7 ms·
As I've said on HN before, Wikipedia is a lie. The façade says "come and contribute!" The actual operation of the site is no longer like that. There has been
by jacques_chester 14y ago
As I've said on HN before, Wikipedia is a lie.
The façade says "come and contribute!"
The actual operation of the site is no longer like that. There has been a total inversion of the premise.
Wikipedia should have an anti-deletion bias.
There. I said it.
It should take a massive number of people to delete a page. Hundreds. Thousands maybe. Some particular amount of registered users (5% say, or double the square root. Whatever).
- tptacek 14y agoThis is a series of radical assertions each presented without evidence. Anyone who spends serious time on Wikipedia could tell you immediately what the site would be like if it required "hundreds" of people to delete a page: completely overrun with spam and vanity pages --- not about BBS door games or individual BBS's or open source authors or even bloggers, but about individual local little league teams, bands that have never played gigs or released tracks, marketing professionals, individual episodes of fake TV shows, attempts at defaming individual high school girls, 6th place finishers in city council elections, political parties with one member, "microbrew" beer pages for each of some guy's homebrew projects, made up cities in made up countries as part of some guy's counterfactual world history, repeat all previous entries in this list for each of Japan, England, Belgium, and South Africa, amateur open-mic-night standup comedians, individual bootlegged videos of concerts, "one of the 100 most influential Chinese-Canadians in British Columbia", individual unpublished short stories, as-yet-unreleased new energy drinks from as-yet-unstarted startups, 9000 pages about individual aspects of the Ron Paul campaign, film festivals from towns in Nebraska with fewer than 5000 people, repeat all previous entries in this list 10 times over the course of a year with slightly permuted names, fake professors at real universities, real professors occupying fake posts at fake universities, 46 different theories of cold fusion, fake cancer cure, fake cancer cure, fake cancer cure, fake cancer cure, fake cancer cure, world championship players from nonexistant Starcraft leagues, aspirational pages about made-up video games, individual authors of self-published ebooks, and of course, 1-5 pages about every single company incorporated in every US state. In other words: exactly what you'd expect from an "encyclopedia that anyone in the world can edit". The site would be every naysayer's 1999 prediction for what Wikipedia would become.
- Goronmon 14y agoAside from spam and pages that exist merely to advertise products/companies/etc, it seems like most are those examples aren't necessarily bad, and if no one is using the articles, it's not like a huge number of static text/image pages are going to be a massive drain on resources. Perhaps the answer to this is to allow for "personal" wiki pages that can be approved for inclusion into the main body of Wikipedia. From my perspective, I would rather have lots of extra fluff in Wikipedia that I will never see rather than whole subjects being deleted from the site on the whims of a few jerk admins. Edit: And you seem to be defending the deletion of BBS history under the guise that "Else spam would be everywhere!" which isn't an argument I agree with.
- tptacek 14y agoFirst, I'm not "defending the deletion of BBS history". It's telling that merely trying to put what's happening on Wikipedia in any kind of balanced perspective counts as taking a side here; it shows how artificially polarized this issue is. Second, there are clear practical reasons why it would matter if the examples I provided survived as Wikipedia articles: * The overall perception of Wikipedia's reliability --- which, in reality, is comparable to that of Britannica's for most subjects, and particularly for subjects that are important in the context of traditional encylopedias --- would be sharply diminished. * The encyclopedia would be full of overtly false information, since no contributor to the project would be able to verify any of the information in those articles. * Wikipedia would be ruthlessly gamed to get pages to the top of Google SERPs (it already is, and a lot of deletionism over startups and individual people is a reaction to that). * The project would lose huge amounts of time to mediating squabbles over article name real estate as different garage bands or local volleyball teams argued over which should be the first listed name for their project.
- enoch_r 14y agoThe problem with the unused articles is slightly subtler than "it will use up our hard disk space!" A friend of mine recently created a Wikipedia article for one of her own economic theories. She is not an economist, and as far as I know has never studied economics. The theory is loosely based on the work of one economist, but the sources she listed included her own blog, that economist's work, and newspaper articles--not articles about "the XYZ Theory," but articles about events she believes are relevant to her theory. But the end result was a reasonably well-written article, with plenty of linked citations (which would appear relevant to anyone not paying close attention), about a theory that does not exist. And because the article got so little traffic, she was the only one editing it. The thing is, when she linked to that article from her blog and social media profiles, and from other tangentially related Wikipedia articles, suddenly that theory seemed to have some validity that it hadn't had before. And googling "XYZ Theory," which would have gotten 0 results the day before, now got a handful of results. All of them were related to that article or her blog, of course, but someone casually searching for information might just click through to the Wiki article without noticing. The point is, articles about non-notable topics aren't just irrelevant. They're of much lower average quality than the rest of Wikipedia because they have much less traffic and many fewer potential editors knowledgable about the topic. They're more likely to have factual inaccuracies, more likely to be biased, more likely to just suck. And it'd dramatically reduce the confidence one could have in any Wikipedia article about anything one hadn't heard of before, because you might be its first viewer.
- ahelwer 14y agoOh, this whole song and dance thing again. I have no idea where on Wikipedia this is a problem. Since this is Hacker News, I humbly request than you expand your stomping grounds to include articles on algorithms. Coverage and quality is woefully inadequate, and I've yet to see the tracks of a deletion brigade running through any of them. Also, I've found learning then explaining algorithms is a wonderful way to retain them long-term. Benefits all around.
- chc 14y agoIf coverage and quality is woefully inadequate, that means people haven't been doing much with them, so of course nobody is going around harassing these nonexistent people. Only pages that people are actually interested in get the jerk brigade's attention.
- mjn 14y agoWhat editors are interested in and what's important isn't necessarily the same, though. I try to focus my efforts on areas with the lowest ratio of editors to value of the content. I find that provides a much better effort-to-results ratio than trying to throw in my $0.02 on Israel-Palestine with 100 other people. It also leads to more pleasant colleagues, because when I'm writing about ancient Greek archaeological sites or mathematical theorems, my co-editors are typically other idealistic people who genuinely want to improve the Wikipedia articles on those subjects. If you're writing on something political, then a lot of your co-editors are going to be people with political agendas. On contentious areas where a lot of people are interested and strongly disagree, I'm not really sure how to do it better. Wikipedia is often suboptimal, but so is the opposite, "expert-based" model. I'm an academic, and if you get bunch of us in a room, from different strongly opposed viewpoints, and ask us to try to come up with a consensus survey article, that experience is usually going to end up being painful. I think I'd actually rather wade into a Wikipedia edit war than serve on those kinds of document-writing committees.
- chc 14y agoIt's not just political "hot button" topics. No matter how innocuous the topic, if somebody takes notice of it, you'll often find yourself constantly having to fight random people — who are not the normal contributors to the articles — over stupid legalistic crap. This article with five sections and 20 references should really be a short subsection of that article because, well, he likes shuffling things around; another one should be deleted because the guy has never heard of it and most of the publications that covered it are online-only, etc. If your particular niche has avoided this, bully on you. But I personally wouldn't want to join it, because if more people come on board, that means more attention and thus (in my mind, at least) greater likelihood of attracting the wikilawyers.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoYep. I once had a page deleted within a minute or two after creating it for (as I recall) "duplication" and "not enough content". It wasn't a duplicate at all (it was about a metalworking tool that might look superficially similar to a woodworking tool, if you don't know anything about tools, which the editor didn't), and one reason there wasn't enough "content" was that I was still uploading the original images that I'd shot myself specifically to illustrate the article. I did get the delete rolled back, but got chided for "incivility" along the way (funny, I would have thought that deleting someone else's work when you don't have a clue about the topic of the article would count as "uncivil"). I lost enthusiasm for contributing to Wikipedia after that and haven't done much there since. Occasionally I correct minor-yet-annoying spelling errors, but that's about it.