3 ms·
It's a NoScript/Ghostery/RequestPolicy world. Sorry, but no, it isn't. Whether it's building their own PCs or running a custom Linux kernel or installing priva
by Silhouette 14y ago
It's a NoScript/Ghostery/RequestPolicy world.
Sorry, but no, it isn't. Whether it's building their own PCs or running a custom Linux kernel or installing privacy utilities or using three factor authentication with a telepathic failsafe for their security system, geeks tend to vastly overrate their collective importance. In reality, they tend to represent tiny fractions of any market that isn't specifically built around geeks by its nature. Most people aren't like geeks.
Now, suppose your new interactive web app doesn't offer a good user experience without things like JavaScript. Maybe you could make it work up to a point, but realistically it's never going to be a polished presentation or do everything the full app could. Now put yourself in management's position, considering the cost/benefit of implementing a second-rate fallback vs. allocating the same time and resources to improving the core experience for almost everyone. Can you imagine how little they care about geeks who deliberately nerf their own browsers in a way that means they couldn't use that service anyway and therefore aren't likely to pay the service provider money either?
(Edit: Incidentally, people in glass houses etc. Your own web site's home page, under the amusingly ironic headline "passenger: Rails deployment that just works", appears to be doing anything but working. HTH.)
- rhizome 14y agoIt does, thanks, though it's not my main concern. I'm not overrating (really, overestimating) anybody's collective importance, I simply think degradability is a good idea. When I said it was a "world" like that, it was that these things exist, and coupled with disability concerns I work accessibility into everything I do. What is the downside? What of a contemporary web app is impossible to degrade? As far as penetration of these plugins go, a comparison of Google Analytics numbers with raw logfile analysis makes that very clear.
- Silhouette 14y agoWhat is the downside? What of a contemporary web app is impossible to degrade? I think there are two major downsides. Firstly, there is the opportunity cost. Any time and money I spend catering to a niche group who choose not to support modern technologies properly is time and money I didn't spend improving the experience for everyone else. Secondly, a lot of web apps are about convenience or entertainment. Beyond a certain point, a degraded experience isn't quantitatively worse, it's qualitatively worse, possibly even to the point of effectively making the entire service worthless. As far as penetration of these plugins go, a comparison of Google Analytics numbers with raw logfile analysis makes that very clear. Yes it does. Having done that analysis for the businesses I run, the people blocking Analytics specifically are a small but noticeable minority, but the people blocking JavaScript entirely are noise, and quiet noise at that. Based on that data, when it comes to so-called graceful degradation, we are far more interested in supporting the significant minority of visitors who have older versions of IE that don't support things like HTML5 and CSS3 well than we are in supporting those who nerf a perfectly good modern browser. YMMV, of course.