3 ms·
Anybody competent enough to build a system like this, even somewhat smaller units thereof, is more than clever enough to see the forest despite the trees and re
by angersock 14y ago
Anybody competent enough to build a system like this, even somewhat smaller units thereof, is more than clever enough to see the forest despite the trees and recognize that their work could be used for bad purposes.
Again, let's not argue over defense contractors or some damn fool thing--when you work for Google, when you work for AT&T, when you work for Palantir or HBGary or whoever, you don't get to say "lol not my department I made swing apps and file dialogs" when you find out they've done something bad.
We need to speak out when people work on harmful technologies.
- peterwwillis 14y agoWhat's one of the "bad purposes" you're talking about, anyway? What's the threshold of "badness"? How do you define what is worth quitting your job, and what might merely annoy a user? Can you even quantify it? Is it illegal, and where? What is 'it', anyway? I'm talking about things like identifying if somebody is gay or republican or kinky and using the information for profit. Aside from selling it to background-check websites and the like, and the fact that it's information people willingly give up about themselves to entities unknown, I have trouble understanding how you can be so offended you think people should lose their jobs rather than develop potential parts of a potential system that could maybe harm someone at some point. Your assumption about the "cleverness" of developers is misguided. If a guy is told to write a small piece of code which simply takes HTTP requests from JavaScript and plugs it into a database, there is no idea what the fuck that could be used for. The guy maintaining the database also may not know what the fuck he's looking at, it may just be numbers. Are you really so willfully ignorant as to believe every single outcome of every single human action is cut & dry?
- angersock 14y agoHave you ever read "Scroogled" by Cory Doctorow or Stallman's "The Right To Read"? Both are a bit absurd at first glance but viewed today seem oddly prescient. I'll even accept your assertion (for the sake of argument only, mind you!) that engineers at a company might only work on some small fragment of JS munging numbers in a database. At some point, though, an engineer needs to implement the API for a saleable product using that information, or code up a dashboard with element names like "#user-site-history" or "#tracked-profile-visits", or at the very least see the marketing materials the sales folks use to show that the product is competitive due to this information gathering. Your assertion makes publicity even more important--eventually, some engineer or admin is going to have to get their hands dirty and that is when they need to speak out. ~ To go back and answer your "so what if we have targeted advertising" directly: there is currently no heavily established legal framework of which I am aware that protects metadata about users gathered for the purposes of advertising. I do not know if Google or Facebook is prevented from giving up (for whatever reason!) the results of their ad engine's analysis of user browsing to anyone at a whim. We (Americans, at any rate) are very lucky that our government at least goes through the motions of liberty enough to not overtly round up deviants and send them off to the camps or send drones after them--this is far from the case in various other countries. As far as the idea that the information is given up willfully, we're talking about techniques and technology that are really only ten or fifteen years old...the average consumer has not had time to build up any sort of reasonable intuition about what they are sharing or not sharing, or how that information can be linked to other facts about their lives. To say that they've "willingly" given up this information is, I suggest, somewhat misleading.