3 ms·
This argument is terribly fallacious. "Managing" is extremely important to value creation. A fundamental principle of capitalism is that you can use existing w
by swombat 18y ago
This argument is terribly fallacious.
"Managing" is extremely important to value creation. A fundamental principle of capitalism is that you can use existing wealth ("capital") to invest in ways to create more wealth. Capitalism relies on people's self-interest to ensure that each investor will invest in the opportunity that has the most value-creation potential with the lowest risk.
Investors, people "managing money", aren't just sitting on the sidelines cashing in on everyone else's good ideas. Their essential purpose is to move available capital to wherever it will produce the highest returns - i.e. wherever it will produce the most wealth.
The total wealth of a nation impacts the wealth of everyone in that nation. I don't like the way republicans use the idea of "trickle-down economics", but the fact is, if you create lots of value (by putting money in the right place at the right time), that value inevitably spreads to many other people in the economy.
Managing money is not "taking a left turn into the deep end". Creation will happen in hundreds of different forms. Picking the one that works best and giving it life is extremely valuable.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoI wish we didn't seem to have a spcies wide blind spot when it comes to adopting risk. when people rail against successful money managers they are never looking at all the failed ones, thus ignoring the amount of personal risk involved. sure there are a few winners, but why do you want to penalize them for their success?
- pxlpshr 18y agoGood argument and I agree with you, but by my point is more focused on recent actions in regard to the socialization of risk and privatization of reward. My comment aside, I definitely appreciate the value of honest financial gurus. To your point re: the principles of capitalism, US is still very young and most institutional investments funds are not top performers longer than a few years. They are NOT the best for picking long-term winners, ultimately their criteria is governed by a 5-10 year exit. Let's not carelessly forget where capitalism can get it wrong — self-interest has done plenty of harm in man's time. What concerns me is that many of these "managers" are now on the 'creation' end of the "solution".