education and healthcare definitely seem like good first steps to improving the situation to me. Letting the prospective workers be as smart and as healthy as they care to make themselves seems to have no obvious downsides to me. With any luck that would create an expanded middle class that could be taxed to pay for it. The trend of people squandering their education and ending up in low paying jobs anyway disturbs me, but I think that could be solved by offering only majors that are in demand for free. Free STEM and medical sciences would be my initial suggestion, but I would want to see any decision like that backed up with some solid data (perhaps the data would reveal my concern is unfounded).