3 ms·
There's a bunch of details regarding LLMs and copyright, but I don't see how > They should be forced to publicly release the books as an Ebook. would be reaso
by streetfighter64 3mo ago
There's a bunch of details regarding LLMs and copyright, but I don't see how
> They should be forced to publicly release the books as an Ebook.
would be reasonable in any way? The books aren't theirs to release publicly. If I brought a copy of any given movie on DVD, ripped it and used it to train my own "LLM" located at /dev/null, should I then be allowed (or even forced) to release the movie publicly for anyone to watch for free?
- cj 3mo agoThe alternative (throwing books away for no good reason) isn't much more reasonable.
- pfdietz 3mo agoIt happens on a massive scale, so it's completely reasonable. Books are disposable information delivery vehicles now. Publishers pulp great quantities of unsold books too.
- streetfighter64 3mo agoWell, destroying them once they already exist is reasonable, but producing garbage (e.g. great quantities of unsold books) on a "massive scale" is completely unreasonable though. But that's a larger problem that encompasses single use packaging and all the other plastic garbage we're producing all the time.
- deleted 3mo ago[deleted]
- 999900000999 3mo agoWe’re in a brave new world now. If theirs reason to believe your destroying the last copy of a book( or another copy isn’t easy to obtain) then you should make a copy of it available. Set up a compensation fund for the rights holders. Anything is better than culture literally being sucked into the void.